Психология и
социология/12. Социальная психология
Магистранг гр. НВЭм-14-, Быкова Светлана Михайловна
Иркутский
национальный исследовательский технический университет, Россия
Comparative
analysis of the transformation of family traditions and values of
modern Russian families and families from South Korea: the attitude to mixed
marriages, mental and civilizational features as the cause of the differences
in the characteristics of transmission of social memory generations.
The
family occupies a very important place in the life of any person. For some
people, it brings joy to others - grief, but for all the family is significant
and it can not be underestimated.
The state has always been and will remind us of
one big family, each follower is there in common. Thanks to these similarities,
communication between members of the same country will be held in a relaxed
atmosphere, which, unfortunately, is unlikely to get the representatives of
different nations. In any conversation between people from different countries
can be seen the following pattern: each party seeks to be a leader and wants to
show the benefits only, missing important moments.
International communication at any level remains
unchanged: mistrust and rivalry - traits that best describe the psychological
components of his opponents. Therefore, considering this communication, even
within the family, you can see the differences in the life plans, attitudes and
interests that have been laid down as a child and as a result, in most cases,
they are a major cause of divorce in such marital unions.
In such families, it is difficult to educate
their children, between spouses are constant conflicts, while the children are
neglected and can not take sides. There is a mix of cultures, traditions and
values, which has a positive effect on the level of the multinational state and
the negative impact on the level of each individual family.
National mentality and peculiarities of farming
affect the nature of family traditions. In the process of transmission of
social memory generations, it has weighty importance social environment where
educated people, cultural and ethnic traditions of the country, especially
family and community structure and the level of success of the combination of
everyday life with moral ideals, declared ancestors.
To identify the social and cultural
characteristics of family traditions, typical for Russia and South Korea was
held in the format of an empirical study of unstructured interviews.
An analysis of the responses of South Korean
respondents, found that family for them is of great importance. In this
country, it serves not only as an institution of socialization and instrumental
value, allows us to develop economically and to be socially protected children,
but also as a fundamental value, giving an incentive to life, self-development,
obtaining additional benefits and career advancement.
Among the Russian respondents such trends raise
the profile of the family has not been noticed. Family is important for the
Russian respondents, but they do not consider other interests have to sacrifice
for the sake of it. Anton from Irkutsk (26, student) argued as follows: "A
family in our country can not start as long as freedom is not tired, forty
years before, that's when it will be important, as long as you're young, and
enjoy a better life for yourself ... ".
Korean respondents, Chung Jung-ho (26 years,
student) said the following about it: "The family - the most important
thing in life! Work and hobbies - also important elements, but the family is
most important, but sometimes needs a rest from it and to feel the happiness
... ".
Let us turn to the question of the degree of
closeness of relations of children and parents. The study revealed that the
Russian and Korean respondents have not experienced being in family life, not
fully located in a trusting relationship with their parents.
Korean respondents base their conclusions on the
fact that parents are their mentors inviolable, so saved intergenerational
distance. As for the respondents in Russia, they do not explain their behavior,
and argue its common reluctance to communicate with parents, showing thus their
contempt for him.
Respondent Chung Chung Ho general opinion
expressed by the Korean respondents in this regard: "... between father
and son there is a close relationship, the son should be brought up in
austerity and respect for his father ...".
Russian respondents, Catherine (20 years, a
student) and Anna (20 years, a student), claimed that their relationship with
their parents, "like everyone", explained as follows: "It
depends on compatibility characters, zodiac signs ... "and the remaining
Russian respondents confidently answered that" The relationship with the
parents in trouble and that's okay, because we their children .... "
Consider the question of who should be engaged
in raising children and what qualities should have a good parent. With the
majority of Korean respondents revealed that the upbringing of children should
be engaged parents "without the involvement of teachers' and parents for
good characteristic qualities such as" kindness, mutual trust and hard
work. "
On the part of Russian respondents, as well as
the respondents from South Korea, the prevailing view that children in the
first place, must educate their parents. Yet, in this thread respondent Anton
expressed concern and said, "If those out as mothers in some families with
many children, it is better to let them give in custody, there will be at least
feed the children, keep an eye on them and wear is fine ..." .
Asked about the qualities every good parent
should have the Russian respondents identified qualities such as
"responsibility and commitment to the care of children."
Turning to the question of whether families with
children are welcome in Russia and South Korea, it was found that large
families are perceived negatively in Russia (the respondents indicate that:
"There is much more convenient to live alone ..."). Respondents from
South Korea do not contradict the fact that large families are mostly
low-income, but argue that: "The minimum number of children in the family
- two or three, it is necessary for its prosperity ...".
On the question of at what age is best to
acquire own family, respondents from different countries meet at all in the
same vein: Russian respondents named some 25-year-old age limit, and the ROK in
their judgments close to the age of "35 years."
For example, a respondent Min Ji said:
"Previously, families were large and strong, could soon start its economy
and provide for the family. Now there is no economy, and to earn a lot of
money, you have to work and receive a prestigious post, to learn and to work.
Therefore, man must first work, he can marry at 35 and women can learn and find
a husband soon. I want to get married at 29 years, 30 years ... ".
Another respondent from South Korea, Yoo Jin on
this issue said: "The family is created when people are ready. Many men in
Korea grow late, so I will create a family until 32 years ... ".
Thus, the opinions of Korean and Russian
respondents were completely different, since, in contrast to the opinion of
South Korean respondents, almost all respondents in Russia said that
"Family is best to acquire in 25 years!".
In the matter of respect for elders,
respondents' opinions were divided. According to the Korean respondents:
"In respect for elders based society, it is made to order remained
everywhere, then people need to behave as it should ...". As for the
respondents in Russia, compared with South Korean respondents, the elderly are
not respected at all. For example, Anna (18 years, student) says: "Senior
respect those who are older, and children now had escaped from the custody and
are responsible for themselves. So it should be .... "
On the question of whether there are special
celebrations, celebrate who believe the whole family, the respondents from
South Korea named two holidays: "New Year and Chuseok." In contrast,
respondents from Russia, they have no concept of "celebrating a
birthday." They rarely celebrated birthdays with the family, most often it
is in the company of friends, with the use of meat and alcohol in a small
karaoke bar.
For example, a respondent Chung Chung Ho on this
issue expressed the following: "The New Year and Chuseok - holidays for
families. Birthdays - rarely celebrated New Year - often. Chuseok - a harvest
festival, we celebrated it in the fall. There are held various competitions,
contests, games, selling goodies. People gather together families and play
games ... ".
Respondents from Russia named four family
festival: "Birthday, New Year, Twenty-eighth of March and 3 February."
Let us issues concerning divorces, adultery and
orphanages. Interviews showed that Russian families less strong, often happen
adultery and quarrels, and after them, people get divorced and are looking for
another family. As often happens in Russia, which is given to children in the
care of the state. In fact, in South Korea the problem is also very relevant,
especially, that the children get in children's homes.
Respondents from Russia argue their views as
follows: "Treason happen at every turn, bred more often than married, and
children in orphanages are not given for any reason, and take on the
dysfunctional parents ...".
South Korean respondents indicated that:
"Couples break rarely adultery occur most frequently in affluent families,
politicians and businessmen, when a woman is looking for fun on the side, it's
all well hidden and not exposed to the public, they live as strangers. If
children are given the care of the state, but it is usually lonely and
abandoned women who have nowhere to go ... ".
Respondent Chung Chung Ho believes that such
phenomena - a rarity in South Korea, but as to how often do parents leave their
children in the care of the state, he said: "Unfortunately, this problem
does exist today. Though earlier it was worse, our country was very poor, so
talking about it in jest, that the main export - is the car and the people as
the labor force and the bride from South Korea. Mothers often leave their
children to build their lives, it was the norm. Now it has decreased, but still
not quite izzhilos ... ".
According to the other respondents, Min Ji:
"Treason in married life do not occur often, but men in our country
believe that a woman can change them, they are afraid, so often it is
controlled, hire people to control it. When they see that she has changed, they
divorced her. Now the rich wives of politicians and businessmen like young men,
so they change. Men rarely change, but if it happens, they do not get divorced
and the wife does not know it .... "
According to Yu Jin, divorce proceedings -
"frequent", and with respect to adultery, she pointed out,
"cheating in marriage occur at successful people, they hide it. The poor
people of other values, they do not change. When I get married, I'll find a
secured, but in moderation, man .... "
Concerning the orphanages, Russia was more
humane. Respondents from South Korea pointed out that "children are in
state care on their own parents", "... it was especially
characteristic of twenty years ago, when the country was not as rich and mainly
exports machines were considered and live labor ..." . In recent years,
according to respondents, the situation is stabilized, people are much less
likely to abandon children in the care of the state, and this happens
"when a woman is alone with a baby and can not provide for themselves and
the baby." That is, in our time it happens "forced, unlike what
happened even some twenty years ago."
The basis of this view are the opinions of
researchers following respondents: Korean Ji Min respondent states: "Young
families often break, and she can not feed themselves, so leave the baby. More
mature families break up and children are rarely brought up and live in
prosperity ... ".
The following opinion was expressed by
respondent Yu Jin: "... It happens often, is the problem with this
government is fighting. Parents do not want to take on the burden of
responsibility, but suffer. When a parent is left alone, it can not cope with
the child and work simultaneously , it is impossible, so it leaves the child
and thinks back for him, but it is not. Everyone starts to live again and does
not want to return their problems, so the problem with the child remain in the
state. She finds herself a rich husband buys expensive clothes, eating
expensive food instead of kimchi and forgets about the feelings of the child.
She forgets her child, and the child forgets his mother is scary ... ".
Regarding the Russian side, the respondents
pointed mostly to the fact that "Parents are trying to ensure that their
own children, but sometimes in families there are signs of deviant behavior
that manifest themselves in the fact that people drink too much and no longer
care for their children." In this case, the guardianship is entitled to
take away the child from socially dangerous environment, and transfer to a
prosperous family.
Let us turn to the more incriminating question
of who should be the master of the house, male or female. Opinions of Russian
respondents were divided, most of them indicated that it is a man, but a
significant part of the respondents still disagreed, explaining that: "A
woman has a lot more power and should not give in just because she's a woman
...".
Opinions Korean respondents were slightly
different, they all said that the house should take a dominant place only
between man and argued as follows: "Man - the head of the family, even if
a woman is too strong, it does not struggle with the man, she submits to him
and gives birth to him children. If a woman does not want to obey, she can not
find a husband ... ".
We turn to the question about the traditions and
norms of the family. In South Korea, the family have strict limitations in
communication (even those, such as the fact that "the wife does not dare
to contact her husband by name") and precise rituals, the violation of
which leads to a public reprimand, (such as "annual mandatory Congress
relatives to the ancestors (dead or alive) "). All this just tells us that
the unspoken norms and ideals laid down in the principles of everyday Korean
and rarely violated, can not be said about the moral behavior of Russians.
Russian respondents indicated that they do not
need to adhere to certain principles, on the contrary, they strive to create a
system of rules that will express a high degree of freedom and personal choice
of each member of the family.
At the end of the interview each respondent was
asked to give an example of a family tradition. Concerns researchers was the
fact that the institution of the family in Russia, judging by the respondents
in this case, with each generation becoming less strong and significantly lost
its value in the eyes of young people.
South Korean respondents cited the example of
the various family traditions, but the Russian respondents such traditions do
not remember and react to the issue lightly.
Korean respondents Chung Chung Ho called
following the family tradition: "The wife should adhere to in all aspects
of decisions of her husband, even in politics. If a child grows rude, it is the
fault of women as child-rearing should only deal with it, it is her duty if she
did not perform in Korea, man is free to drive the woman to divorce her and no
other reasons ... ".
Another respondent, Ming Ji, brought examples of
their family tradition: "When meeting with parents, people do not call
their names, and the girl never be called to address to her husband ...".
Another respondent also spoke about some of
family traditions, "we ate as a family, it is also a tradition to the
table at the beginning always gets his father, and so do the other families. In
other families there that getting to know the parents of the bride or groom, do
not say the name of mom or dad; Koreans have great respect for his mom and dad
and always do as they are told ... ".
Russian respondents, as opposed to the activity
of respondents in South Korea, in this case, could not think of any one
tradition, referring to the fact that: "In some families, the tradition
remained in the garden of joint excursions for potatoes, that's all ... Well,
tradition at which old-age daughter should have a mother and son should at his
age to get a car. "
Thus, the socio-cultural characteristics of
family traditions in Russia and South Korea have a number of distinctive
features. This allows you to note that the mental and civilizational features
play an important role in the mechanisms of formation and transmission of
social memory generations. National mentality plays a huge role in the
formation of value orientations of each individual family.
At the end of the interview each respondent was
asked to give an example of a family tradition. Concerns researchers was the
fact that the institution of the family in Russia, judging by the respondents
in this case, with each generation becoming less strong and significantly lost
its value in the eyes of young people.
South Korean respondents cited the example of
the various family traditions, but the Russian respondents such traditions do
not remember and react to the issue lightly.
Korean respondents Chung Chung Ho called
following the family tradition: "The wife should adhere to in all aspects
of decisions of her husband, even in politics. If a child grows rude, it is the
fault of women as child-rearing should only deal with it, it is her duty if she
did not perform in Korea, man is free to drive the woman to divorce her and no
other reasons ... ".
Another respondent, Ming Ji, brought examples of
their family tradition: "When meeting with parents, people do not call
their names, and the girl never be called to address to her husband ...".
Another respondent also spoke about some of
family traditions, "we ate as a family, it is also a tradition to the
table at the beginning always gets his father, and so do the other families. In
other families there that getting to know the parents of the bride or groom, do
not say the name of mom or dad; Koreans have great respect for his mom and dad
and always do as they are told ... ".
Russian respondents, as opposed to the activity
of respondents in South Korea, in this case, could not think of any one
tradition, referring to the fact that: "In some families, the tradition
remained in the garden of joint excursions for potatoes, that's all ... Well,
tradition at which old-age daughter should have a mother and son should at his
age to get a car. "
Thus, the socio-cultural characteristics of
family traditions in Russia and South Korea have a number of distinctive
features. This allows you to note that the mental and civilizational features
play an important role in the mechanisms of formation and transmission of
social memory generations. National mentality plays a huge role in the
formation of value orientations of each individual family.
Characteristics of the family, who were named by
respondents from different countries differ significantly among themselves and
together represent a family tradition as one of the most important ways of
transmission of social memory generations.
Family traditions in Russia and South Korea are
similar in degree of importance of the family as a social unit, similar to that
training is preferred by parents, not by specialists in education and that
families with children are not desirable in a modern society; in families
considered to be the head and breadwinner man and a woman - the keeper of the
hearth, which is engaged in the upbringing of children. For other social and
cultural characteristics of family life from different countries obtained
during the study, there are significant differences.
Respondents from Russia are elderly less respect
than the representatives of South Korea, they are not planning to have
children, in contrast to the respondents from South Korea, who wish to have at
least two or three children.
In South Korea, get married and do it
consciously as an adult, but in Russia it most often occurs in adolescence
spontaneously.
Thus, the socio-cultural characteristics of
family values people from different countries depend on the
national mentality and civilizational features that have been clearly proven by
a comparative analysis on the example of Irkutsk citizens perspectives as
representatives of the Russian society, and the inhabitants of Seoul, as the
representatives of South Korean society.
Literature
1. Afanasyev TM The family today. -M .:
Knowledge, 1977. -52s.
2. Role of the Logunov Lili family ancestral
memory in intergenerational interaction // Family in the context of
pedagogical, psychological and sociological research: Proceedings of the
International. scientific-Practical. Conf. / Ed. A. berberine, BA Doroshin etc.
- Penza - Yerevan - Prague LLC Scientific Publishing Center
"sociosphere", 2010. - 0.2 p. L.
3. Meyvogel R. Preschool and children's
education in Europe // Wrap. №5, 1998. -4-6s.
4. Simbirtseva TM Korea at the crossroads of
epochs // ant-Hyde 2000 -68s.