Zholchibekova K.Zh.
Taraz State Pedagogical Institute, Kazakhstan
DISTINCTIVE FEATURES OF METAPHOR AND SIMILE IN
IMAGERY OF R.L. STEVENSON
In this research
work we try to illustrate the role of metaphor and simile in extracts. We stressed on imagery titled
“Strange case of Dr.Jekyll and Mr.Hyde”, which was written by famous Scotland
writer, the author of world adventure stories and novels, the biggest
representative of English neoromantism, Robert Luis Stevenson. When we hear
this name, we automatically imagine ourselves “Treasure Island”. In 1886 the
book was published, in 1888 it was translated into Russian. The metaphors and
similes are lavish in this book, however it is hard to find out these stylistic
devices, because it was written in classical style. D.Davidson tried to
systemize the interpretation in his article titled “The theory of metaphors” in
1990. B.V. Tomashevsky in her book “Stylistics and versification”, which was
published in 1959, Ortony Andrew in his “The role of similarity and in Similes
and Metaphors”, which published in 1993 and another linguists tried to
systemize interpretation of simile. Using their theories we tried to define
metaphors and similes of R.L. Stevenson’s imagery.
First, we offer
you extracts with metaphors and similes from his imagery revealing them. Look.
1. “…so that the
shop fronts stood along that thorough fare with an air of invitation, like rows
of smiling saleswoman.”
Simile with
unexpected comparison describes the way how the shop fronts stood. In his
extract there are two similes: a) “the shop fronts stood with an air of
invitation”, describes the action. How did the shop fronts stand? With an air
of invitation. b) “An air of invitation, like rows of smiling saleswoman”,
describes the object. What kind of invitation? Like rows of smiling saleswoman.
2. “the street shone out
in contrast to its dingy neighborhood, like a fire in a forest.” It is simile, predicate is revealed,
introduced by preposition in comparative phrase like. “Shone out, like a fire in a forest.” Frequently, when
predicate is described in comparison with another phenomena or object, simile
is used.
3. “All lighted up as if
for a procession and all as empty as a church till.”
In one sentence there
are two similes. “All lighted up as if for a procession”, simile is introduced
by conjunction in comparative clause as
if, described circumstance of an action. “All as empty as a churchtill”,
introduced by preposition in comparative phrase as….as, compared two different objects.
4. “It wasn’t
like a man; it was like some damned Juggernaut.”
There can be
confusion with like, being bowed to
metaphor or simile. It is faux simile. We will attempt to prove it. Taking
under consideration I.Gurova’s interpretation as metaphor, let us look at the
whole extract:
“All at once, I saw two
figures: one a little man who was stumping along eastward at a good walk and
the other a girl of may be eight or ten who was running as hard as she was able
down a cross street. Well, sir, the two ran into one another naturally enough
at the corners; and then came the horrible part of the thing; for the man
trampled calmly over the child’s body and left her screaming on the ground. It
sounds nothing to hear, but it was hellish to see. It wasn’t like a man, it was
some damned Juggernaut.”
The words like or as are widely known hallmarks of the simile, but there are so many
faux similes bearing these hallmarks that further appraisal is always
necessary. According to extract we see that the man was so awful, that’s why
the author substituted him with Juggernaut. Metaphor is more powerful than
simile, so, it is suitable to define it as a metaphor.
Juggernaut is a term,
which is used to describe appeared invisible power, showing to somebody, who
possesses through all troubles unmentioining the difficulties. One of the names
of Krishna, which means “Chief of the world”. However, R.L. Stevenson used this
term in negative meaning as a mutant and awful man. Sometimes, we will build
both a metaphor and a simile from same parts, showing how incredibly close
these two stylistic devices are. Perhaps this is due to the fact the word like means both similar and the same.
Some sources define
simile as an explicit comparison introduced by such words like, as… as, as
though, but this definition is not enough, it is not full. We would offer such
definition as simile is an explicit comparison of two objects belonging to
different classes and with limited meaning, if it is introduced by like, there should be further
explanation of their similarities. In the example above we see that man and Juggernaut belong to one class, this is another reason of
considering it as a metaphor.
5. “It was but for one
minute that I saw him, but the hair stood upon my head like quills.”
Somebody considers it as
simile, but indeed it is set expression, which means to be afraid of something.
6. “An ivory-faced and
silvery-haired old woman”, hyphenated metaphors close to epithet. There is
implicit comparison. Simple metaphor is revealed.
7. “Stood huddled
together like a flock of ship.”
It is a metaphor based
on logic motivation. Dead metaphor, because this term widely used in our society,
it is mundane, it is not new for us. Look at the whole extract: “The hall, when
they entered it, was brightly lighted up; the fire was built high; and about
the hearth the whole of the servants, men and women, stood huddled together
like flock of sheep.” The author implies that men and women are a flock of
sheep. This type of metaphor also can be complex and compound.
8. “Blank silence
followed, no one protesting; only the maid lifted her voice and wept loudly.”
It is implicit metaphor,
the full subject is not explained, but is implied from the context of the
sentence. They may still be found within colloquial contexts.
9. “Hold your tongue!
Pool said to her, with ferocity of accent that testified to his own jangled
nerves; and indeed, when the girl had so suddenly raised the note of her
lamentation, they had all started and turned towards the inner door with faces
of dreadful expectation.”
Hold your tongue is a dead metaphor, with a ferocity of accent that testified to
his own jangled nerves is a dormant metaphor, where the connection between
the vehicle and the subject is not clear, raised
the note of her lamentations an active metaphor, they had all started and turned towards the inner door with faces of
dreadful expectation is a simile based on emotive motivation. There
metaphors based on logic motivation, they are imagery expressions.
10. “The cook, crying
out Bless God! It’s Mr.Utterson, ran
forward as if to take him in her arms”. Simile is based on emotive motivation,
described the action.
11. “Well, when that
masked thing like a monkey jumped from among the chemicals and whipped into the
cabinet, it went down my spine like ice.”
Masked thing like a monkey is a simile,
is emotionally motivated imagining in front of his eyes, it went down my spine like ice is a simile, is motivated by
emotions.
12. “With ape-like fury,
he was trampling his victim”, simile which includes itself a metaphor. Ape-like fury is a dead metaphor. With ape-like fury, he was trampling.
This part answers to question how he was trampling. A simile, which introduced
by the word with describes the
predicate, the action.
13.“At one table, there
were traces of chemical work, various measured heaps of some white salt being
laid on glass sources, as though for an experiment in which the unhappy man had
been prevented.”
A simile is introduced
by the conjunction as though, describes
the predicate on emotion.
14.“I never saw a circle
of such hateful faces; …, with a kind of black sneering coolness-frightened
to,…, really like Satan.”
Face is really like Satanis a simile with
explanation, introduced by the preposition in comparative phrase like, is created emotionally, and
describes an object.
15. “His friends were
those of his own blood or those whom he had known the longest; his affections,
like ivy, were the growth of time, they implied no aptness in the object.”
Friends
of his own blood are a dead metaphor. His
affections were the growth of time, like
ivy is a metaphor is created logically. It is an active metaphor. There ivy
is a plant, which grows on suitable surface for climbing, including trees,
natural rock outcrops.
So, there are
given above fifteen extracts, which includes similes and metaphors from R.L.
Stevenson’s imagery. There are only fifteen extracts, but includes itself much
more similes and metaphors, they are variab le, lavish. For making a conclusion
it is enough to analyze the given extracts above. There we see the
peculiarities of author’s style and his representing of stylistic devices as
metaphor and simile. The given imagery is classic, that why every line includes
itself many stylistic devices. Metaphors and similes are frequently complex.
The originators peculiarity is that he used several metaphors and similes in
one sentence, one simile includes another one. And simile includes itself a
metaphor, while metaphor includes itself an epithet. Dead and active or live
metaphors are also bountiful.
Wide readership
could have a confusion while interpreting the stylistic devices introduced by like, because this word is used in set
expressions, in metaphor, in simile. If we know the rules, which we offer you,
it will be easy to differentiate them. The rule is simple, look, if the
stylistic device introduced by the word likeis
created emotionally that is a simile, if it is created logically, that is a
metaphor.
The obvious
peculiarity of R.L. Stevenson of representing metaphors and similes is that he
frequently used the preposition with.
In former theories of simile and metaphor such phenomena doesn’t exist. May be
this is the main peculiarity of R.L. Stevenson of representing his own
metaphors and similes. The differences between them are also on their created
motivations as logic and emotive, is the same as in metaphors and similes with like. The frequencies of such devices
look at the diagram below. There are also our own tables of classification of
metaphor and simile. Classification of metaphor is according to structure and
concept. Classification of simile is according to its type of description and
introducing words. As similes describe object or predicate, in our
classification there are two types of simile: objective and predicative.
Absolute
metaphors in some sources are called paralogical or antimetaphor. There is also
non-absolute metaphor, for example box – house. Compound, extended, complex
metaphors are close to each other. Active metaphor is also called as live
metaphor. Extended metaphor is also called as conceit.
So, R.L.
Stevenson used dead metaphors as well as active metaphors. Similes and
metaphors are complex enough. He used conjunctions like and with both in
metaphor and simile. According to sense of extracts similes are emotionally
motivated and metaphors are logically motivated.
References
1. Stevenson. R.L. 1886. Strange case of Dr.Jekyll and Mr.Hyde. UK. ISBN 0-553- 21277-X
2. Eôèìîâ
À.È. Ñòèëèñòèêà õóäîæåñòâåííîé ðå÷è. Ìîñêâà. 1961. 519ñ.
3. Òîìàøåâñêèé Á.Â.
Ñòèëèñòèêà. Ë.:Íàóêà. 1983.- 288ñ.
4. Óøàêîâà Å.Ì.
Ëèíãâèñòè÷åñêèé àñïåêò â èçó÷åíèè ñèìèëå. Ñòàâðîïîëü.
1967. c5-50
5. www.metaphor-encyclopediaarticleandmorefrommerriam-webster