Кандидат филологических
наук
Ломова Елена Александровна
Место работы, должность:
доцент кафедры русской и мировой литературы Казахского государственного
национального педагогического университета имени Абая (КазНПУ им. Абая),
Казахстан, г. Алматы
Домашний адрес:
Казахстан, 050021, г. Алматы, ул. Калдаякова, д. 103, кв. 23
Телефон 3-29-23-74,
8-701-722-89-53
Эл. адрес: elena_lomova_@mail.ru
Аннотация
На
рубеже XIX-XX веков интерес
к женским образам Достоевского был связан с философским осмыслением женского
вопроса. Новый импульс к этому интересу придал культ женственности славян,
женственности России, который оформился к середине девятнадцатого века, и
впоследствии стал популярным как в нашей стране, так и за рубежом.
Героинь
писателя рассматривали в контексте православной культуры, а также изучали
двойственную иррациональную сущность их характеров, что позволяет говорить о
сложившейся на Западе тенденции к
интерпретации женских образов писателя как синтеза мифологического,
христианского и психологического начал.
Исторические
и социальные аспекты изменения места и роли женщины в американском обществе 1870-1910
годов XX века определили ее новый облик и новые составляющие ее миропонимания и
восприятия действительности.
Поэтому
вполне закономерно, что «женская» тема занимает важное место в творчестве
американских писателей, являясь одним из «измерений» историко-культурного
процесса развития художественного сознания и творчества.
Как
одна из доминирующих тем американской литературы конца XIX- начала XX веков она
дает ключ к пониманию места женщины в обществе, ее роли в развитии
общественного прогресса, выяснению типичности или специфики вопроса о ее правах
и свободах.
Annotation
At the end
of XX - beginning of XXI century creativity of Dostoevsky Russian writer was
experienced a new surge of attention of foreign scientists to the female images
and in this direction turned to intensive research studies in the US and the
UK.
Authors of
these works considered heroines of the writer in the context of Orthodox
culture, as well as studied the irrational nature of their dual nature, to
allow to speak about the current trends in the West, to the interpretation of women's images of the writer as a
synthesis of mythological, Christian and psychological features.
It goes
without saying that the "female" issue occupied an important place in
the works of American writers as one of the "dimensions" of
historical and cultural development of artistic consciousness and creativity.
As one of
the dominant themes in American literature XIX- end of the beginning of XX centuries, it provided the key to understanding the
place of women in society, her role in the development of social progress, the
issue of the specificity of her rights and freedoms.
Ключевые слова: «женский вопрос», равноправие женщин,
православная культура, социальный аспект, феномен «новой жены», «южная
женщина».
Keywords: “women question”, women equil rights, Orthodo cultura, social aspect,
phenomen of “new nife”, “southern women”
"Women's Topic" in prose and its
reception in Russia and the Anglo-American Slavic Studies
To tell
the truth, a science discussion about the "female thread" in Russian
classical literature would be were difficult without appeal to the creativity
of F. Dostoevsky.
In the
works of the great writer's female characters always seem to be very
ideological and artistic value, because women are the bearers of human
happiness and comfort in troubles, embody the idea of motherly and infinite
sacrifice.
Like many
of his contemporaries, F. Dostoevsky recognized the importance for freedom and
equality for women, but at the same time believed that emancipation must be
explained in terms of the Christian love for humanity. From his point of view,
it was great mistake to solve the problem of the man and the woman separately,
whereas he considered it as a single integrated organism. [23]
According
to him, a woman should not aspire to be like a man, and the main flaw of the
modern woman is precisely the extraordinary its dependence on some of their own
men's ideas, the ability to take their word for it and believe in them
uncontrollably. [15]
Dostoevsky captured
different sides of female nature: freedom of feelings, dissatisfaction with
life, a critical attitude to it sell and its handpicked successor, readiness to
action, spontaneity and instinctive feminine nature. [15, 59]
At the
turn of XIX-XX centuries, interest in the female images Dostoevsky was
associated with a philosophical understanding of women's issues. [18]
New
impetus for this interest has given the cult of Slavic femininity, Russian
womanhood taking shape in the mid-nineteenth century, and later became popular
in Russia and abroad. [22], [10]
At the end
of XX - beginning of XXI century creativity of Russian writer was experienced a
new surge of attention of foreign scientists to the female images and in this
direction turned to intensive research studies in the US and the UK. [20]
The
attention of researchers turned also to folklore and mythological foundations
of female images F. Dostoevsky.
They
considered heroines of the writer in the context of Orthodox culture, as well
as studied the irrational nature of their dual nature, which allows us to speak
about the current trends in the West, to the interpretation of women's images of the writer as a
synthesis of mythological, Christian and psychological features. [21]
The way of
perception and understanding of woman images F. Dostoevsky at the turn of
XX-XXI centuries is known to increase researching words belonging to a
particular scientific school, the theoretical orientation of literature and the
chosen method of interpreting the heroines of the writer.
However
American and English scientists aware of any failure of a single methodology
for the holistic analysis of the author's position F. Dostoyevsky in relation
to a female character. Therefore, researchers are increasingly integrating the
different approaches, trying to reach a new level of understanding of artistic
synthesis of the universe Russian classics. [5]
Numerous
parallels and roll in the perception assessment heroines of F.Dostoevsky's
Russian and English researchers gave accurate picture of the strengthening of the
relationship between researchers of different countries and of the integrity
and unity of the literary process.
In
addition, world philology community is working intensively to translate
articles and science researching concerning Dostoevsky’s creativity.
Mutual
enrichment of Russian and foreign researchers ideas and achievements in the
field of female characters F. Dostoevsky promoted a better understanding of the
poetics of an artistic image, not only in the works of Russian writer, but also
in the works of Russian and world literature XIX-XX centuries. [14]
Interpretation
dialogue about female images of F.
Dostoevsky taken a place English and American studies in late XX - early XXI
century confirmed the idea M. Bakhtin's polyphonic principle of construction
works of the writer. Russian scientist proved the idea of special
self-extracting heroine obsessed to be heard, understood, with no well defined
ideology and the inner world, but with a high consciousness and excessive self-esteem,
configured to fight the obstacle to its limits, with the inclusion of all the
mental faculties could appear only in the works of F. Dostoevsky. [9,127]
F.
Dostoevsky turned to explore characters, solved his heroines and that way lead
to diversity and polyphony of their internal “image” in the dynamics of events
and plat twists.
Characters
of F. Dostoevsky were outstood of different measure of spiritual maturity and the degree of realization of freedom.
They reacted differently to the demands of the moral law.
In the
opinion of the writer, for humanity, there were two ways of development,
depending on the ability to use the gift of spiritual freedom.
The first
of them was way violation of the moral law with the aim of egoistic
self-assertion - called the way of the Antichrist. Development in this case
would turn to degradation, and freedom with willfulness.
The second
way was the path of love to promote the ideal of humanity. In this case people
followed Christ, defeating sin and abnormality in his heart.
The images
of Dostoevsky Grushenka and Katerina Ivanovna, like their predecessors -
Nastasia, Aglaia, Dunya Raskolnikov and Sonia even Marmeladova, moved toward
spiritual enlightenment, repentance and good.
Feminine
images of F. Dostoevsky revealed extraordinary artistic achievement. "This was made
possible as a result of focused
study of polar dual unexpected, irrational female personality, and the inner
spiritual and psychological conflict heroines of the novel was a manifestation
of a special psychological manner of Dostoevsky". [9, 93]
Historical
and social aspects of changing the place and role of women in American society
in the period 1870 till 1910 of XX century determined a new look and new components of her worldview
and perception of reality. [24]
It goes
without saying that the "female" issue occupied an important place in
the works of American writers as one of the "dimensions" of
historical and cultural development of artistic consciousness and creativity.
[16]
As one of
the dominant themes in American literature XIX- end of the beginning of XX centuries, it provided the
key to understanding the place of women in society, her role in the development
of social progress, the issue of the specificity of her rights and freedoms.
[2]
Researching
great interest in the fate of American, exploring particularly feminine,
feminine view of the world, women's values, studying the role of women in the
various areas of society, American
writers in their works sought to objectively reflect American life, the
problems of women's emancipation and feminism, as well as to high lighter the
development new priorities and social values, could be regarded as a kind of
literary creation response to the change of the spiritual content in the appear
in the works of G. James (1843-1916),
К. Cholina (1851-1904), X. Garland (1820-1940), DG Phillips (1867-1911), Т. Dreiser (1871-1945), С. Crane (1871-1900), D.
London (1876-1916), Upton
Sinclair (1878-1968) and other writers.
In the
works created during this period, the authors sought to fill the live image
content shaped in the real world the phenomenon of "new wife". [3]
But there
was a great difference between women writers and male writers in the
interpretation of this problem.
Male
priority emphasized the social role of a woman leader, orator, political
competitors and emerging social movements in society. [14]
The
specifics of the approach to artistic interpretation of the "female"
topics women writers comprised ability women writers easier and more natural to
describe surrounded reality their daily life and the
family. Since family life was for them the main habitats and the literary work
directly or indirectly contributed to the revaluation of values in favor of
changing roles and functions, primarily in the family. [17], [15], [16]
The bulk
of scientific papers devoted to the study of the role and place of women in the
American South of the XIX century, make up the study of social and historical
content.
These
works considered the Status of American woman, as well as their place of residence,
and raised the question about the degree of understanding between women of
different classes and races («Southern Women», NY, 1988).
They
analyzed the education system, described the history of the feminist movement
and considered the degree of participation to slavery.
American
writer highlighted the problem of the South during the Civil war. In these work
there were numerous facts of domestic nature, including the rules of dating and
courtship, marriage and related issues of the rights and responsibilities of
women, the issues of procreation and education of girls, allowing to gave an
accurate picture of the specificity of life.
[6]
K. Dillman
drew attention to the fact to be necessary to distinguish the concept of
"Southern Women" and the concept "Women in the South,"
because only one fact of residence in the territory of the South did not give
grounds to speak about particular attitude, special behaviors and the ways of
self-identification, of American southern woman. [6]
Researchers
at the phenomenon of "Southern women" often refered to the written
testimony women lived in the South parts of the world.
At the
same time the used diaries and texts of writers in the south region to find out
a more complete picture of the southerners and their role and place in the
social life of the South of the century.
[12]
Due to the
fact that literacy in the Old South was the
privilege of the white population, naturally, a novel a memoir text were
belonged on white women not from the slave, or more or less independent
households, and hence their affidavits represented some ideological and
philosophical concept. [11]
So far, in
fact, only one widely known written evidence of black southerners, a former
slave, related to the prewar period. This is memoir Harriet Jacobs «Incidents in the Life of a
Slave girl: Written by Herself», 1801, and today they are the most cited in the
works, which investigated the status of and the situation of Southern women.
Only in
2001 in the newspaper "New York Times" published an article by D.
Kirkpatrick that has just discovered three hundred page texts entitled
"The Bonds – Woman Narrative». At the preliminary conclusion of experts a
found text is written as a novel with the date 1857, and its author is a
runaway slave Jane Jenson. Today it is the earliest known novels written by
black women.
As for the
white women of simple estates, which belonged to salaried workers, their voice
was completely absent in the southern women's literature.
By the time
of the rise of interest in the study of
the literary heritage of the South coincided with the rapid development of
gender studies in the United States and has been associated with the release in
1953 of the English edition of Simone de Beauvoir's "The Second Sex".
He was the
first to attempt and integrate consideration of the specifics of literary
creativity of women XIX century.
American
and English scientists also discovered the names of forgotten Southern writers of the century, some of which
would later be numbered among the classics of American literature. An example,
American scientists study the creative legacy of Kate Chopin (1850-1904), and
it is now included in the national literary anthology and is recommended for
required reading at the philological faculties of American universities.
Literature
1. Allen E. A Woman's place in
the novels of H. James. L.: Macmillan Press, 1984.-223 p.
2. N. Bame Women's Prose: A
Guide to novels written by women for women in America 1820-1870 period, V.
IV-V, 1987, N-Y. - 99 p.
3. Baym N. Woman's fiction. A
Guide to Novels by and about women in America, 1820-1870, IV-V, - 1990, N-Y, -
90 p.
4. Belyavskaya I.A. Women's
issue in the United States in the XIX century (Problems and currents). // American, 1982. M .: Science,
1982. - p.38-65.
5. Clinton С. The Plantation Mistress:
Woman’s World in the Old South. New York: Pantheon Books, 1982. - 331 p.
6. Columbia Literary History
of the United States. / Ed. by E.
Elliot. N.Y.: Columbia Univ. press,
1988. – 122 p.
7. Dillman S.M. The Sparsity
of Research and Publications on Southern Women: Definitional Complexities,
Methodological Problems, and Other Impediments. // Southern Women. New-York, 1988. – 78 p.
8. Douglas A. The Feminization
of American Culture. N.Y.: Doubleday, 1988. - 405 p.
9. Dvoynishnikova T.F. Dostoevsky:
results and prospects of the study: on a material of Russian and English-
language literary (1970-2000) / Diss.
cand. filol. Ulan-Ude.-299 p.
10. Evans S. Birth of freedom.
The history of American women. M .: Progress, 1993. - 320 p.
11. Fetterley J. Pryse M.
Writing But Of Place: Regionalism, Women and American Literary Culture. -
Urbana: University of Illinois
Press, 2002. - 480 p.
12. De Grave K. Swindler, Spy,
Rebel: The Confederate Woman in the 19th "Century America. Columbia:
University of Missouri Press, 1995. - 240 p.
13. Gwin М. Black and White Women of
the Old South: The Peculiar Sisterhood in American Literature. Knoxville: University
of Tennessee Press, 1985. - 238 p.
14. Gorelova L.H. New
approaches in the study of English literature. // Philological Notes. - Saransk, 2001, - p.70-79.
15. Gushina T.V. Artistic and
functions of female characters novel F.Dostoevsky's "The Brothers
Karamazov." / Diss.
cand. filol., 2004, 180 p.
16. A History of the United
States of America .: In 4 volumes, - VII (1877-1918). - Science, 1985.-600 p.
17. Kostina EV "Women's
Topic" in the American novel (1870-1910) / Diss. cand. filol., М., 2003. – 194 p.
18. Miloslavskaya S.K.,
U.D.Howells and Russian literature. / Diss.
cand. filol. М., 1974. –
170 p.
19. Mitina
O.V. Female gender behavior in the social and cultural aspects. // Social studies and the
present, 1999. №3. – p. 79-191.
20. Morozov TL The dispute
about man in American literature: history and modernity. M .: Nauka, 1990-331
p.
21. Mulyarchik A. Restless
women's hearts. // Mulyarchik
A. USA: twentieth century. The faces
of the literary process. Moscow, Minsk, Baronovichi, 1984. - p. 67-298.
22. Savchenko LF Business
woman. // USA: economics, politics,
ideology, 1990. № 3. - p. 121-127.
23. Vetlovskaya VE "The
ideal of the Madonna" in "The Brothers Karamazov." // Dostoyevsky: Materials
research. S.-Peterburg. Science,
2000. -p. 305-
333.
24. Voronina O.V. The ideology
of the feminist movement. // USA:
Economics, politics, ideology, 1980. № 9. p. 38-49.
25. Wyatt Brown B. The Shaping
of Southern Culture: Honor, Grace, and War, 1760-1880 s. The University of North
Carol in Press, 2001 - 412 p.