Sleta V.A.
2nd year student
Specialty:"International
law"
International Relations Faculty
Al-Farabi Kazakh
National University
Scientific adviser:
Candidate of Law,associate
professorTussupovaA.Zh.
Political representation of women in the Republic of Kazakhstan
Ensuring
equal rights and opportunities for all segments of the population to
participate in the political life of the country - a prerequisite and a
necessary condition for building the constitutional state. The struggle of
women for their political rights, especially for active and passive suffrage
(elective franchise), is one of the important problems in modern states.
Another thing is that granting equal political rights, that is, the proclamation
of formal equality of both sexes in matters of political decision-making, to
the de facto equality of opportunities in this area is still far.
The
term "discrimination" refers to infringement of the rights of the
state, legal or physical persons in comparison with other
individuals.Discrimination - is unjustified and unwarranted usurpation of the
right to critical and contemptuous attitude to others just because they are
different. In this regard, we should agree with the existing opinion that the
"sharp contrast between legislative changes and effective implementation
of these changes in life - this is one of the main obstacles to women's
participation in public life" [1, p.56].Discrimination against women
creates inefficient use of women's abilities and waste of valuable human
resources. In our opinion, the minority of women in power in decision-making,
reduce their ability to participate
in the creation of a just social society.
As
it is known, Article 7 of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of
Discrimination Against Women (1979) obliges States Parties to take all
appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in the political
and public life of the country and, in particular, to ensure to women, on equal
terms with men, the right:
a)
to vote in all elections and public reverends and to be eligible for election to all publicly elected bodies;
b)
to participate in the formulation of government policy and the implementation
thereof and to hold public office and perform all public functions at all
levels of government;
c)
to participate in non-governmental organizations and associations concerned
with the public and political life of the country [2].
The
relevance of the considered theme lies in the fact that in most countries,
including the Republic of Kazakhstan, this problem is still not solved.The
Platform for Action of the IV World Conference on Women (Beijing, 1995) noted
that many political parties and government structures continue to impede
women's participation in political life. In some countries, including those
where there are political, economic and social reforms, there is a significant
reduction in the number of women represented in legislative bodies.Persistent
gender stereotypes and discriminatory attitudes about the roles of men and
women constitute a serious obstacle to ensuring women's equal participation in
decision-making processes at all levels.
It
should also be noted that despite the adoption of resolution 1325 (2000) of the
Security Council, women are still not represented in formal peace negotiations
and peace processes, post-conflict peace building, recovery, reconstruction and
reconciliation [3].
Among
the factors that hinder women's effective participation in decision-making,
referred to the view of low legitimacy of women in public and political posts
and credibility. To them Another factor slowing down the process of effective
participation of women in decision-making is limited availability of
statistical information of the number of women involved in many spheres of
public life and the private sector. A significant obstacle is the lack of data
and information on the effectiveness and quality of the work of women in senior
positions in various policy areas.
In
this regard, we want to consider the political representation of women in the
Republic of Kazakhstan.
Referring
to the practice, it can be concluded that the different international
organizations (UN, EU, ILO) consider the problem from the point of view:
a)
human rights: women make up half of the population (in Kazakhstan - 51.3%) and
more than a third of the workforce. According to world statistics, every sixth
household isheaded by a woman. Their right to full citizenship and equality of
opportunity in employment should be implemented at all levels, including at the
level of decision-making;
b)
social justice, equality of all before the law;
c)
to accelerate the development, improve the efficiency of society.
The
Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan 1995, paragraph 2 of Article 14 contains
a provision that no one shall be subjected to any discrimination for reasons of
origin, social, official or property status, sex, race, nationality, language,
religion, convictions, place residence or any other circumstances. Based on the
scope of Article 33 of the Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan, all
citizens of the Republic of Kazakhstan have the right to participate in
managing state affairs, the right to elect and be elected to state and local
governments, as well as to participate in the national referendum, equal access
to public service [4].
Gender
equality is given much attention in the Concept of Legal Policy of the Republic
of Kazakhstan for the period 2010 to 2020 [5]. This concept aim is to improve
national legislation to ensure that Kazakhstan's legal system will be able to
compete in matters of convenience and reliability with the laws protecting the
rights of the developed world. The Concept underlines the growing role of the
factor of gender equality in political and public life, equal rights and equal
opportunities for women and men.
In
his message the President N.A. Nazarbayev on the 14th of December, 2012 "Strategy" Kazakhstan
- 2050 "- a new policy ofestablished state" emphasizes the need for
the implementation of gender rights and opportunities for men and women [6].
Currently,
in the Republic of Kazakhstan, women are more likely to take an active part in
public life and to stand as candidates for the civil service. Thus, according
to the Agency of Statistics of the Republic of Kazakhstan for the period from
2009 to 2015 all the central bodies of the female population among civil
servants was 54% [7; p.121-129].
In
many industrialized - developed and socially oriented countries women have
almost reached parity with men in matters of rights and opportunities, taking
an active part in social and political life of their countries. However, the
situation in the Republic of Kazakhstan for the period from 1999 to 2004isnot
allowed to talk about the happy situation in this area [8].
Taking
into account the importance and urgency of addressing issues of equal
participation of the citizens of Kazakhstan in political, social and economic
life of the country, Government Decree dated November 27, 2003 ¹ 1190 approved
the Concept of Gender Policy in the Republic of Kazakhstan (repealed
30.09.2010). This concept defines the main directions of gender policy in our
country - to achieve a balanced participation of men and women in power
structures, ensuring equal opportunities for women's economic independence, to
create conditions for equal enjoyment of rights and responsibilities in the
family, freedom from gender-based violence.
Addressing
the gender issue by the Decree of the
President of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 29, 2005 N 1677 approved
the Strategy on Gender Equality in Kazakhstan for 2006-2016 [9], in which the
implementation of measures aimed at ensuring gender equality in all spheres of
social and political life of our
republic. Began in this regard, each section of the Strategy has been included designed together with
the regional office of the UN Development Fund for Women (UNIFEM) indicators on
gender equality in politics, economy, education, family, health issues and the
prevention of violence against women and children.
Speaking
in 2009 at the V Forum of Women of Kazakhstan, took place under the sign of the
tenth anniversary of the National Commission for Women Affairs, Family and
Demographic Policy, N. Nazarbayev stressed that at present in our country, is"developed and began to act a whole
layer of gender legislation" [10 ].
In
the above Gender Equality Strategy of the Republic of Kazakhstan was given the
task - to achieve 30% representation of women among the heads of state bodies.
After the adoption of the above documents more than 40 women's organizations in
Kazakhstan raised the issue before the Government and the President of the
Republic of Kazakhstan on the introduction of women's constituencies and 30% of
quota at all levels of government.
In
the Republic of Kazakhstan, there was widely used the post-Soviet space
"gender hierarchy" of power, where women are presented on the lower
and middle levels, but virtually are absent in high positions (at the level of
decision-making).
In
this regard, the President instructed the Government together with the Administration
of the President, the National Commission (for family and women), the
leadership of the party "NurOtan" to develop a concrete action plan
to 2016 to promote women to decision-making level [11]. The Plan identified 16
key actions, such as the monitoring of civil service personnel from a gender
perspective, the definition of the main indicators of quantitative and
qualitative composition of women working at the level of decision-making in the
various fields of activity in the public and private sector, an increase
women's representation Political government positions to at least 30%, and
others, as well as the ways and methods of their implementation, designated
responsible agencies and deadlines.
Kazakhstan
is expected to change in the short term, the situation for the better,it will
be a benchmark for other countries where gender issues still remain in the
background.
In
2010,at the World Economic Forum, it
was noted that Kazakhstan was in the rating of gender equality ittook the 41st
place among 134 countries, and therefore, Kazakhstan is among the 50 most
developed nations, ahead of the 14 EU states.
According
to the annual report of the Global World Economic Forum on Gender Equality, the
Republic of Kazakhstan in 2013 was at the 32nd place among 146 countries of the
world. Our country is higher than all the countries of Eastern Europe and the
Caucasus, as well as France (45th), China (69th), Japan (105th). [12]
If
we look at the statistics, we can see that from 2012 to the present time, the
number of women in the Majilis of the Parliament of the Republic of Kazakhstan
and the civil servants of the Majilis of Parliament of the Republic of
Kazakhstan - 138 people, that is, 40.1% of deputies – 28women among them ,
i.e., 26.2%. In 2011, this figure was 15.9% (out of 107 deputies, the number of
women was - 17). In the Senate of the Parliament of the 47 deputies, 3 - women,
or 6.4% of the total. The number of women among the deputies of the 4
convocation, and was 3 of 47. The local representative bodies arealso
increasing the number of women MPs. In 2015 in the maslikhats of all levels of
the number of female deputies of the party members is 613 people or 18.4% of
the total number of deputies (3333 people). In 2012 this figure was 18% (624 of
3304) [13].
Thus,
we can assume that the presence of women in our country in representative
bodies from 2012 to 2015 has increased. There is a growing number of women -
leaders in the executive branch. So, 2of the 12 ministerial posts are held by
women - it is the Minister of Health
and Social Development of the Republic of Kazakhstan and Minister of Economic
Integration.
Executive
secretary of Ministers - 2. In addition, at present the number of women, deputy
senior officials: Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan -1; Head of the
Office of the Prime Minister of the RK-2; Ministers - 6; Prosecutor-General 1;
Chairman of the National Bank of RK-1; Deputy Governor of - 9, which represents
12.2% of the total (74) Deputy Governor of. At the same time there are no women
among the regional governors. There are also a large number of women - heads of
State and Legal Division 1; Center for Strategic Research and Analysis 1;
-department domestic policies - 1. Finally, we note that women hold the posts
of State Secretary and Chairman of the National Commission for Women Affairs, Family
and Demographic Policy [14].
At
this point the proportion of women is 60% (as of 01.01.2013g. It was 59%)in the
party "NurOtan", the party "AkZhol" - 52%.
The
judicial branch is also planned positive development: for the period 2013-2014,
the judges of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan, women accounted
for 40%; among local judges women - more than half (71.1%) [15, p. 129]. In
2015, among the newly elected judges of the Supreme Court - 17 men (53%) and 15
women (47%), among the local judges women - 73% [16].
Despite
the great work carried out by the Republic of Kazakhstan, most women (over 70%)
still point to the lack of political and legal equality between men and women [17;
c.5]. Such a trend in our opinion,isdue to the preferred orientation of women
in receipt of social guarantees, not on high earnings and career growth. In
this context, it becomes clear that it is the provision of social benefits in
the public service contribute to the consideration of women's public sector as
the most delectable version of professional activity.
A
similar situation is observed in the issue of active integration of women in
the political process, promoting them in the higher structures of power and
control. Political behavior of Kazakh women can be evaluated on the following
criteria: women's participation in organized forms of political life, that is,
they belong to political parties and organizations; the formation of political
attitudes and public opinion; electoral behavior. A detailed analysis of these
criteria leads to the conclusion that politics is still a man's business and
its appearance in the individual representatives is seen as a natural exception
to the rule, but not a natural phenomenon, even in the construction of
democracy [18].
At
the same time, the political participation of women can be manifested through
their participation in the elections, that is, in electoral behavior. In this
regard, the issue becomes important electoral behavior of women, their cohesion
and initiative, the ability of women to use the numerical superiority in order
to make their political preferences visible and, ultimately, contribute to the
advancement of women in the political arena.
We
note that in all prior elections of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan
itis almost always ran only men. This suggests that our society was not yet
ready to see a woman president as head of state. At the same time,
extraordinary elections of the President of the Republic of Kazakhstan carried
out in April 2015 presidential candidates stood for election in the Republic of
Kazakhstan 6 men and the first time - a woman. Perhaps women engaged in
politics, public service and in business is no real contenders for the post of
President of the Republic of Kazakhstan. In our opinion, Kazakhstan women still
need to have real opportunities for participation presidential elections, as
candidates, as well as men, and to be able to exercise their passive right to
vote on equal terms in accordance with paragraph 1 of Article 5 of the
Constitution of the Republic of Kazakhstan [19].
In
our view, the lack of information, lack of promotion of women's participation
in politics, the low level of political and legal culture reduces the motivation
of women to participate in the electoral process. Women's competition, as a
sign of sex, prevents women to join forces in a single constituency. Listed
means that women voters are still less stable, less united than male
politicians.
Based
on the foregoing, we consider it necessary to highlight the key methods for the
effective participation of women in political life:
a)
to promote the adoption of temporary special measures such as quotas, a
temporary exemption from the election assessments, access to state media,
access to public resources and sanctions against political parties that violate
the law, to increase the participation of women in elected and appointed
bodies, decision-makers in public institutions.
b)
to work on issues of voter registration in order to create opportunities for
women to exercise their democratic rights.
In
our opinion it is necessary to support
women's organizations of civil society to ensure the interests of women:
a)
To assist in the development of collective political programs, for example
through women's party or through national congresses of women. Despite any
differences between women, they may have common priorities of women: those
common priorities can relate to them the right to hold managerial positions or
their access to quality health care and child care. For women it is important
to coordinate their activities, create associations, to work together and
develop a common vision in times of change.
b)
to provide capacity-building and professional and methodical preparation for
the development of communication skills and conducting awareness-raising work,
as well as internal organizational capacity of women's groups and movements.
In
order to increase the responsibility for ensuring the rights of women in public
institutions, we offer:
a)
to monitor the fact that during the process of revision and development of
normative and legal acts were taken into account proposals of political, legal
and other government institutions, concerning the participation of women and
implementation of their social, political and economic rights.
b)
toseek to create accountability mechanisms by which public authorities will be
accountable for their implementation of national commitments to gender equality
and women's rights.
We
also believe that we must provide support women political leaders to increase
their influence. It is important to assist the candidates and elected leaders
to develop their skills and potential. This assistance includes the development
of professional skills (language skills and ability to lead a parliamentary
debate, skills advocacy), as well as get acquainted with information materials
on gender, international commitments on gender equality and the use of
different strategies. This assistance also includes the promotion of mechanisms
such as women's coordinating groups in the parliaments or women's network
(establishment of linkages for joint action: information exchange, direct
assistance, personal and professional support, such as the Network of Women "East-West"
- Network of East - West Women - electronic distribution network covering the
United States, Western and Eastern Europe) in the institutions of the civil
service, and creating state mechanisms that have the authority, capabilities
and position in the government, in order to act as an effective advocate of
policies in favor of women.
It
should be emphasized that it is necessary to raise public awareness about the
role of women in public life and in decision-making processes. Within the
framework of relevant strategies of governments or other authorities is
required, inter alia, to submit annually a publicly available information on
the number of women involved in all government structures.
Summing
up the results, it can be drawn the
following conclusions:
1.
The first step on the way to engage in active political position of women and
promote increased motivation to uphold and protect the political rights should
act ordering the interaction of the most active women's groups to engage other
women to participate in the political process. In other words, it is necessary
to influence the policy through the female electorate as the largest social
basis of democratic society.
2.
To promote women in the power necessary to overcome a certain mistrust of the
subjective part of the population in the ability of women to participate
equally with men in government. To do this themost effectively candidates
should manifest itself in the propaganda work with voters to prove to the
electorate of the importance of their presence in power, skillfully use
election technology, build the right tactics behavior.
Given
the situation, we propose the following measures to ensure the equalization of
opportunities for the access of women and men in political institutions:
1)
Changes and amendments to the electoral law that would encourage the expansion
of women's representation in the lists of candidates of political parties and
associations;
2)
Amendments to the law on the civil service, which would encourage the promotion
of women in the upper echelons of state power;
3) Formation of the female talent pool for the class of
higher civil service positions through special training programs, acting on a
permanent basis.
It
should be borne in mind that as long as the bearer of political rights
themselves are indifferent to the situation, the likelihood of the poor state
of political rights will remain at a high level. In the future, we need to
continue to implement measures aimed at eliminating the historical and social
conditions and factors that do not allow women and men to "play" by
the same rules. Equality - the end result, and it is achieved when legally
enshrined equal rights backed up by special social programs.
REFERENCES:
1.
Legal Encyclopedia / Editor B.N.
Topornin. - M., 200.- 1272 p.
2.
Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan
dated 29.06.1998 N 248-1 «On accession of the Republic of Kazakhstan to the
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against
Women"(18 December 1979)
3.
The conclusion of the fifty-third session of the Commission on the
Status of Women, 2-13 March 2009 - Paragraph 3 (a) (ii) of the agenda
4.
The Constitution of the Republic of
Kazakhstan (adopted at the national referendum on 30 August 1995) (as amended
as of 02.02.2011 r.) / "Kazakhstanskaya Pravda" on September 8, 1995
5.
Decree of the President of the
Republic of Kazakhstan dated August 24, 2009 ¹ 858 "On the Concept of
Legal Policy of the Republic of Kazakhstan for the period from 2010 to
2020" (as amended on 01.16.2014, the) / "Kazakhstanskaya Pravda"
dated August 27, 2009 ¹ 205 (25959
6.
Message from the President of the
Republic of Kazakhstan - Leader of the Nation NursultanNazarbayev to people of
Kazakhstan. December 14, 2012 "Strategy" Kazakhstan-2050 "- new
political policy established state" (Astana, December 14, 2012) - //
"Kazakhstanskaya Pravda" dated December 15, 2012 ¹437-438 (27256 -
27257)
7.
Women and men in Kazakhstan /
Statistical Yearbook / in Russian / Committee on Statistics of the RK Ministry
of National Economy. / Editor: A.A.Smailov -Astana, 2014 - 134 p.
8.
http://www.zakon.kz/page,1,1,4478163-v-kazakhstane-prodolzhaet-ostavatsja.html
- [Electronic resource]
9.
Decree of the President of the
Republic of Kazakhstan dated November 29, 2005 ¹ 1677 "On approval of the
Strategy of gender equality in the Republic of Kazakhstan for 2006-2016" /
"Kazakhstanskaya Pravda" dated December 3, 2005 N 333-334
(24943-24944)
10.
http://www.zakon.kz/4478163-v-kazakhstane-prodolzhaet-ostavatsja.html
- [Electronic resource]
11.
Order of the Head of the
Presidential Administration of the Republic of Kazakhstan ¹ 01-38.69 from
17.06.2011g. "On Approval of the Action Plan for the period up to 2016 to
promote women to decision-making level from among the best-trained women employed
in various sectors of society and the State" - [Electronic resource:
http://pandia.org/text/78/163 /88559.php]
12.
World Bank, World Development Report
- 2012: Gender Equality and Development. Washington, 2011)
13.
Women and men in Kazakhstan /
Statistical Yearbook / in Russian / Committee on Statistics of the RK Ministry
of National Economy. / Editor: AA Smailov -Astana, 2014 - 134 p.
14.
GOVERNMENT BODIES OF KAZAKHSTAN
(2015) - // Information system "Paragraph"
15.
Women and men in Kazakhstan /
Statistical Yearbook / in Russian / Committee on Statistics of the RK Ministry
of National Economy. / Editor: AA Smailov -Astana, 2014 - 134 p.
16.
http://kapital.kz/naznacheniya/46182/izbrany-sudi-verhovnogo-suda.html
- [Electronic resource: Appointments. Elected Judge of the Supreme Court]
17.
Vasiliev V. Following the example of
the older brother of the Turkish - // NezavisimayaGazeta. - 2002. - ¹ 156. -
S.5-7.
18.
Nysanbayeva A. Gender aspects of the
comparative analysis of the programs of political parties of the Republic of
Kazakhstan - [Electronic resource: http: // www.khassanova.kz]
19.
The Constitution of the Republic of
Kazakhstan (adopted at the national referendum on 30 August 1995) (as amended
as of 02.02.2011 r.) / "Kazakhstanskaya Pravda" on September 8, 1995
.