Amantayeva Ainura Malikovna, Dukenbai Gulzhannat amantayeva.ainura@mail.ru , gulzhannat0609@gmail.com
L.N.Gumilyev Eurasian National University, speciality “Foreign languages:
two foreign languages”, Astana, Kazakhstan
DEBATE TECHNIQUES IN ENGLISH AS A MEANS OF SPEAKING SKILLS DEVELOPMENT
Debate is a method of interactive and representation argument. Debating is
also carried out for educational and recreational purposes, usually associated
with educational establishment. This major goal of the study of debate as a
method or art is to develop the ability to debate rationally from either
position with equal ease. Debate has its own strategies and types. One of the
strategy that "debate can motivate students thinking, moreover, if they
must defend their stand or opinion which is in contradiction with conviction
them". This strategy can involve all students to be active, not only the
debate performer. One of the types in debate is competitive debate, this qualifications suppose that teams compete against each other and are judged the
winner by a list of criteria that is usually based around the concepts of
"content, style and strategy"[1]. According to this strategy that
“Competitive debating uses the skills of argument to debate and discuss
important issues about our beliefs, government policies and proposals on how to
improve the world or face up to problems in society. A competitive debate
should be rational, focused, and structured. Debating builds a unique
set of skills, helping students to analyze problems, think critically,
synthesize arguments and present these ideas in a cogent and convincing manner[2].”
Next
types is Role-play
debates, also help to avoid dualistic
debate models by assigning students to argue on behalf of different characters
in a situation. For instance, in the issue of national health care, students
could be assigned to various roles, such as doctor, patient, a wealthy person,
a poor person, a lawyer, a judge, an insurance company, the president, and so
on[3]. Through the debate of the issue from various points of view, the
students can broaden their understanding of the issue. Debate is different from other strategies. In debate, students are given
some topics to be discussed. One or two students would present their opinions
and facts concerning the topics. The next step, they response to the students
questions and comments.
Debate
is one of effective speaking activity which encourages students to improve
their skills. Debates are most appropriate for intermediate and advanced
learners who have been guided in how to prepare for them. Debate is a great way to improve the students’
speaking skills. It also allows them to do research and read more texts in
English. During the process, they can widen their vocabulary too. Most of all,
their critical thinking skills are enhanced. There are four major components in
English proficiency. This includes listening, speaking, reading, and writing.
Throughout the debating process, from the researching of issues, expressing
arguments, listening to opponents and hearing teacher’s feedback, all four
skills are given emphasis.
Students have to know how to use the basic
debate techniques in English classroom, such as style, speed, tone and
volume. Style is the manner in which you communicate your
arguments. This is the most basic part of debating to master. Next
one is speed, it is vital to talk at
a pace which is fast enough to sound intelligent and allow you time to say what
you want, but slow enough to be easily understood. Tone is what makes you sound interesting. Listening to one
tone for an entire presentation is boring. Volume takes important part when student has
debating. Speaking quite loudly is sometimes a necessity, but it is by
no means necessary to shout through every debate regardless of context.
There is absolutely no need speak any more loudly than the volume at which
everyone in the room can comfortably hear you. Shouting does not win
debates. Speaking too quietly is clearly disastrous since no one will be
able to hear you [4].
All speaking activities above encourage
students to practice speaking in classroom. Teacher should choose appropriate
activities above based on the level of the students. Every teaching and
learning process can be enjoyable if teacher gives the appropriate activity
based on students’ levels. Beside it the process of transferring knowledge can
be done easily. Debate is data in which people take up positions, sue arguments
and expound on their opinions on a range or matters; with or without some sort
of lead figure or chair person Based on the definitions above, it can be
concluded that debate is an activity in which students take up positions on
issue and defend their position. Debate is one of technique which has many benefits for students: 1) Improve students’
critical thinking. In debating, every student is proposed to analyze a problem
critically. 2) Develop students’ communication skill. Debaters spend many hours
assembling and practicing hundreds of public speeches on topics of national
importance. 3) Questioning skill developed in and struggle-often in the face of
disappointment and defeat[5]. 4) They are capable of making and defending
informed choices about complex issues outside of their own area of interest
because they do so on a daily basic.
In the learning process, debate has limitations
too. Firstly, debate technique only can be used for specific subjects, such as
subjects that are concerned with agreeing and disagreeing and giving argument.
Secondly, debate needs a long times for preparation. Much preparation is needed
in debating in order to make sure the debate runs well. Students should prepare
their arguments before the debate to make it easier for them to attack the opponent’s
opinion. Finally, it requires the students to be controlled in defending their
argument. Many students can’t control their emotion when they defend their
argument.
In
conclusion, the use of debate technique has been advocated in teaching speaking process.
Typically, debate is very interested to be implemented to improve speaking
skill. Students have a lot of opportunity to practice speaking and have active
involvement in debate. However, they worked very cooperative and tried to
defend their team, and they were more active to speak in classroom. Teaching
speaking through debate can be enjoyable experience for both teacher and
student. In fact, students can improve their speaking skill after being taught
by debate technique. It can be seen by students’ achievement in speaking test,
also it can be concluded that the studies
reviewed above all point to a similar direction. Classroom debate is an
effective learning strategy particularly because it promotes student-student
interactions. Obviously, active learning cultivates multifaceted thinking procedures
and develops maintenance, absorption, comprehension and appropriate use of
course content; as a result, learners benefit much when teachers make use of
educational techniques that encourage students’ active involvement. As a
result, participating in debate exercises must not be restricted to those on
forensics teams but must an experience offered to learners in a broad diversity
of university classrooms.
References:
1. "What
Is Debating?". Cambridge Union Society. Retrieved 2015-08-20. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debate
2. from
website: http://debatica2012.blogspot.ru/p/debates.html article:
Debatica2012
3. Goodwin, supra note 25 at 160; Schroeder, H.,
& Ebert, D. (1983). Debates as a business and society teachingtechnique. Journal of Business Education, 58,
266-269.
4. Kidd,
A. (2002). The oxford union rough guide to debating. The
English Speaking Union. Retrieved
August 26, 2002 from the World WideWeb:http://www.britishdebate.com/resources/hb_oxfordguide.htm
5. Bedir, H., 2013. Reading and Critical Thinking Skills
in ELT Classes of Turkish Students. World Applied Sciences Journal,
21(10): 1436-1439