d.h.s. D.Baigunakov, c.h.s. G.Sabdenova
U.A.Dzholdasbekov Academy of economics and law,
Taldykorgan, Kazakhstan
Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty,
Kazahstan
Monuments (kulpytases) of Kartnak and Takya Ata (South Kazakhstan)
Karnak kulpytases (monuments) are situated in the territory of old cemetery in the north part of Karnak
village of Kentau town of South Kazakhstan region. It was
investigated by an archeological and ethnographic expedition of Kazakh
scientific and research culture institution in 2013. The geographic coordination of the monument taken in that period is N 433115.1, E 0682006.8.
This old cemetery occupies a territory
of 3-4 hectares. It has been
used by Kazakhs, Uzbeks, and Tajiks for last times. Definite parts of the
cemetery are devoted to representatives of each ethnos; consequently, it was
divided into several parts. As it is owned by different ethnoses, its
characteristics differ from present day monuments. At first, the size of the
monument was small; later on it seems to be enlarged, as ancient tombs are
spread in the southern and north-western parts asymmetrically. Gravestones of
some tombs are turned over and groomed, there are enough gravestones with some
corners fallen into pieces. Remainders of constructions similar to tombs of
early Iron Age or early medium age are found in the territory of the cemetery.
Some tombs of late centuries are covered only by gravestones without any
manuscripts; most of them are of blue or white color, which represents their local
origin.
Karnak kulpytases (monuments), the object of our research
work, are made from stones and sand. Only some of them are completed by blue marmite
and granite. According to specialists, such monuments are wide spread in the
western and southern parts of Kazakhstan. In ancient times the methods of
constructing monuments were changing depending on the religious ideas;
decoration issues of monuments represent the traditions, world view, and
memorial and handicraft process of the people living in that period [1].
T. Dairabai, one
of the researchers, stating that such monuments are less spread in other
regions of Kazakhstan says that he met only
two monuments made from sand and stone in Kyzylorda oblast, one of them is
situated in an old place of Adam Ata tomb of Kazakly district, the other is the
gravestone of Moshybai Tortuyl (the 19th century) buried near Tan
village of Zhalagash district [2]. According to its outer
view, the last monument is similar to monuments wide
spread in the western regions. These monuments of the western regions were
investigated by researchers partially. Such works as “The architecture of
nomads” of S. Azhigali [3],
“Kazakh traditional stone engraving art” of R.A. Beknazarov [4], “Gravestone” of I.Tasmaganbetov [5]
are the most valuable among works devoted to this
theme of history. These works have made a great contribution to investigating
the ways of genesis and development of the stone graving art. These sources
give a deep knowledge about gravestones and large information on their
individual character. Certainly, above named sources do not comprise the whole
flow of literature on gravestones, because there had been early researches
before the above named pieces were published.
Monuments of Kazakh history have attracted
the attention of researchers since the medieval ages. For instance, such medieval authors as Akhmet ibn Fadlan, Giliom
de Rubruc, Ruzbikhan mentioned stone compositions of cemeteries in their works.
These constructions were also discussed in the works of Russian researcher such
as Rychkov, Falk, Pallas, Berg, Karuts and others. During the soviet epoch T.Ê.Bassenov, M. Mendikulov, E. Massanov and others
researched these gravestones. After Kazakhstan’s gaining independence, the work
of researching gravestones was conducted systematically, such specialists as S.
Azhigali, Z. Samashev, Zh. Zhetibayev progressed in defining their nature [6; 7]. Such problems as the peculiarities and types of stonegraves, ways
of their refreshement, methods of using the images of everyday and industrial
objects on the surface of gravestones, and their functions were investigated by
the researchers.
If to go back to the
above discussed issues, the fact that only two stone and sand constructions
were found in the territory of Kysyzorda oblast, which joins the southern and
northern parts of vast territory of Kazakhstan, can be explained by less
intensive and uncompleted research work, as T. Dairabai says. Although, it is impossible that Kazakhs of Syr River bands of Kyzylorda
oblast did not use methods of constructing gravestones of Turkistan region. Because some specialists state that there were center for producing
gravestones in Turkistan, and their products were of no less quality compared
with those made in Samarkand.
Indeed, the researchers do not give any
information about the centers, which produced gravestones. However, one of such
kind of centers was situated near Khoja Akhmet Yassawi’s mausoleum in Turkistan
city between the 16th and 20th centuries. In traditional
Kazakh society gravestones made in Samarkand had been evaluated highly till the
20th century. According to some scientific resources, Samarkand
gravestones were very popular in the whole Central Asian territory. Trade
caravans brought gravestones in travelling back from Samarkand, when they
transported there large weighs of goods. Centers of producing gravestones were
also in Nurata and near Kazygurt mountains of present day South-Kazakhstan
oblast. The large number of these centers influenced on the diversification of
methods of making gravestones and their nature. For instance, the fact that
gravestones of different style and size were found near Arystanbab mausoleum in
Otyrar region can serve as a proof for it [8, 7-8]. It is important to note that the materials of gravestones of Arystanbab
mausoleum still need deeper investigation and further systematization. A
surface and small research conducted by S. Akylbek some time ago does not
demonstrate the nature of gravestones of southern regions thoroughly [8]. It is of great prominence to understand the need to
research gravestones of Arystanbab mausoleum by orientalists, historians,
literary and ethnology researchers. Only then, it is going to be possible to
identify the evolution of the gravestones of the southern region thoroughly,
and their influence on the development of gravestone producing art of the other
regions.
In general, since
Karnak gravestones did not change much since they were built. The outer view of most of them is alike. Some
of them do not have any manuscripts. Writings on some others are slowly
erasing. There are several gravestones partially destroyed or broken under the
effects of natural forces. The
gravestones have a very small amount decorations. Those
decorations present on gravestones are enriched by surahs of Koran, which is
considered as one of the well-known specific peculiarities of Karnak
gravestones.
Epitaphs are written as lines on some
gravestones, on some others they are decorated with thick curves. Some
gravestones are covered by Arabic texts on both sides, while others have
writings only on one side. The volume of writings also differs; some are
smaller, and others are written with large letters. Alongside this, some
gravestones keep the symmetry, and others are asymmetrical. Decorations of
gravestones are also different. Some of the gravestones first investigated are
supplied with the signs of scissors or human palms, which may give us the
information about the late person’s job, as scissors may denote a tailor. According
to this, we can assume that the relatives of the buried person wanted to tell
everybody the talent of the late and gave a gravestone master a special order. Stone
engravers tried to decorate the tombs as well as possible. Most gravestones’
size and dimensions are almost the same. By this, it is possible to assume that
all these gravestones were made in one center, and even during one period of
time. However, Karnak gravestones differ from others by their multiple styles. Most
of them are in one style, designed as tombs with two or three ladders, while others
have a cupola on upper parts.
The masters of stone engraving art used
a lot of different images. Solar images as sun and star, decorations
symbolizing flowers, hand mirror with a handle, cupola, different kinds of signs, and lines are drawn with a special attention.
Edges of some stones and spaces between writings are enriched by curving or
geometric lines. Some gravestones are decorated by vertical lines. The base of most gravestones is 2-3 centimeters long compared
with the other parts.
The volume of Arabic writings on the
gravestones is different. Some gravestones are totally covered with Arabic
writing, while Arabic texts on some of them are written with small letters.
These small letters slightly started diminishing as the time passed. It is
interesting to note that Arabic writings cover the top and even the both sides
of gravestones. Some smaller gravestones have no written texts at all, but
their front side has recess and their upper middle side is decorated by
geometric figures. These gravestones did not supply with any information about
the buried people in them, which makes it difficult to know the date of their
construction. They possibly are the oldest gravestones in the cemetery, as the
technology of building is primitive, which demonstrates that the stone engraver
as inexperienced.
According to the
orientalist Aitzhan Nurmanova, most gravestones of Karnak cemetery are decorated by the wide spread Islamic phrase “La Illaha illa Allah,
Muhammadan Rasul Allah!”, which is translated into English as “There is no
power except Allah and Muhammad is his Prophet!”. These words are met almost on
every gravestones of Karnak village. On one of these gravestones made from long
blue granite it is possible
to find the above mentioned words, but they also added by dates “1242/1826”. A. Nurmanova could identify the following words on
one of gravestones consisting from three parts (in Kazakh): “1312/1894”, “Sana”,
“Ofat”, “Gafur Alla … umit/umbet”,
“Amma Kurban bek”. The name of the late person is usually written on the top or
upper part of gravestones, as A. Nurmanova could read the words “Al-Marhum”
denoting “the person passed away”, while other parts were not possible to read
because of the effects of outer natural powers as wind, sun and water. Alongside this, some gravestones are covered by moss, which makes it
impossible to read and investigate thoroughly the manuscripts for the Arab
language specialists.
Alongside them,
there is Takya Ata gravestone in Karnak village.
The geographic coordination of this gravestone is N
433104.9, E 0682122.4. There is a tomb built
approximately in the 20th century in
its center, where several people are buried. There is a possibility
that some parts of it were built earlier, as the building is formed by separate
parts attached to each other. The eastern and southern parts of the building were
constructed later by adding canopy. The gravestones of the tomb were put side
by side into the furthest corner of logs of canopy and they were covered with a
column of logs. They rise one part of the building shelter. During the field
researches a small gravestone was found in the territory of the cemetery. Its
upper part was made in the shape of oval. There are Arabic manuscripts on its
frond view. The material of the cemetery is similar to previous monuments. Some
Arabic writings are unclear, some are covered by moss. In other words, it is
possible to state that gravestones of Takya Ata cemetery almost lost for the
history. For the outer view, gravestones used in constructing are quite similar
to the complex of the first cemetery by their formation technology and outer
geometric decorations.
In concluding this article, it is
possible to state that Karnak kulpytases (monuments) seem to be simpler
compared with such kind of monuments found in the western part of the country.
Alongside this, they are not supplied with weapons. Despite the fact that outer view of objects is similar
to sheep appearance, most of them are in shape of high enriched with different
ornaments. Karnak monuments serve as information source on lives of
peoples inhabited this territory. The dates of buried
people on the gravestones demonstrate that the dates of their building are
between the 18th and 19th centuries. It is well known
fact that there are numerous old manuscripts in the territory of Kazakhstan.
The issue of collecting, enumerating and analyzing these monuments is one of
the urgent ones. The Arabic manuscripts on the gravestones demonstrate not only
the religious opinions and philosophical view point of vernacular people, but
also they make a great contribution to researching the history and culture, analyzing
the language, art and calligraphy; and identifying stone graving issue.
References:
1. Kazak madeniyeti. Ensiklopedialik anyktamalyk. – Almaty: «Aruna», 2005. -576 p.
2. Dairabai, Ò. Sirek kezdesetin
kulpytas // Ana tili, 19 September, 2013.
3. Azhigali, S. Arkhitektura kochevnikov – fenomen istorii I kultury Evrazii (pamiatniki
Aralo-Kaspiiskogo regiona). – Almaty: NITS «Gylym», 2002. - 654 p.
4. Beknazarov, R.À. Kazaktyn dasturli tas kashau oneri. – Almaty: Tipografiya
OP, 2005. -160 p.
5. Tasmaganbetoiv, I. Kulpytas. – Almaty: Berel, 2002. - 392 p.
6. Samashev, Z., Zhetibayev Zh. Kazak
petroglifteri (kone tamyry men sabaktastygy). – Almaty: «Il-Òåkh-Êitab», 2005. – 134 p.
7. Kulpytastar. Kurast.: Ì.Sdykov, Zh.Ò.Årnazarov. – Uralsk: Batys Kazakhstan
oblystyk tarikh zhane arkheologia ortaligi, 2005. - 44 p.
8. Akylbek, S. Arystanbab mazaratyndagy kulpytastar. Epigraficheskie kladbisha
Arystanbab. – Shymkent, 2000. - 40 p.