Musin Kuat
Saniyazdanovich
Department of constitutional and international law,
Karaganda State University named after Evnei Arystanovich Buketov, Karaganda,
Kazakhstan
Role of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization in foreign policy of
Kazakhstan
Before starting
disclosure of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation and a role of Kazakhstan in
this international organization it is necessary to study prerequisites of
emergence of the foreign policy relations of Kazakhstan. Analyzing the
introduction of interstate policy of the Kazakh khanate and modern Kazakhstan,
it is possible to notice analogy of introduction of foreign policy between
modern policy of Kazakhstan and the policy pursued by governors of the Kazakh
khanate. At the time of existence of the Kazakh khanate, his governors
maneuvered between powerful empires Imperial Russia and Tsin Empire, thereby
conducting a two-track policy that most likely prolonged existence of the
Kazakh statehood [1]. At the end of the 20th century after finding of
independence one of the priority problems of foreign policy of Kazakhstan was
an adjustment of cooperation between the countries of the international scene.
Our current president N. A. Nazarbayev outlined contours of Kazakhstan’s
foreign policy, having designated its multi-vector character, having noted that
"Republic has to have a reasonable balance between Europe and Asia.
Though, certainly, Kazakh people have deep joint roots with the Turkic
people" [2]. Already the first initiatives of sovereign Kazakhstan showed
to the world community peaceful character of foreign policy of our republic
directed on creation of the atmosphere of mutual trust and cooperation, on
development of equal relations with all states and the international
organizations. Foreign policy activity of Kazakhstan at the initial stages of
its formation was directed for creation favorable macro - and the
micro-political relations for worthy entry of Kazakhstan to the world
community. In more than 20 years from the moment of independence finding
Kazakhstan achieved unknown heights almost in all fields of activity including
foreign policy, having proved as the independent and full subject of the
international relations. It is caused by its favorable geographical position on
border of two continents, Europe and Asia, between key participants of the
international relations, the Russian Federation and People's Republic of China.
Now Kazakhstan is deservedly perceived on the international scene having built
thereby the relations of friendship and mutually beneficial cooperation with
the neighboring and leading states. Main foreign policy priorities are
protection of national interests abroad, advance of peacekeeping initiatives,
ensuring regional and global security, protection of the rights and interests
of our citizens, attraction of direct foreign investments, strengthening of the
international and bilateral cooperation. Today Kazakhstan is the active member
of many international organizations, among them are UN, OSCE, SCO, OIC, the
CSTO, the CIS and others. Kazakhstan signed more than three thousand
international treaties of interstate, intergovernmental and interdepartmental
level. I emphasize in more detail on such international organization as the
Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO), on its prerequisites of emergence,
problems and prospects, a role and a place of Kazakhstan in the Shanghai
Cooperation Organisation. The 60th years of the XX century were put prerequisites
to creation of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation when USSR and the People's
Republic of China entered negotiations on permission of territorial disputes.
After disintegration of the Soviet Union there were new negotiators in the
person of Russia and the states of Central Asia. After the People's Republic of
China resolved territorial disputes with the neighboring states of the CIS
(Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan), there was a possibility of
further development of regional cooperation [3]. As the uniting factor the main
role was played by the civil war in Afghanistan between troops of Northern
alliance and the Taliban creating a threat to security of all five states. Due
to the sharp activization of the international terrorism, religious extremism
and ethnic separatism 1996 and 1997, heads of five states at meetings in
Shanghai and Moscow signed "The agreement on confidence-building in
military area in border areas" and "The agreement on mutual reduction
of armed forces in border areas" that became the important historical
stage which led to start of the mechanism under the name "Shanghai
Five". The subsequent annual summits of participants of the Shanghai five
took place in Moscow in 1997, Alma-Ata (Kazakhstan) in 1998, in Bishkek (Kyrgyzstan)
in 1999 and to Dushanbe (Tajikistan) in 2000.
By the time of
carrying out the Bishkek summit creation of constant mechanisms of cooperation
began: meetings of ministers and expert groups, there were national
coordinators appointed by each country, "The Bishkek group" was
created where heads of law enforcement agencies and intelligence services for
fight against border crime entered. The new international organization started
developing. In 2001 the meeting was held in Shanghai. Then five member countries
admitted Uzbekistan that entailed renaming of the organization into the
Shanghai Cooperation Organisation or "The Shanghai six" to structure
of the organization. The first documents accepted by SCO, "Declaration on
Creation of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation", "Shanghai
Convention on Fight Against Terrorism, Separatism and Extremism" and
"Joint Statement on Connection of Uzbekistan to the Mechanism
"Shanghai Five "" steel. The declaration on creation of SCO is
signed at a meeting of heads of six states in Shanghai on June 15, 2001. At the
summit in St. Petersburg the Charter of SCO (I came into force on September 19,
2003) — the basic authorized document fixing the purposes, the principles,
structure and the main activities of the Organization is accepted on June 7,
2002.
Signing in
Bishkek became on August 16, 2007 an important step in strengthening of legal
base of association. The contract on long-term neighborliness, friendship and
cooperation which creates prerequisites for a conclusion of versatile
interaction to qualitatively new level. So far ratification procedures were
finished by Kyrgyzstan, China and Russia [4]. Proceeding from "The
Shanghai spirit" in the relations in the organization, member states of
SCO adhere to the principles of mutual trust, mutual benefit, equality, mutual
consultations, respect for variety of cultures and aspiration to joint
development, and in external relations adheres to the principle of not
alliance, not an orientation against someone and openness. As for structure of
SCO that the supreme body for decision-making in SCO is Council of heads of
member states (SGG), he gathers once a year and makes decisions and
instructions on all important questions of the organization. The following
supreme body of SCO is Council of heads of governments of member states of SCO
(SGP), he gathers for discussion of strategy of multilateral cooperation and
the priority directions within the organization, the solution of fundamental
and topical issues of economic and other cooperation once a year, and also
approves the annual budget of the organization. Also, there operates the mechanism of meetings at the level of
heads of parliaments, secretaries of security councils, Ministers of Foreign
Affairs, defenses, emergency situations, economy, transport, culture,
education, health care, heads of law-enforcement departments, the Supreme and
arbitration courts, Generals Attorneys. Council of national coordinators of
member states (SNK) of SCO serves as the coordination mechanism within SCO. The
organization has two permanent bodies - the Secretariat in Beijing, Executive
committee of Regional anti-terrorist structure in Tashkent. Also at the
organization there is created the Interbank Consortium. The general secretary
and the Director of Executive committee are appointed by Council of Heads of
states for a period of three years. Since January 1, 2013 these posts are held
by D.F.Mezentsev (Russia) and Zhang Sinfen (China). The total area of member
states of SCO equals about 30 million 189 thousand sq.km that makes 3/5 areas
of Eurasia, and the population - 1.5 billion. the person that makes 1/4 all
population of the globe [5].
All years of
existence as the independent state of Kazakhstan I pursued very sure foreign
policy, entering various international organizations. Kazakhstan - is one of
five countries standing at the origins of emergence of the Shanghai Cooperation
Organisation. In this organization Kazakhstan takes a key place because of the
geographical arrangement in the center of the territory of SCO. Cooperation
within SCO is the priority direction of foreign policy of Kazakhstan. The
president of Kazakhstan N. Nazarbayev specifies that the fastest formation of
SCO as the authoritative international organization is one of the priority
strategic directions of foreign policy of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Active
creative work of all member states of the organization has to become a powerful
factor in ensuring regional and global security, in dynamic development of
multilateral trade and economic cooperation. Experts consider that
participation of Kazakhstan in the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation becomes
more and more fruitful now. SCO took very important place in foreign policy of
the country, from time to time restricting other directions. It is connected
with that the leadership of Kazakhstan realizes that important role which by
the present moment plays Kazakhstan on the world scene as a peculiar bridge
between Europe and Asia and in the power sphere, and in geopolitics [6]. Owing to
the geopolitical situation Kazakhstan in principle can't pursue unilateral
policy, be guided on someone "force pole". Kazakhstan is compelled to
balance constantly between interests of large powers and only so can
effectively provide the national interests.
I dictated
participation in SCO to Kazakhstan and an instinct of the state
self-preservation: at the beginning of the XXI century of national security of
the republic many challenges are thrown down. Among them both the international
terrorism, and "export" of
radical Islam, both arms trafficking and drugs, and streams of illegal
migration. Alone it would be too difficult to cope with them. Therefore it
isn't casual that one of the first and major documents of SCO is the Convention
on fight against terrorism, separatism and extremism. As B. Nurgaliyev, the
former ambassador of Kazakhstan noted - "It is well-known that the
president of Kazakhstan Nursultan Nazarbayev pays priority attention to the
questions connected with SCO. Kazakhstan is one of consecutive supporters of
the regional integration based on coinciding or close understanding of both new
calls, and prospects of transformation of the Euroasian space into the region
of the world, stability and wellbeing". Interaction within SCO allowed Kazakhstan
to settle a number of controversial territorial issues, and systematic and
transparent reduction of armed forces in border areas discharged residual
elements of military-political intensity. Besides, the intensification of a
mutually advantageous trade and economic exchange between SCO member countries
significantly influences the general strategic landscape of the region,
displacing accents from military-political area in area of peaceful economic
interaction. On June 11, 2010 Kazakhstan admitted the chairman's duties to SCO.
One of the main priorities of Kazakhstan on a post of the head of SCO is
peacekeeping, safety and stability in the region of Central Asia. Speaking at
the summit of the organization the President of Kazakhstan Nursultan Nazarbayev
declared that assistance of Kyrgyzstan will become one of presidency
priorities. In this regard the head of the republic urged the countries of SCO
to help "to overcome Kyrgyzstan present difficulties, to preserve the
peace and stability, to move on the way of improvement in the social and
economic sphere". Despite an external monolithic look, experts note a
number of problems on which contradictions in policy of members of SCO the most
serious of which concerns a divergence of political and economic interests of
the powers of Russia and China which are observed. China, considering SCO
countries as a perspective sales market, considers that priorities of SCO
between anti-terrorist and economic activity have to share equally, and in the
long term economic strategy can take the main place in activity of the
organization. Russia, on the contrary, insists on preservation of traditional
activity of SCO in the field of fight against manifestations of "three
evils" (on terminology of SCO): terrorism, extremism and separatism and,
being afraid of establishment of economic hegemony of China in Post-Soviet
Asia, makes efforts to constrain offers of Beijing on an intensification of
economic cooperation within SCO. However, China can be not interested in
building of a military, anti-terrorist component unlike Russia and the
countries of Central Asia as China generally solved a problem (Uigur)
terrorism. Disagreements between China and Russia are brightly shown concerning
questions of expansion of the organization. In particular disagreement between
them concerning reception of new members in SCO. This disagreement is shown, in
particular, that Russia supports the accession to the organization (the
traditional ally) of India and in this regard agrees to accession (traditionally
friendly to China of Pakistan) while China treats similar plans enough
watchfully. It is obvious that similar expansion (and first of all in view of
the entry of India) will create a considerable counterbalance to China and,
undoubtedly, for a long time will slow down any plans for creation of a free
trade zone within SCO. In June, 2011 (on the eve of the summit of SCO in
Astana) the President of Kazakhstan N. A. Nazarbayev declared that desire of a
number of the countries - observers of SCO to become full members of the
organization is "quite reasonable", but at the same time "the
future expansion of SCO shouldn't become end in itself and furthermore to go to
damage of the organization or to substitute original sense of its existence"
[7]. This vision found understanding and at other countries of the Shanghai
alliance, and, as a result, at the following summit in Beijing member states of
the organization made, in particular, the decision that the countries which are
under sanctions of the UN Security Council (as, for example, Iran), can't
become members of SCO.
Despite developed
problems the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, expressing the general
aspiration of the people of member states, continues to work successfully in
interests of the world, cooperation and development. Realization in practice of
the principles of "the Shanghai spirit" – mutual trust, mutual
benefit, equality, mutual consultations, respect of variety of cultures,
aspiration to joint development, promoted formation of effective model of the
interstate relations of friendship and cooperation. The organization, combining
efforts of member states, I became the guarantor of the world and forward
development, ensures safety, stability and development on space of SCO,
resolutely resists to terrorism, separatism, extremism, a drug trafficking and
cross-border organized crime, develops regional cooperation, strengthening the
relations of neighborliness and trust. Member states consistently make efforts
on confidence-building in military area around border and take necessary
measures in order to avoid border disputes for the benefit of the world,
tranquility and stability. Member states will and strengthen cooperation within
the Organization for removal it on the new level and transformations of space
of SCO into the region of the long-term world, friendship, prosperity and
harmony from now on [8].
Creation of SCO
served the solution of the main problems of modern mankind (terrorism,
extremism, separatism) having prevented thereby many threats to security
concerning SCO member countries. Thus the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation
collected in a fist all forces of fight against terrorism, extremism,
separatism for the sake of safety and stability, the world and prosperity of
the countries of the Shanghai six. Further development of this organization has
to reduce significantly quantity of acts of terrorism, prevent extremism and
separatism, to develop economic, political and other relations between the
participating states of SCO.
1. Ablay-khan.
Domestic and foreign policy. R. B. Suleymenov, V.A. Moiseyev. Almaty,
"Zhazushy", 2001.
2. Zhigalov K.V.,
Sultanov B. K. First president of the Republic of Kazakhstan Nursultan
Nazarbayev. The chronicle of activity (1.12.1991 — 31.05.1993). - Almaty, 1993.
– P. 8 — 9.
3. Komissina I.
N., Kurtov A.A. Shanghai Cooperation Organisation. – 252 ð.
4.http://newsruss.ru
5.http://www.sectsco.org
6. Increasing
role of Kazakhstan in SCO // Novoye Vremya. -
24.05.10.
7. Nazarbayev H.A.
SCO: ten years of history. Russian newspaper. - June 3, 2011.
8. DECLARATION of
heads of member states of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation on creation of
the region of the long-term world and joint prosperity // http://www.akorda.kz