A.I.Musayev, S.T. Duysenbayeva, R.T.Turegeldieva
M.Kh.Dulaty TarSU, Taraz, Kazakhstan
EVALUATION OF FERTILIZING PROPERTIES OF WASTE WATERS IN SOUTHERN KAZAKHSTAN
Mechanical structures and then artificial
biological cleaning are not completely free from
sewage pollution. Not less 10-20% of pollution and under impeccable work
of treatment facilities the most persistent
organic compounds is remaining among them. Any violation of their work condition - overloading, poor maintenance, etc. increases the percentage of residual contamination
more. (Table1).
Table 1 - The degree of
wastewater treatment
|
Method of biological |
Degree of cleaning, % |
||||
|
BPK 5 |
Nitrogen (N) |
Phosphor ( Ð2Î5) |
Potassium ( Ê2Î ) |
on bacteria |
|
|
Artificial |
86,7 |
37,5 |
29,3 |
18,0 |
94,5 |
|
Soil |
94.3 |
81,6 |
96,6 |
76,7 |
97,1 |
|
How
many times soil cleaning is more perfect than artificial |
1.1 |
2,2 |
3,3 |
4,3 |
1,03 |
These
data also confirms the high efficiency of soil wastewater treatment. At the
same time in the fields of irrigation, recycle of municipal wastewater occurs
simultaneously with additional cleaning as a source of moisture and fertilizing
substances for growing crops.
Consequently,
under conditions of Southern Kazakhstan, wastewaters are not only a source of
irrigation water, but valuable fertilizer as well. It is estimated that
fertigation effect of urban wastewater in an amount 2000 m/h is equal to the 2
c. of ammonium nitrate, 1.5 c. of potassium chloride and 0.5 c of
superphosphate.It is also important that the wastewater nutrients are in
dissolved, well assimilable for plant and fed into the soil together with
water. The soil is enriched with nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and other
essential elements of plant nutrition.
Only
in domestic (urban) wastewater of republic, according to preliminary data,
10,600 tons of nitrogen, 3,600 tons of phosphorus and 9,500 tons of potassium
are contained, which more than 300 hectares of farmland could be fertilized.
Consequently, one of the main agromeliorative and ecological indicators under
agricultural wastewater utilization in pouring farmland is the evaluation of
their fertilizing properties.
As
there are two kinds of wastewater irrigation: humidifying and fertigation are
held by wastewater with high concentrations of nutrients (livestock, waste
water, and enterprises’ drains of the food industry).
According to the
developed world classification (WPC 32-2.2-86), fertilizing value of urban
wastewater, gone a full biological treatment with the content of nutrients:
nitrogen <50, Phosphor <10 and Potassium <30 mg / L - refers to the
low III group. We have been studying the fertilizing properties of Almaty
wastewater since1976.
At the beginning
of the research period (1976-1980 years) only mechanical cleaning was operated
at the city sewage treatment, after which the waste water was discharged into
the storage device of Zhamankum. During this period, the quality of wastewater
was investigated after cleaning constructions and in pond storage device of
wastewater in Burundaisk farms as well. (Table 2).
Table 2 - Fertilizer properties of Almaty wastewater (1976-1980 y.) and
after mechanical cleaning, mg / l
|
Item of sampling |
Nitrogen (N) |
Phosphor (Ð2Î5) |
Potassium (Ê2Î) |
|
After
cleaning constructions (mechanical) |
30,6-36,1 |
7,1-10,4 |
16,5-18,4 |
|
Storage
pond of Burundaisk farm mg / l /% reduction |
18,5-26,4 40-27 |
2,6-4,6 60-55 |
8,6-12,3 48-33 |
From
the comparison of fertilizing properties of wastewater after cleaning
constructions and in storage pond (accumulation period of 5-6 months is not
growing season) is seen that a storage pond was self-purification of nitrogen
to 27-40%, phosphorus - by 55-60% and potassium at 33-48%.
The
magnitude of COD was decreased from 200-250
to 33-55 mg / l BPK - from 119-150 to 17-43 mg / l. It is explained that the storage
pond together with water regulation, acts as a biological pond. However,
fertilizing quality of wastewater is remained in Category III. The station of
biological cleaning is put into operation since 1980. Indicators
of fertilizing
properties are shown in Table 3.
Table 3 – Indicators of fertilizing properties of Almaty wastewater, mg
/ l (after biological cleaning, 1986-1991 and 1999-2012 y.)
|
Item of sampling |
Nitrogen |
Phosphor |
Potassium |
|||
|
1986-1991 |
1999-2012 |
1986-1991 |
1999-2012 |
1986-1991 |
1999-2012 |
|
|
water divider |
21,4-29,2 30-20 |
10-16,1 65-55 |
4,6-6,1 35-40 |
2,2-2,8 70-73 |
9,4-12,6 23-32 |
7,8-9,9 53-46 |
|
Sorbulak |
26,8-27,2 |
16,6-26,8 |
6,8-7,1 |
2,7-6,8 |
13,0-13,4 |
8,8-13,4 |
Comparison
of the data table shows that after the biological cleaning, there is some
reduction in fertilizing properties of sewage: nitrogen - by 20-65%, phosphorus
- by 35-70% and potassium - by 23-53%. While there is a big difference over the
years. So, if before 1984 the cleaning effect of the biological station does
not exceed 50%, by 1995 it has reached up to suspended solids 95%, BPK - 92% by 2000 – by suspended solids - 96%, BPK - 89.5
and COD - 92.3%.
Improvement of
biological cleaning constructions and other facilities allowed bringing the
degree of purification to the desired level. However, as noted above, and in
these circumstances there is residual contamination by organic substances.
Table 4 - The loss of nutrients and organic mass at different methods of
wastewater cleaning (K. Stehlik, Czechoslovakia, 1972)
|
The
nutrients |
Decline
of nutrients, in% |
|||
|
By mechanical |
By mechanical,
biological |
By mechanical biological cleaning on biofilters |
In oxidizing canals |
|
|
Nitrogen, total |
10-30 |
25-45 |
40-55 |
10-50 |
|
Ê2Î |
0-10 |
0-10 |
0-10 |
0-10 |
|
Ê2Î |
25-35 |
35-45 |
not conducted |
|
|
Organic mass |
30-44 |
40-60 |
not conducted |
|
Loss of nutrients is noted in other
studies by various cleaning methods.
Table
5 - Comparative effectiveness of various methods of domestic wastewater
cleaning, % (E.I.Goncharuk, 1976)
|
Methods for cleaning up |
Diminution |
||
|
BPK5 |
Suspended solids |
Bacterial number |
|
|
mechanical |
30-35 |
50-60 |
40-50 |
|
Biological (on biological filters for activated
sludge plants) |
70-80 75-85 |
70-80 85-90 |
85-90 90-95 |
|
In the fields of irrigation |
90-95 |
90-95 |
90-95 |
|
|
|
||
Under comparing the amount of
nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium after cleaning constructions with its
quantity in Sorbulak lake’s composition (until 1988 Zhamankum storage device
was acted, which was stopped to be existed as the result of breakthrough of
wastewater into Kaskelen river) and in pond storage facilities of Burundaisk,
the amount of nitrogen and phosphorus is traced to be decreased and the
significant changes in content of potassium were not observed (Table 6).
Table
6 - Fertilizer properties of Almaty wastewater in various years of research, mg
/ l
|
Item of sampling |
Period |
Indicators |
||
|
Nitrogen (N) |
Phosphor (Ð2Î5) |
Potassium (Ê2Î) |
||
|
After
mechanical cleaning in diverting canal |
1976-1980 |
33 |
26 |
12 |
|
After
biological cleaning in diverting canal |
1980-1990 |
29,2 |
6,11 |
12.6 |
|
1990-2000 |
16,1 |
4,5 |
11,8 |
|
|
2001-2002 |
17,7 |
3,4 |
13,2 |
|
|
Lake Sorbulak |
1980-1990 |
27,1 |
6,9 |
13,2 |
|
1990-2001 |
18,2 |
0,55 |
12,4 |
|
|
2001-2002 |
15,1 |
2,5 |
11,6 |
|
|
Pond
storage device of Burundaisk farm |
1976-1980 |
23,7 |
3,2 |
10,6 |
The
significant reduction in fertilizing properties of wastewater in 1990-2000 is
connected with the closure of many industrial enterprises in Almaty. Reducing
the amount of nutrients in the pond of Burundaisk farm storage and Sorbulak
lake was occurred during the transportation of the waste water (to pond storage device of Burundaisk farm - 20-25 km to Sorbulak lake - about
100 km) (4).
Under
these conditions, conveying collector is peculiar cleaning construction,
wherein the waste water is flowing through it, it is better stirred and
increases its dispersion, a number of organic compounds are exposed to
hydrolysis. In addition, tertiary treatment of wastewater in pond storage
device is flowing in conditions closest to the natural course of the pond
self-purification.
It
is folded from several independent and interrelated processes: mechanical
deposition, bio flocculation, aerobic oxidation, anaerobic decomposition,
methane fermentation, photosynthesis, etc.
Analysis and evaluation of fertilizing
properties of municipal wastewater in southern Kazakhstan’s cities showed that
they all belong to group III with low fertilizing value (Table 7).
Table
7 - Average content of nutrient in urban wastewater of Southern Kazakhstan, mg
/ l
|
City |
Nitrogen |
Phosphor |
Potassium |
|
Almaty
(after bio cleaning) |
33 |
14 |
12 |
|
Shymkent
(after mechanical cleaning) |
27 |
16 |
15 |
|
Taraz (after mechanical cleaning) |
38 |
15 |
19 |
|
Êyzylorda
(after bio cleaning) |
21 |
5,2 |
22 |
Fertilizer
quality of these waters in their content of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium
cannot have a significant impact on the improvement of soil fertility. Taking
into account the lack of nutrients in Southern Kazakhstan, irrigation by
municipal wastewater is recommended to combine with the mandatory introduction
of the necessary standards of organic and mineral fertilizers. Required dose of
fertilizer is calculated on the removal of soil nutrients by plants with regard
to their content in irrigation water and soil.
Wastewater
of JSC "Kazphosphate" is characterized mainly by an alkaline
reaction, low salinity (0.7-0.9 g / l); type of chemistry is unstable over the
years. Chemical reactions of wastewater reflect the feedstock, which water is
met in the technical industrial processes. Under the group of wastewater
suitability for irrigation, they are related to the third group, which requires
the flushing regime of irrigation by ensuring drainage with restricted cultures
composition.
Ratio
of cations is unfavorable; alkalinity of soils possibly refers to the
wastewater with low fertilizing value. Content of fluorine, total phosphorus
and solubility phosphorus vary within wide limits: fluorine - 2, 7 - 12, 1;
fluorine total 13.8 - 85.0; soluble phosphorus - 5, 2-62, 3. Content of
fluorine - outside of acceptable content in natural water.
Domestic
and industrial sewage of LLP "BM" are treated at full biological
cleaning constructions. The degree of BOD5 and
COD cleaning comprises 90- 95%, their contents after the cleaning construction
corresponds to dirty waters. After the biological cleaning, they are referred
to the second type of sulfate class (SO4-Cl-Na). According to the total salt
content (1.1-1.6 g / l), it is met the requirements of irrigation water and can
be used for irrigation of crops on all soil types.
According
to organic substances content (BOD5), it is classified as very dirty water. The
ratio of BOD5 and COD equal
to 0.4 is close to domestic waters, where the tertiary treatment must
expediently be carried out by soil-biological way. Development of
alkalinization process sodium is possible in watering according to ratio of
cations.
Maintaining
of wastewater after cleaning constructions in pond greatly improves their
quality indicators: salinity decreases by 2-3 times (0, 45-0, 51 g / l),
changing the chemical composition, the water goes to the hydro-chloride-calcium
waters (HCO3-Cl-Ca); the ratio of the cations varies in the positive direction.
Consideration of theoretical and experimental
researches carried out in different areas of CIS and abroad, was found that by
using of weakly mineralized municipal wastewater as irrigation water, the main
negative component negatively affects the geochemical regime of the soil is the
ratio of cations, especially in sewage of lake Sorbulak.
Increase
of sodium content (Na) in the irrigation water may help to displace calcium
(Ca) and magnesium (Mg) from soil absorbing complex and to increase the amount
of sodium in it (Na), so that there can be soil alkalinization process, but it
must be recognized that weak acid anions in the effluent are presented by
organic acids which, calcium soil is activated in an appropriate aqueous mode,
thereby it contributes to the improvement of water-physical and geochemical
properties of the soil.
Conclusions:
1. Urban wastewater is related to domestic waste waters according to the
chemical composition and their quality:
- Sanitary - hygienic and irrigation indicators of sewage are improved in pond
storage device in the process of natural course of self-purification under
influence of biocenosis;
- Urban wastewater is related to III
group with low fertilizing value and mandatory required standards of organic
and mineral fertilizers are recommended by using it in irrigated agriculture.
List of references:
1.
Novikov V.M., Kovaleva N.A., Ovtsov N.P., Dodolina V.T., Musayev A.I.etc.
"VSN 33-2.2.022-86 irrigation, MWR USSR, 1986.-85p.
2.
Stehlik Kare, Condition and prospects of research on wastewater irrigation in
Czechoslovakia / / Agricultural use of sewage: Proceedings of the VI
International Meeting of scientists from the socialist countries on the use of
wastewater in agriculture - M., 1972. - 170-186 p.
3.
Galchenko M.G., Zhelyazko V.I. Wastewater Irrigation. - M., Agropromizdat,
1988. -104 p.
4.
Musayev A.I. Formation of return water in water basins of southern Kazakhstan,
and evaluation of its suitability for irrigation / / role of reclamation in
ensuring of industrial and ecological safety in Russia: Materials of the
International Scientific and Practical Conference. Moscow, 2009. - 239 – 245p.