Oleg
Skorba, Ph.D, The Chair of Accounting
and Audit of the State
Higher
Educational Institution “Ukrainian Academy of Banking of The National Bank of
Ukraine”
organization of THE audit of
production supplies
Abstract The article is devoted to the organization and methodology of the audit of
production supplies of the entity.
Keywords Inventories, material
assets, production supplies, audit of production supplies.
1. Introduction The
necessary condition for the production process of any entity is the presence of
production supplies in the required quantity and range.
The principles of
stocks accounting and disclosures in the financial statements are covered in
Accounting Standard number 9 "Inventory". In accordance with the
provisions inventories are recognized as an asset if it is probable that the
company will receive future economic benefits associated with their use, and
their cost can be reliably determined.
With
the purpose to ensure the effectiveness of accounting production supplies are divided
into appropriate classification groups.
Typically, the
entity's volume of operations with inventories is large, and the review process
is rather time consuming.
2. Analysis of research and publications The question of inventory audit of economic entities is the subject of
the works of famous authors: R. Adams [1], E. Arens [2] M. Belukha [3], B.
Usacha [6], K. Utenkovoyi [7]. Research activities involve both general and
specific questions in directions of performance audit. As for the existing universal
audit experience, it is huge, but it cannot be used without adaptation to the
current economic conditions in Ukraine, this fact explains the choice of
direction and relevance of the research.
3. Formulation of the problem The purpose of research is to outline the nature of the audit of an
entity’s inventories.
4. Results In accordance with ISA 200 "Objective and basic principles of
auditing financial statements" auditor is to express an independent
opinion as to the correctness in the reporting of information on production
supplies.
Basic principles of
the inventory formation in accounting are highlighted in Accounting Standard 9
"Inventories". Inventories - assets held for sale in the ordinary
course of business activity; are held in the process of production for sale of manufacturing
product; held for use in the manufacture of goods, works and services, and
management as well.
Inventories are
recognized an asset if it is probable that the company will receive future
economic benefits associated with their use, and their cost can be reliably
measured.
For
accounting purposes, inventories include:
- raw materials, basic and auxiliary materials, components and other
tangible assets intended for production, works, services, production and
administrative needs;
- work in progress in the form of uncompleted processing and assembly of
parts, components, products and unfinished processes. Work in progress at
companies that perform work and provide services consists of the cost of
meeting the unfinished works (services), which now is not considered income;
- finished products that are made in the company, intended for sale and
meet the technical and quality specifications set by contract or other legal
act;
- goods in the form of material assets purchased (received) and now held
for the purpose of subsequent sale;
- low value items used for up to one year or the normal operating cycle,
if it is longer than one year;
- young animals and fattening animals, products of agriculture and
forestry.
The unit of accounting for inventories is their name or homogeneous
group (type).
The purpose of
the inventory audit is to obtain adequate and sufficient audit evidence of
compliance with accounting laws and regulatory requirements, and information in
the financial and tax reporting is accurate in all material respects.
According to the
purpose, the main objectives of the inventory audit are to check the following
points:
- the reality of stocks;
- of property rights to stocks;
- accuracy of recognition and evaluation;
- accuracy and completeness of documentation of receipt, disposal and use
of reserves;
- reliability of analytical and synthetic accounting of inventories;
- ensuring quality stock holding in all areas of production;
- accuracy of the rules of use of inventory;
- adherence to rules and regulations of cost norms and availability norms
of inventory;
- the accuracy and reliability of the information presentation about
stocks in the financial statements.
During the audit of inventories the auditor operates in following
directions:
- obtaining accounting documents of the customer;
- familiarization with the organization of the warehouse and accounting
inventories;
- review of primary documents from revenue reserves and its reflection in
the registers of analytical and synthetic accounting;
- control of the actual cost of inventory and evaluation;
- verification of inventories used in production, for other needs and
reflection of these transactions in the accounting;
- check transactions for the sale of stocks;
- review of the inventory stocks and of display of its results in the
accounting;
- checking the measurement of inventories at the balance sheet date;
- validation of recording VAT on the acquisition and sale of stocks;
- review of the analytical, synthetic accounting, general ledger and
financial reporting for compliance and accuracy of information about inventories.
Accordingly the
objects of the inventory audit are: groups of stocks, quantitative and
qualitative acceptance of stocks from suppliers, as well as internal moving
between divisions of the entity, financially responsible persons, warehouses
and manufacturing.
In accordance
with strategy being developed according to ISA 300 "Planning" in the
preparatory phase the auditor evaluates the system of internal control of the
entity. Testing of the internal control system is presented in the table below [7].
Table
1
Test
of internal control of production supplies
|
¹ |
Contents |
Answer options |
Notes |
||
|
Yes |
No |
No Information |
|||
|
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
|
1. |
Does the storage of inventories comply with established requirements |
|
|
|
|
|
2. |
Are stocks that are in the warehouse
and in use fixed by those who are responsible for the storage and their use |
|
|
|
|
|
3. |
Are there contracts on the full material liability of employees
directly connected with the storage,
processing, selling (dispensing), transportation or use of in the production
process of
inventories transmitted to them |
|
|
|
|
|
4. |
Are the records in terms of accountable
persons
kept? |
|
|
|
|
|
5. |
Is the access to electronical information
on stocks restricted? |
|
|
|
|
|
6. |
Is the inventory of
production supplies properly conducted? |
|
|
|
|
|
7. |
Is the result of
inventory correctly
reflected
in the accounting? |
|
|
|
|
|
8. |
Are the unused portions of inventories highlighted with the sign Z? |
|
|
|
|
|
9. |
Did the reporting period include theft and damage to
inventories? |
|
|
|
|
|
10. |
Was the natural
attritition of inventories charged off according to norms? |
|
|
|
|
|
11. |
Were any stocks eliminated in the reporting period? |
|
|
|
|
|
12. |
Were extra wealth discovered in
inventories
accounted? |
|
|
|
|
|
13. |
Were illiquid and extra wealth discovered in
inventories removed from the register? |
|
|
|
|
|
14. |
Are certain types of sudden
inventory conducted? |
|
|
|
|
|
15. |
Is verification of data of accounting registers according to general ledger data conducted? |
|
|
|
|
|
16. |
Is the adjustment based on fixed limit-fence
cards with documents on expenditure conducted? |
|
|
|
|
|
17. |
Are the facts of charging off from damage and destruction
of stocks
controlled? |
|
|
|
|
|
18. |
Is the precision in calculation of primary
documents controlled? |
|
|
|
|
Having
fulfilled an assessment of entity's internal control, the auditor goes to audit
planning resulting in a plan of audit (Table 2).
Table
2
Plan
of production supplies audit
|
¹ |
The list of audit procedures |
Performer |
Verification period |
The period audited |
|
1. |
Comparison of residual inventory
according to the general ledger of residues in the accounting records |
O.Marchenko |
05.01.2015 |
01.01.2014-31.12.2014 |
|
2. |
Checking contracts on the full material liability |
V. Markov |
05.01.2015 |
01.01.2014-31.12.2014 |
|
3. |
Verification of compliance of invoices and sales invoices to the logbook |
O.Marchenko |
08.01.2015 |
01.01.2014-31.12.2014 |
|
… |
|
|
|
|
|
25. |
The formulation of the audit findings |
V. Markov |
20.01.2015 |
01.01.2014-31.12.2014 |
The general algorithm of production supplies audit can be
represented in Fig. 1.
Checking of
correctness of assessment Checking of warehouse accounting Checking of storage facilities![]()


Summarization of audit results
Fig. 1. The algorithm of production
supplies audit
The audit program
of accounting operations of inventories should include study of the
preservation of property, valuation of costs and capitalization, correctness of
evaluation of purchased property, use
of inventories in production, testing of operations with low-value items (IBE).
In the process of
verification it is determined whether all types of inventory have developed
standards, whether they are reviewed in case of changes in the conditions of
production and supply, who is responsible for the rationing of inventories.
During the audit
of inventory the availability and quality norms of material reserve based on
their needs for production according to established norms of costs, delivery
terms, calculated safety stock, if necessary, to minimization of inventory, are
analyzed. We analyze the quality norms of inventory, which, in particular, can
be made by calculation, using card-cutting or other methods.
In the process of
audit it is necessary to find out:
- what original documentation is used in the enterprise, whether it corresponds
to the approved form;
- whether the order of processing warrants to obtain materials from the
supplier and transport organizations is stored in the enterprise; is there a
system of control of warrants’ storage, use and their charging off;
- whether the control over correctness and timeliness of receipt of goods
on the basis of profitable documents is monitored at stores and in accounting
department of the enterprise;
- whether separate lots of inventories that are used in the process of
laboratory testing are taken for temporary safekeeping;
- whether the order of inventory internal displacing processes is issued
by relevant documents in the enterprise;
- is there the order of the transaction on release of inventories based on
contracts, invoices, consignment notes, tax invoices in the enterprise;
- whether the measures to control the storage of wealth are taken. It is
necessary to determine whether the director of the company appointed
financially responsible persons responsible for storing valuables, whether the
agreements on the full material liability are contracted with them;
- whether there are conditions for financially responsible persons for
storing inventories, or is there the room to store inventory, cabinets, safes,
etc.
- whether premises are equipped with fire alarm;
- whether there is a permanent commission for inspection of storage and
charging off of material inventories appointed by the order of the company
manager;
- whether an inventory and spot checks on supplies storage are conducted,
if their results are dated; what measures are taken towards the guilty in case
of shortage of stock, in what condition weight devices are kept.
During this
process the following things are investigated: completeness of stocks posting
on accounting data; their compliance with the quantity and quality according to
documents composited by material responsible persons and completeness of
posting inventories received without the accompanying documents. Fixing of
liability is tested according to contracts on the full liability concluded
between management of companies and individual employees; consumption rate of
raw materials for production and compliance. The soundness of adoption of
standards and their application is checked in fixed limit-fence cards and
spending materials cards; IBE, its use and integrity is checks as well. The
evaluation of acquired IBE, the cancellation of their value when transmitting
in service, availability of monitoring their use; original documentation of
accounting for inventories, which was investigated in terms of reliability of business
operations reflected in it are checked; accounting and reporting are checked as
well. The reliability of data movement and balances of inventories carried at
them; notes to financial statements are studied. We investigate information on
inventory valuation methods; the carrying (accounting) value of stocks from
separate classification groups; the carrying (accounting) cost of inventories
carried at net realizable value; the carrying (accounting) value of inventories
transmitted for processing on commission in pledge; the increase in net
realizable value at which inventory valuation is conducted according to p. 28
Accounting Standard 9. The reasons that led to the emergence of negative
phenomena, the amounts of non-productive costs are studied, persons guilty of
causing damage are found; shortage of values and losses identified in the
inventory, their validity and responsible persons are detected. The study of
other objects where damage is verified is summarized, it is checked whether its
size is confirmed by the accounting data and other evidence collected, how correct
the material liability of individual employees and the amount of its compensation
is established.
4. Conclusions Thus,
inventories is a complex category, the central feature of which for managerial
aims is the understanding of inventory as the amount of money invested in these
assets. Financial results of the company are directly dependent on effective inventory
management. Therefore the auditor should evaluate the current system of inventory
management in the enterprise and make proper conclusions and give
recommendations for its optimization that will help to increase the economic
benefits of the enterprise. To ensure the efficiency increase of control on the
level of inventories the auditor should develop and suggest a system.
REFERENCES
1. Adams, R. Fundamentals of audit [text] R. Adams; Translation with the
English. - M .: Audit: UNITY, 1995. - 398 p. - ISBN: 5-85177-011-2.
2. Ahrens, E. Audit [Text] /E. Ahrens, Dzh. K. Lobbek / Translation with
the English. - M .: Finance and Statistics, 1995. - 560 p. - ISBN:
5-279-01213-0.
3. Belukha, M.T. Course of the audit. [Text] / M.T. Bilukha - K .: High
School: LTD "Znanya", 1998. - 573 p. - ISBN 5-11-004719-7.
4. Volkov, O.I. Economy enterprise (firm) [text]: Textbook / Ed. prof. O.I.
Volkov and O.V. Devyatkina. - M .: INFRA - M, 2007. - 601 p. - ISBN
978-5-16-002990-0.
5. Pylypenko I.I. Audit. International Standards on Auditing in the audit
practice of Ukraine [Text]: Manual. / Under the general editorship I.I.
Pylypenko. - K .: LTD "Status", 2005. - 175 s.- ISBN 966-8544-03-X.
6. Usatch, B.F. Audit [Text]: Tutorial / B.F. Usatch. - K .: Znanya - The
Press, 2003. -223 p. - ISBN 966-7767-81-7.
7. Utenkova, K.O. Audit [Text]: Tutorial / K.O. Utenkova. - K .: Alerta,
2011. - 408 p. - ISBN 978-617-566-037-9.