M. Dement
Forming future officers’ professional motivation in
State Service of Ukraine of Emergencies.
The professional
training of future officers noted the necessity of modern higher education. To
fulfill the requirements of the Presidential Decree of Ukraine number 726/2012
"On some measures to optimize the system of central bodies of executive
power" in the community delivering a package of measures on the process of
reorganization of the Ministry of Emergency Situations (MES) of Ukraine in the
State Service of Ukraine of Emergencies. Specificity of training cadets MES is
that, unlike many military occupations of the future officers, cadets MES
except paramilitary activity has civic functions: a teacher, a psychologist, a
mentor, a counselor. It is important to mention that the professional
activities of the personnel of the future officers of MES based only on a few
organizational foundations of the military sphere - unity of command,
subordination (centralization), charter, service discipline, personal
responsibility - and therefore very similar to the activities of other security
agencies, internal troops, internal affairs, border guards, etc.
The importance of
the theoretical training of cadets is reflected in many scientific educational
research. But, in our view, are valuable studies of practical problems of their
training. One of these is the problem of creating professional motivation of
future officers. Professional motivation reflects the attitude to the chosen
profession, encourages creative expression of personality in professional work
and daily life, suggests in a future officer presence thirst for knowledge of
professional disciplines and related disciplines, which the cadet studies. The
motive of professional work is an
internal engine that encourages cadets to professional work.
The purpose of
the article is to analyze the methods of pedagogical research in determining
the motivational criterion at carrying out of pedagogical experiment during
professional training cadets MES.
Experimental
basis of research conducted by us during a few years was elected the National
University of Civil Defense of Ukraine (Kharkov) which becomes the main base
for the research. On the ascertaining step of the pedagogical experiment was
determined a motivational criterion. The indicators of motivational criterion
is the low personal characteristics, in our research we examined the following
indicators: the motivation to the professional work, the motivation to the
university studies, the motives of training activities, the motives of
professional choice, work motivation.
The first was
chosen indicator of motivation for professional work. To determine the
indicator the motivation for professional work was used V.L.Vasileva technique.
The cadets were asked to complete a questionnaire and evaluate the proposed
list of reasons on a ten-point scale. After we have processed the results of
the survey: the degree of importance of each motif, expressed in points, it was
concluded that, how pronounced in the future officers a professional calling
and how they are expressing attendant and secondary motives, interests.
After the survey,
we found that cadets of first year dominated attendant and secondary motives of
professional activity: the desire to assert them, to improve their status and
prestige, the desire to be in a professional environment, the ability to
satisfy their desire for power, circumstances forced.
Unfortunately,
the most of the cadets were not detected the primary professional motives and
interests: consciousness usefulness of their activities; interest to the
profession, the desire to help people in difficult and unusual circumstances,
the desire to pass their knowledge and experience gained during the
professional activity, the desire for self-development.
It was also
chosen polling method, to identify the formation of motivation. In an interview
the attitudes of cadets towards their chosen profession, their awareness of
choice, the conditions of formation of motives and a place that profession
takes in its system of motives.
We proposed
questions regarding the features motives for choosing a profession and
professional motivation of methods A. P. Moskalenko, D. A. Kobzin, A. A.
Starodubtsev: 1. Why do you want to work (learn) here? 2. How do you make
decisions about future education, future profession? 3. What influenced your
choice of profession? 4. How do you think what will give this profession for
you? 5. Why your profession is better than others? 6. If we imagine that such a
profession is not, what will you choose? Why? 7. Why do you think that this
profession is right for you? 8. How do you think, what personality traits need
this profession? 9. How did you first get interested of this profession?
Survey results
also testified that at the beginning of the experiment, prevailed the cadets
with secondary motives, not with inner motives. The results of research
correlate with the results of studies conducted by other pedagogical
experimental researches to determine the motives of professional choice cadets MES.
At the initial stage of learning in most subjects the professional motivation
is underdeveloped; the dominant motifs are interested to a prestigious
profession, utilitarian motives to achieve professional status, romantic
enthusiasm, the financial interest and others.
Also, we
investigated the motivational sphere of cadets. Received at the beginning of
the experiment data clearly represent the motivational sphere of this category
of cadets. Thus, among the motives of professional activity the most important
of them are situational, selfish, compensation (according to the classification
V.L.Vasileva): improving the material conditions; authority; their welfare and
well-being of the family, a high salary, career, opportunity to be responsible
for a human life.
Before the
beginning of the study, the cadets hardly revealed their inner motives: the
possibility of benefit, respect for others, love of work, the opportunity to
help people, job satisfaction, and the like.
Thus, it can be
argued that these experimental studies suggest the dominance of situational
motivation in choosing a profession of the future officer in the beginning of
the experiment. Perhaps it is natural and partially due to the current economic
situation in the country, as well as an inadequate imagination of cadets about
the features of the profession at the time of selection. But it must be
emphasized that the process of professional self-determination does not end
with a career choice, the question of specialty choosing, for clarification of
this selection from time to time arise during a person's lifetime.
First-year cadets
are choosing a profession of the future officer MES under the influence of
situational factors, the dominant of which is the relative stability of the
profession, the financial interest, the external prestige. This illustrates the
need for special measures to establish internal motives: to improve their
personal qualities in the process of formation of readiness for professional
work in the field of Emergency Situations, the increased desire to conform to
social expectations, the possibility of benefit, love of work, the ability to
help people.
In order to
obtain a more objective assessment of the motives we took into account not only
the data of the questionnaire, but the results of our interviews, which
included a series of open-ended questions designed to obtain information about
the motives of future professional activity. We also conducted interviews with
the cadets of the experimental and control groups.
Future officers
were asked to answer the following questions: How long have you decided to
choose a career of officer? What was the main when making your decision to
become them? Thanks to whom you have decided to choose this profession? What
professional qualities do you think are necessary for the officer? How do you
understand the objectives and tasks of the professional activities of future
officer? What, in your opinion, knowledges required for a successful career of
the future officer?
During the
research of indicators motivational criteria at the end of experiment we used
the same procedure as at the beginning of the experiment.
To determine the
overall dynamic of motivation on work were carried out 2 section - the first -
on ascertaining step of the experiment, and the second - in the control phase
of the experiment. They were carried out both in the experimental and control
groups using the same methods. Results motivation levels are shown in Table 1.
Table 1
Changes in motivation on work
cadets groups EG and CG at the beginning and end of
the experiment
(increase in%).
|
¹ |
The motivation for
professional work |
The official examiner
stage |
Control stage |
Increase |
||||||
|
|
Levels: |
EG |
CG |
EG |
CG |
EG |
CG |
|||
|
1. |
High |
17 |
16 |
30 |
20 |
13 |
4 |
|||
|
2. |
Medium |
33 |
35 |
46 |
40 |
13 |
5 |
|||
|
3. |
Low |
50 |
49 |
24 |
40 |
-26 |
-9 |
|||
Comparative
analysis of the percentage increase high and medium levels of formation of
motivation for professional and motivational criterion explained by combination
of different activities: methods, techniques, forms, important for formation of
readiness to professional work in the educational space, training sessions,
role-playing and corresponding changes in the realization of cadets own
motivation to improve the effectiveness of the educational process,
optimization of the various activities of the future officer with orientation
for new professional knowledge, skills, implementing them in practice,
systematic educational work.
In the end we
come to the conclusions: in the process of experimental tracking were made the
next conclusions: 1) the formation of the cadets preparedness for professional
work affects both internal and external motivations - fashion to a college
education, family ties, 2) the interest of future officers to their own surge
capacity, the installation on the development of their professional skills
determines the direction of the experimental work, 3) the cause of the weak
nature of the motivation of the future officers on mastering a profession it is
an influence by both internal problems and external circumstances 4) provide
that motives for mastering the profession can be formed and less fixed in any
purposefully doing this.