O.I. Panasenko, V.V.
Parchenko, A.S. Gotsulya, I.V. Melnik, A.A. Safonov, V.A. Salionov, R.A.
Scherbyna, V.P. Buryak, N.A. Postol, T.O. Samura, I.M. Keithyn, S.N. Kulish,
Jul. Timoshyk,
Panasenko T.V.
Zaporozhye State Medical University
APPLICATION OF THE CHROMATOGRAPHY IN FORENSIC TOXICOLOGY
The father of
chromatography is recognized as the Russian botanist M.S.Tswett. He stated the
"chromatography" is a method in which the components of a mixture are
separated on an adsorbent column in a flowing system. In his original
experiments (1903), Tswett packed a fine powder such as sucrose into a glass
tule to produce a column of the desired height. After extracting green and
yellow chloroplast pigments from leaves and transfecting them to petroleum
ether, he poured a small volume of the extract onto the column. When the
pigments had formed a narron initial band at the top of the adsorbent, fresh
solvent (petroleum ether ) was added and pressure applied to the top of the
column. As the solvent flowed through the, column the individual pigments move
at different rates and were eventually separated from each other. The key
features of Tswett's technique where the application of the mixture as a narrow
initial zone and the development of the chromatogram by application of fresh
solvent. Others had emploed procedures based on the phenomena of adsorption or
partition, but these lacked Tswett's critical development step and therefore
did not yield effective resolution of mixtures.
Amongst many
subsequent developments. those A.I.P. Martin (1910-2002) and R.L.M. Synge
(1914-1994), who were awarded the 1952 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for the
discovery of partition chromatography [9] and of A.T.James and A.I.P. Martin
who developed gas-liquid partition chromatography [6], stand out [1]. Further
important work lay in the development of sensitive detector for GC.The
flame-ionization detector (FID) responds to most organic compounds,whilst the
electron-capture detector (ECD) shows an enhanced and selective response to
compounds containing strong electronegative moieties such as halogen atoms or
nitro groups. The nitrogen-phosphorus detector (N>P>D) also known as the
alkali flame-ionization detector (AFID), shows an enhanced and selective
response to compounds containing C-N bonds of phosphorus . In 1948 the Swedish
analyst A.W.K. Tiselius was awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for his
pionering work in developing electrophoresis. Capillary electrophoresis (CE) was
pioneered by Hjerten, who had built tube electrophoresis units by 1959 and went
on to demonstrate that free-flowing electrophoresis in capillary tubes with UV
detection was feasible.
Forgeston and
Lukacs [7] developed the first truly useful CE instrument and showed that it
had exceptional resolution. More resently, capillary electrophoresis and
related techiques have been used in the analysis of drugs and other poisons.
Chromatography
and electrophoresis have developed into a range of modes including paper
chromatography (PC), thinlayer chromatography (TLC), ion-exchange
chromatography, gel-permeation chromatography (GPC, also known as
size-exclusion chromatography, SEC), affinity chromatography,
gas-chromatography (GC), supercritical-fluid chromatography (SFC),
high-performance chromatography (HPLC), capillary electrochromatography (CEC).
CE and CEC are hydrin techniques whereas eluent flow is produced by
electro-osmosis.
In the 1950s
there was great emphasis on the development of TLC methods. At the same time,
research in liquid chromatography led to the development of various amino-acid
analyzers. These analyzers used columns made of styrene/ divinylbenzene
polymers that were derivatized to make strong cation-exchange (SCX)
materials.After gradient elution (changing the eluent composition with time in
a defined way) , the column eluate was mixed with ninhydrin, heated and passed
through a spectrophotometric cell and the absorbance monitored (570 nm). The
analysis of one sample could take 2 days. In PC and TLC, techniques that are
sometimes referred to as planar chromatography or development chromatography,
solutions of the analytes are usually applied as small discrete spots or bands.
The application solvent is evaporated before the edge of the paper sheet or
strip, or thin-layer plate, is placed in the liquid mobile phase, which is
drawn along the sheet or plate ( the stationary phase ) by capillary y action.
Several analyses may be performd in parallel. All the analytes are detected (
narmally visualized ) at the end of the development process.
In most other
form of chromatography, a sample is either added to the eluent, which may be a
gas, a liquid or a supercritical fluid, such as carbon dioxide, or placed on a
support material or otherwise concentrated before the eluent is introduced. The
eluent containing the analyte and other components of the saample/ sample
extract is then allowed or made to flow through or past a stationary phase
supported within a column. The mobile and stationary phases are chosen such
that different components of the sample different affinities for each phase. A
component that has poor affinity for the stationary phase will pass through the
column quite quickly, and vice versa. As a result f these differences in
mobility, sample components became separated as they travel through the column.
This process is called elution chromatography and analytes are detected
sequentially as they elute from the column. In both development and elution
chromatography sample transport is by continuous addition of mobile phase.
Various modifications of these techniques are possible, for example development
of a TLC plate in a second dimension using a different mobile phase.
There has been
continuous development in many branches chromatography and in CE since 1960s,
particularly in materials and in the refinement of instrumentation that has
resulted in the efficient, reliable and sensitive analytical methods that form
the backbone of modern routine laboratory analysis [2,4,5]. Manufacturers
catalogues and wed, sites often contain up-to-date information on newer
products, although important experimental details may be lacking.
Chromatograms, for example, may have been injected; in some cases the the
actual amount injected and the detector sensitivity may not be stated. As well
as the formal scientific literature, the trend to publications sponsored by
manufacturers or funded from advertising has produced same useful free
magazines, LC GC is probably the best of these.
Chromatographic
theory was studied by wilson [11], who discussed the quantitative aspects of
chromatography in terms of diffusion, rate of adsorphion, and isotherm
nonlinearity.The first comprehensive mathematical treatment describing column
performance in terms of stationary phase particle size and diffusion , was
presented by Martin [10]. However, it was van Deemter et al [12] who developed
the rate theory to describe the separation processes following on from earlier
work of Lapidus and Admunson. Gidding and Eyring [3] first looked at the
chromatography and from the 1960s onwards, examined many aspects of GC and
general chromatography. In the simplest forms of GC and of HPLC , the
stationary phase is simply a rigid material packed within a column through
which the eluent flows, but more usually the stationary phase is coated or
bonded directly to a column, or to particles of a rigid support material packed
within the column. In the mid 1960s, discussion of the parallels between LC and
GC suggested that use of smaller particles in HPLC would lead to better
efficiency, hence greater speed of analysis, and this better
sensitivity/selectivity. The problem with columns packed with larger particles
was the slow mass transfer of the analyte molecules into and out of the pores
of the stationary material packing made with smaller particles were thus
investigated to improve resolution. A range of suitably small particle size
packing based on 10 mm average particle size silica gels were soon introduced,
and work began on how best to pack these small particles to give efficient
columns.
Retention factors
(k), absolute retention times (volumes) and retention times relative to the
retention times relative to the retention of a given campound (internal standard) can be useful ways of
recording retention data in GC. However, the Kovats retention index [8]
provides a methodvof recording retention data that is independent of eluent
flow rate, column length, phase leading and operating temperature. Moveorer,
accurate measurement of to is not required. Straight-chain hydrocarbons are
assigned an index of 100 x the number of carbon atoms in the molecule )e.g.
decane =1000). The retention index of a given analyte at a given column
temperature is then calculated by difference from the retention indices of the
normal alkanes eluting before and after the analyte. Retention indices can also
be calculated from data generated on a temperature program applying the
following formula during individual ramps of the program: RI=
where:
RI=retention index of x.z=n-alkane with z carbon atoms eluting before x,
trx=retention time of x,trz=retention time of z and tr(z+1)= retention time of
n-alkane with z+1 carbon atoms eluting after x Many attempts have been made to
develop a suitable retention index system for HPLC using for example,
homologous series of alcohols, ketones or nitroalkanes, but in practice such
methods often no advantage over retention factor and other simpler ways of
expressing retention in HPLC .
SUMMARY
Chromatography
techniques, notably GC and HPLC, and to an extent TLC, are of unrivalled
importance in analytical toxicology as discussed in the following chapters, but
must be used with due care and attention to detail if reliable results are to
be obtained. An appreciation of the theoretical aspects of chromatography as
presented here is important in making best use of the resolving power or these
systems. Hower, SFC, once widely advocated for a variety of applications, has
been largely discarded.Capillary electrophoretic techniques too, whilst of
value in pharmaceutical QC and in separating enantiomers on an analytical scale
, at present have neither the sensitivity nor the mechanical strength to
provide a robust system for brass analysis.
REFERENCES
1.
Adlard E.R. Fifty years of gas
chromatography/E.R. Adlard//Chromatographia, 2003.-val.57.-pp 13-18
2.
Ettre L.S. Milestones in the
Evolution of Chromatography/L.S. Ettre// ChromSource, Franklin. T.N,
2002.-624p.
3.
Gidding I.C. A olecular dynamic
theory of chromatography/ I.C. Giddings, H.Eyring//I.Phys.Chem., 1955.val.59.-pp.
416-421
4.
Grob R.I. Modern Practice of Gas
Chromatography/R.I.Grob, EF. Barry//Wiley, 4-th edn., New York, 2004.-676p.
5.
Issad H.Y. A century of Separation
Science/ H.I. Issad//Dekker, New York,2002.-735p.
6.
Fames A.T. Gas-liquid portion
chromatography: the separation and microestimation of volatile fatty acid from
formic acid to dodecanoic acid./ A.T.Fames, A.I.P. Martin // Biochem. I.
1952.-val.50.-pp.675-690
7.
Forgenson I.W. Free-zone
electrophoresis in glass capillaries/I.W. Forgenson, K.D. Lukas//Clin.Chem.,
1981.-val.27.-pp.1551-1553
8.
Kovats E. Zusammenhange zwischen
sructur und gaschromatographischen daten organischer
verbindungen/E.Kozats//Fresenium Z. Anal. Chem., 1961 H.181.-S. 351-366
9.
Martin A. I. P. A new form of
chromatogram involving two liquid phases/ A.I.P. Martin,
R.L.M.Synge//Biochem.I., 1941.-val.35.-pp.1358-1368
10.
Some theoretical aspects of partion
chromatography/ A.I.P. Martin// Biochem. Sac. Symp., 1949.-val.3.-pp.4-20
11.
Van
Deemterm I.I. Longitudinal diffusion and resistance to mass transfer as
cause of nonideality in Chromatography/I.I.Deemter.F.I. Zuiderweg.A.
Klinkenberg//Chem.Eng. Sci., 1956.val.3.-pp 271-289