A.A.Gruzdeva
State Establishment
"Dnepropetrovsk Medical
Academy
Ministry
of Health of Ukraine"
The state of periodontal tissues in the working of iron ore production
ABSTRACT
Relevance. Dental health of miners has
specific differences of the average of
epidemiological surveys, due to the distinct
negative impact on the tissues and
organs of the mouth of the
atmosphere of the working area. This is the basis for the development of major dental diseases, including
periodontal disease.
The aim of this study was
evaluate the changes of periodontal tissues, developing under the influence of a complex of factors of production of iron ore production.
Materials and methods. A clinical
examination of 368 workers
producing iron age
21-60 years with
different seniority in the
company. Indexed rating: PMA (Parma, 1960), GI
(Y.A. Fedorov, V.V.Volodkina,
1971), PI (AL Russel, 1956),
CPITN.The material for the study of electron-microscopic were the fragments of
gingival papillae of 24 workers in the age of 30 – 60 years, with working
experience of 5 – 20 years, which have been taken in the course of surgery for
medical reasons.
Results. Conclusions. Results and analysis of the conduct of clinical and morphological studies indicate a gradual increase in the prevalence of
signs of periodontal disease in miners with age and increasing
underground service. Clinical
observations have revealed weighting
of the pathological process and
the involvement of large amounts of tissue (it is mostly
about the generalization of the process),
as well as the growth of periodontal
disease with increasing length of service in hazardous conditions
of iron ore production. The results of morphological studies showed signs of sluggish inflammation of
the sclera, atrophic and destructive changes in the gingival tissue.
Keywords: working iron production,
periodontal disease, an index evaluation, morphological study.
Dental health of miners has specific differences from the
average performances of epidemiological studies, due to the distinct negative
impact on the tissues and organs of the mouth of the atmosphere of the working
area. By number of factors affecting the organism the mining industry is one of
the most unsafe industrial sector.
Working conditions in the iron ore mines are characterized
by a high degree of gas content in air of the working area, presence of the
corrosive dust and its sorption by integumentary tissues, extreme temperature
conditions, noise, differences in barometric pressure during ascents and descents
in/from a zone of iron ore development, stressful work conditions. To
everything mentioned above, working conditions are burdened by vibrations. It
was described an adverse effect of factors of production of iron ore industry
in the tissues and organs of the mouth [1 – 5]. Thus, with increasing of depth
of mines the air temperature and the barometric pressure are increasing,
amounting to 995 m 814-834 mm Hg at 27-30 C [4, 5]. Moreover significantly increases the dust formation and the
relative humidity reaches 98%. Accommodation of miners to extreme thermal load
associates with reduction of efficiency and productivity of working, systematic
stress of thermostatic systems of the body, suppression of general immunologic
reactivity, and as a result, increased morbidity [3, 4]. It is any exception a
pathology of the oral mucosa, hard tissue of teeth and periodontal [1, 6, 7].
As a result of the combined effects of industrial harmful
factors by workers develop occupational diseases of the respiratory,
cardiovascular and digestive systems, kidney diseases etc. Such deterioration
of general condition is the basis for the development of major dental diseases,
including periodontal disease.
Goal. To study changes of periodontal tissues, developed under the influence
of a complex of factors of
manufacturing of iron ore production.
Materials and methods. We conducted a survey of 368 workers (all
males) of underground workshops of iron ore mines of Krivoj Rog City which made
the main group for studying. Their distribution over the length of service and
age is shown in table 1.
Tabl.1.
Distribution of the
surveyed workers by age and
length of employment
|
Length of service (years) |
Age |
|||||||||
|
21-30 years |
% (of total) |
31-40 years |
% (of total) |
41-50 years |
% (of total) |
51-60 years |
% (of total) |
Total (abs. number) |
% (of total) |
|
|
0-5 |
21 |
5,78 |
7 |
1,79 |
5 |
1,31 |
|
|
33 |
8,88 |
|
6-10 |
12 |
3,17 |
43 |
11,64 |
18 |
4,89 |
6 |
1,72 |
79 |
21,42 |
|
11-15 |
3 |
0,76 |
50 |
13,57 |
60 |
16,39 |
12 |
3,24 |
125 |
33,95 |
|
16-20 |
|
|
39 |
10,67 |
63 |
17,22 |
29 |
7,85 |
131 |
35,74 |
|
In total: |
36 |
9,71 |
139 |
37,67 |
146 |
39,81 |
47 |
12,81 |
368 |
100 |
Among the surveyed workers dominated people with age 41-50
years with experience of working of 16-20 years (17.22% of the surveyed
workers). Less representative groups were 21-30 years with experience of 11-15
years (0.76%), 41-50 years of experience of max. 5 years (1.3%) and 51-60 years
with experience of 6-10 years (1.65%) and 11-15 years (1.72%). A control group
consisted of 79 employees of ground services (males) of the same industrial
facility, comparable in age, who have no exposure to occupational hazards.
The study was conducted adhering to the primary care
sequence using an objective assessment of oral hygiene and periodontal tissue
examination. The degree of gingivitis index was determined using a modification
of PMA Parma (1960). We determined periodontal index CPITN (Commun³ty Per³odontal ²ndex of Treatment Needs) - Index of the need for treatment of
periodontal disease, the recommended WHO epidemiological survey of periodontal
diseases. The level of hygienic condition of oral hygiene was assessed using the
index proposed by Y. A. Fedorov and V.V. Volodkina (1971). To evaluate the
presence and severity of periodontal disease we used periodontal index (PI)
A.L. Russel (1956).
We conducted electron microscopic examination of fragments
of gingival papillae by 24 workers aged from 20 to 60 years old with experience
of 5-20 years. he material for the electron microscopy papilla were taken in
the course of surgical procedures carried out for medical reasons (gingivitis -
32.27%, extractions - 56.61%, excision of the hood when perikoronarit - 9.12%,
and others). Fragments of the gingival tissues were fixed in 2.5% solution of glutaraldehyde
on the phosphate buffer (pH 7.2-7.4). Fixing of
1.5% solution of osmium acid and poured into a mixture eponidnyh resins. Ultrathin sections were prepared on a microtome
UMPT-7. The material was examined using an electron microscope
TEM-100 (Ukraine).
All data were processed statistically. Statistical
processing was performed PC IBM PC / AT using application package Statistica
version 5.5 for Windows 98.
Results and their
discussion.
Comprehensive clinical examination showed that the inflammatory and
degenerative-inflammatory processes in periodontal tissues occur in the first
years of working on the production of iron ore.
Patients who formed a core group gave minor complaints
about violations of the periodontal complex. However, an objective examination
detected changes of the oral mucosa, which apply to all periodontal tissues
(destruction of ligaments, bone resorption, etc.). Important, in our view, is
the fact that there was a tendency to the appearance of generalized periodontal
disease. Developing chronic processes had a dim clinic picture and meager
clinical symptoms.
Table 2 shows the results of research on the state of
periodontal tissues in miners of different ages and people not working in the
mining industry (the comparison group).
Table 2
Dynamics of periodontal
indices in miners
|
Indices |
Age |
|||||||
|
21-30 years |
31-40 years |
41-50 years |
51-60 years |
|||||
|
basic |
comp. |
basic |
comp. |
basic |
comp. |
basic |
comp. |
|
|
GI |
2,76±0,45** |
2,27±0,41 |
2,81±0,52** |
2,29±0,43 |
2,97±0,56** |
2,03±0,39 |
2,98±0,31 |
2,14±0,19 |
|
ÐÌÀ (%) |
47,03±1,07 |
32,12±0,9 |
53,32±2,1 |
41,27±1,3 |
56,42±1,8 |
46,19±2,0 |
60,56±2,4 |
54,32±2,6 |
|
CPITN |
2,52±0,44** |
1,87±0,35 |
2,75±0,15* |
1,69±0,8 |
2,82±0,53** |
1,92±0,36 |
2,88±0,17 |
1,97±0,43 |
|
PI |
2,19±0,31 |
1,36±0,23 |
2,22±0,41** |
1,41±0,27 |
2,64±0,18 |
1,57±0,13 |
2,85±0,52** |
1,27±0,22** |
Note: * significant differences
between the study and control groups (p <0,01);
** Comparison group differences were
statistically significant (p <0,05).
Hygienic index (GI) of a core group of workers of all ages
has more than 2.6 points, indicating the absence of regular oral care and talks
about poor levels of hygiene.
By the workers, of the
primary and control groups of all ages, we recorded gingivitis of varying
severity - mainly mild to moderate. In the main group PMA index of 1.46 times
the data of the control group aged 21-30 years old, 1.22 times in 41-50 years,
and 1.11 times in 51-60 years.
Periodontal Index (PI) among workers who formed the main
group at the age of 21-30 years points to the formation of irreversible changes
in periodontal tissues and 1.6 times higher than the PI control group [8]. CPITN
index had significant differences in workers and control group.
The analysis of the data is the evident that there is a
gradual increase in the prevalence of signs of periodontal disease in miners
with age, and corresponds with the increase of work experience in underground
service. It should be noted, the weighting of the pathological process and
involving large amounts of tissue (it is mostly about the generalization of the
process) as well as the growth of periodontal disease (gingivitis of varying
severity, periodontitis) with an increase in part-time work in hazardous
conditions, iron ore production and the age of the surveyed workers.
The analysis obtained by
electron microscopic examination of the data, testified about certain changes
in the epithelial cells of the gums in miners.
First
of all, attention was drawn to the status of cell-cell contacts. In many fields
of vision they looked tight all over plasmolemma, however, almost universally
observed sections loosening of intercellular contacts which takes the form of a
more or less wide band of average electron density, which is sometimes
accompanied by a loss of definition of contours cytoplasmic membranes.
In
some cases, the nucleus of epithelial cells had the scalloped shape, sometimes
with deep appendages, or, conversely, invaginations karyoplasm. Moreover, the
chromatin in the nucleus, was usually in the form of uniformly distributed euformy,
although in some cells nucleoli absent.
The
cytoplasm of epithelial cells was most homogeneous, moderate electron density,
containing a complex of a few well-developed organelles. Among them
prevailed mitochondria with moderately dense electro-optical matrix and the
more or less tightly packed orderly arrangement Christie. At the same time, almost everywhere there were areas
in which in electron microscopic studies reveal signs of inter- and intratselyullyar
edema. In such areas, intercellular contacts between
epithelial cells whose nuclei tend to have an
irregular shape, looked sharply
expanded.
Significant
changes have taken place in lie deep layers.
First of all, we pay attention to changes in the microvasculature vessels, most
of which looked paralytic expansion. It should also be noted that in almost all
cases, we observed the presence of expressed to a different extent of
inflammatory infiltration. There prevailed lymphohistiocytic elements with
almost no white blood cells.
Very
characteristic has appeared the presence of inflammatory infiltrate of mast
cells and plasma.
Finally, it
must be emphasized that in some cases in the material were areas with more or
less massive growths of collagen fibers. In these areas in a plurality were
observed fibroblasts with signs of high functional activity. Such areas indicate
a chronic flowing of inflammation.
Thus,
obtained by electron microscopic examination of the data indicate that the
examined miners, despite maintaining the overall organization of the epithelial
layer, and the underlying structures, there were certain changes in the
ultrastructure of the individual components of the gums.
Moreover, these changes were a mosaic pattern, and different portions were
expressed to varying degrees. In some areas was ultrastructure changes indicated
intercellular and intracellular edema mainly epithelial cells, other – had a
dystrophic nature and even destructive changes, indicating that the depth of
the lesion cell ultrastructure.
Conclusions.
After analyzing the data, we came to the following conclusions:
1) an increase
in part-time work in hazardous conditions, iron ore production is associated
with the development of complex periodontal disorders;
2) hazards of
iron ore production by increasing the length of service caused microcirculatory
disorders, the development of dystrophic and destructive processes in the gums
by working of underground halls of iron production.
Ëèòåðàòóðà:
1. Àíèôàåâ Ò.Ì. Ñîñòîÿíèå ïîëîñòè ðòà ó ðàáî÷èõ æåëåçîðóäíîãî ïðîèçâîäñòâà:
Àâòîðåô.äèñ….êàíä.ìåä.íàóê. – Ê.: 1971. – Ñ.25
2. Ãèãèåíà òðóäà è ïðîôèëàêòèêà ïðîôçàáîëåâàíèé â ãîðíîðóäíîé ïðîìûøëåííîñòè./
Í.À. Ìàêàðåíêî, Â.Ñ. Áåëåöêèé, Ã.Ï. Ïèäïàëûé è äð. – Ê., Çäîðîâÿ. – 1979. – 136 ñ.
3. ó㳺íà ïðàö³. Ìåòîäè äîñë³äæåíü òà ñàíåï³äíàãëÿä./
Çà ðåä.. À.Ì. Øåâ÷åíêî, Î.Ï. ßâîð³âñüêîãî. – ³ííèöÿ: Íîâà êíèãà. – 2005. – 552
ñ.
4.
Environmental
and Occupational Medicine. / ed. W.N. Rom 4th Ed. Philadelphia:
Lippincott Wsllsams & Wilkins. – 2007. – 1904 p.
5. Ñààðêîïåëü Ë.Ì. Ñðàâíèòåëüíàÿ îöåíêà çäîðîâüÿ ðàáî÷èõ ãîðíîðóäíîé
ïðîìûøëåííîñòè // Ìåäèöèíà òðóäà è ïðîìûøëåííàÿ ìåäèöèíà. – 2007. – ¹ 12. – Ñ.
17-22.
6.
Hunstadbraten
K. Bergverk oder tannverk. // Tidsskr Nor Laegefogen. – 1998. – S. 4691-4692.
7. Âèáðîïàðîäîíòàëüíûé ñèíäðîì. / Ïîä ðåä. Ò.Â. Íèêèòèíîé, Å.Í. Ðîäèíà. –
Ìîñêâà: Ìåäèöèíà, 2003. – 286 ñ.
8. Ïðàêòè÷íà ïàðîäîíòîëîã³ÿ / Íàóêîâî-ìåòîäè÷íå
âèäàííÿ// À.Â.Áîðèñåíêî, Ì.Þ. Àíòîíåíêî, Ë.Ô.ѳäåëüí³êîâà. – Ê.: ÒΠ“Äîêòîð-Ìåä³à”, 2011. – 472ñ.