The concept of «Islamic solidarity» as the foundation
in the creation of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation
Mussayeva E. – senior
lecturer, Master of Laws, Karaganda
Economic University (Kazakhstan)
Nazarov Y. –
senior lecturer, Master of History, Karaganda Economic University (Kazakhstan)
Talimova G. –
senior lecturer, Master of Economy, Karaganda Economic University (Kazakhstan)
Summary: Creation
of the Organization of Islamic Conference (OIC)
became an important step for the formation of foreign policy paradigm of muslim
states. All the steps to create the OIC in
international relations as the main organization of islamic countries made
within the concept of «islamic solidarity». The article examines as
historical so political preconditions for the establishment of the OIC, as well
as main objectives and reasons that gave rise to organization of muslim states
to create the OIC. In this regard, the OIC under the concept of «islamic solidarity» for the right
to occupy a central place in the islamic world and it is a key organ of cooperation of
the states with a large number of muslim population.
Keywords: foreign policy, contemporary international
relations, Organization of Islamic Conference, International organizations, integration,
Middle East, Islam, history of Islamic world, pan-islamism.
Throughout world
history, the main integrating force was the idea or concept, which became the
main factor for the overall identification sufficiently large regions. At the
end of the XIX century this idea was revived in the islamic world, where people
live in conditions of colonial policy of the european states. This fact
influenced on the occurrence in the national liberation ideologies of two
mutually exclusive tendencies - pan-islamism and nationalism young bourgeoisie.
Pan-islamism as a
religious political movement arose in the second half of the XIX century and
closely related to the activities of Seyda Jamal al-Din Afghani (1839 – 1897yy.).
He formulated the idea of «religious-political alliance of muslim nations».
Pan-islamism was defined as «the unity of the world of islam (Dar al-Islam) in
one powerful group, whose aim is the embodiment of the principles of the Koran.
This islamic group is capable of always and everywhere opposes any course of
human thought ...» [1;11].
Muslim countries of
east al-Afghani compared with brooked shipwreck - should act as the passengers
of the ship: either together to save the ship, or to think everyone about
yourself? In this formulation of the question every true muslim should save the
ship islam. Al-Afghani developed fundamental principles of pan-islamism:
- firstly, the
abandonment of the concepts introduced by the virtue of their alienation from
the islamic society and unfitness for it;
- secondly, to confirm
the basic principle of pan-islamism - islam is true for all times and places [1;11].
Pan-islamism
opposes international spirit of the theory of the muslim brotherhood «regional
narrowness». In the historical and political practice the idea of pan-islamism
is used to support the trend towards hegemony of one of the muslim states. So,
if in its initial stages pan-islamism was a tool to strengthen the Ottoman
Empire, after World War II it became an instrument of rivalry between Pakistan,
Saudi Arabia, Iran, Libya and several other countries for hegemony in the muslim
world. This view is shared by some muslim scholars, such as pakistani author
Fateh M. Sando said: «If idealists and theorists have constantly emphasized the
need for unity of the muslim world, the practice is rarely showed interest in
this problem. Mainly they were busy narrow local objectives: the conservation
of power in the region, maintaining personal prestige or concern about these or
other limited interest» [1;25].
Most fully pan-islamism
is represented in ideology and practice of the organization «Muslim Brotherhood»:
the world is divided into two parts: the world of islam and the «new barbarism»;
for the salvation of mankind, steeped in the «new barbarism», it is necessary
to establish a theocracy; return to the caliphate - the best way to social
justice; the salvation of mankind - a return to God. The central elements of
the concept of pan-islamism is the superclass, supranational «muslim unity», a
worldwide community of the faithful, that is, pan-islamism is theory of the islamic
cosmopolitanism with its characteristics, which does not recognize the
existence of nations, but proclaims the unity of all muslim nations.
The process of implementing
the concept of pan-islamism in the area of the spread of islam prevents a whole
group of factors, the main ones are: the contradiction between the
feudal-nationalist and radical regimes; differences in socio-political and
socio-economic development; rivalry for leadership in the muslim world that
unfolded between countries with different social systems (Saudi Arabia,
Pakistan, Iran, Iraq, Egypt, Libya); the desire of some countries to pursue an
independent foreign policy; unresolved national issues affecting the territory
of several states (problems: the Palestinian, Kurdish, Baluchi, «Pashtunistan»);
the presence of mutual territorial claims (Saudi Arabia - Oman, Iraq - Kuwait,
Iraq - Iran, Morocco - Algeria, Iran - Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia - Yemen, Saudi
Arabia - Iraq, Iran - United Arab Emirates, Iran - Bahrain, etc.); differences
and contradictions between the main branch of islam (sunni and shia), which
play a role in the increasing complexity of interstate contradictions of muslim
countries; by virtue of its participation in various international and regional
organizations, muslim countries can not ignore their obligations for the sake
of «islamic solidarity». The contradictions between the public interest and
religious communities are not always clearly resolved in favor of islamic
unity.
In general, religious
alternative to the colonial dependencies underlying the concept of pan-islamism,
of course, had some progressive potential of the struggle for national
liberation in the early XX century.
After the first
World War, in region of the spread of islam had changed dramatically, to create
preconditions for the emergence of alternative pan-islamism trends. The
collapse of the Ottoman Empire, the creation of the League of Nations, the
elimination of the caliphate in 1924 led to an increase regional nationalism.
The concept of pan-islamism contrary to the ideology of nationalism in terms of
fundamentals and objectives of the struggle for independence: pan-islamism was
expecting the unification of all muslims in a single state, and nationalist
approach demanded independence within the borders of the emerging nation.
In the context of
Turkey, where the nationalist concept of «healthy Turkism» had been implemented
in the form of the ideology of state power and the organization of society on
the basis of the republic; measures were taken to separate religion from the
state, such as the abolition of the sultanate, and then caliphate, closing religious
schools and orders of dervishes; were adopted criminal and civil codes based on
western concepts of law, abolished the institution «Sheikh-ul-islamat» and the
ministry of waqf, created the office of
religious affairs; in a special amendment to the ñonstitution of 1928 was pointed separation of church from state,
abolished the position of islam as the state religion. M. Kemal (1881-1936 yy.)
- the leader of the national liberation revolution in Turkey in 1917-1923 years
- constantly pointed to the unacceptability of ottomanism, panturkism and
panislamism. Essential elements of the anti-imperialist concept of Kemal were as
follows: anti-imperialism, national sovereignty, the condemnation of the economic
policy of monarchs (sultans) [2;72].
Each of the concept - a regional
nationalism, pan-arabism
and pan-islamism - contained
elements of anti-imperialist orientation. However, as a rule, carriers of pan-islamism and pan-arabism in interstate
terms were and are monarchist-feudal regimes and their ideologues, the critique
of imperialism was paralleled by anti-communism, putting forward as an ideal
«golden age» of the caliphate.
And of course, the center of the caliphate would have become the capital of the state - the
initiator of pan-islamic or pan-arabic movement.
This situation in the zone of
spreading islam
created the preconditions for the emergence of the concept of «islamic solidarity» as the
most flexible intermediate (between the national form of existence of the muslim countries and the
ultimate goal - the creation of a single islamic state) formula idea of
intergovernmental cooperation and the imperative of unity on a religious basis.
Country created islamic centers, islamic centers in these
countries put forward the movement's leaders. World Islamic Congress puts
Pakistan on the move «islamic solidarity» as a true «islamic state». Academy of Islamic
Studies at Al-Azhar puts Egypt as the leader of this movement. In turn, League of Islamic World (further - League, LIW) qualifies Saudi Arabia as
a «chosen by Allah ground ... winner of two major shrines of islam - Mecca and Medina» [3;53].
With the creation of Pakistan in
1947 (literally – «the country of the faithful») on the basis of the religious community of muslims in the area of the
spread of islam
there is another plus: islamization in the form of a sovereign state. According
to the russian researcher V.
Moskalenko, «the policy of islamization of Pakistan was not a spontaneous burst of
expression of religious feelings of the population, and was carried out under
the full control on top of the secular power. Islamic theologians in this played clearly
subordinate role» [4;62].
Founder and leader
of the party «Jamaat-e-Islami» in Pakistan Abul Ala Maududi (1903 - 1979 yy.)
is a recognized author in the development of modern conditions the concept of «islamic
state». He put forward the four principles of organization and functioning of
the islamic state:
1. The supreme
power in the islamic state belongs to God, the government acts as a deputy
(Caliph) of God on earth.
2. The shariah is
the fundamental law of the country.
3. Existing legislation
must not contradict sharia.
4. The state should
not transgress the «border», established by islam [5;113].
In practice
prevailed over a steady trend towards the establishment of international
theological-religious and government's attempts to combine several muslim
states.
Already in may 1926
at the Congress in Cairo (30 delegates from 11 muslim countries, there were no
islamic organizations from Afghanistan, Iran, India, Sudan and Turkey) was
adopted an appeal to the muslim world to promote the formation of a new
caliphate.
At the first World
Islamic Congress (WIC) in Mecca in june 1926 (60 delegates) failed to agree on
the need for such congresses. The second congress WIC was held in 1931 in
Jerusalem, where the movement of pan-islamism in the 20s and early 30s really
resist the expansion of Zionism.
1949 and 1951 took
place on 3 and 4 session of the World islamic congress. At this congress was
developed à charter of the organization
and made statements contained a requirement that all governments of the world
of non-interference in the affairs of the World islamic congress.
Thus, all the
meetings of heads of muslim countries and communities, conducted in the period
between the First and Second World Wars, could not have any decisive importance
for the development of the general muslim movement. At the same time, these
attempts interstate association created certain prerequisites for integration
in the region spread the muslim religion and culture.
In 1962, in Baghdad
and in 1964 in the city of Mogadishu were held on 5 and 6 session of the World
Islamic Congress. The headquarters of the World islamic congress is located in
Karachi (Pakistan).
League of Islamic
World is the most influential among the theological and religious organizations,
founded by Saudi Arabia in 1962 and headquartered in Mecca. Thus Mecca became
the center of an alternative Pakistani influence in the movement of pan-islamism
and its modifications. This non-governmental islamic organization was formed to
promote islam, organizing the pilgrimage to Mecca, promote the construction of
mosques. The first forum of LIW adopted a Charter, proclaiming strengthening islamic
solidarity, the dissemination of ideas of islam, support constant contacts with
leading religious figures and scientists, to establish and develop close
relations with muslim adherents who live outside the traditional islamic area,
as well as «support for holy war everywhere, wherever it arose» [6;15].
The idea of
creation of the league was agreed and adopted by initiated by the king Saud
meeting of leaders of muslim organizations in Mecca in 1962. LIW now brings
together the main muslim organizations and society, the largest of which are
the High Council of Mosques, the Permanent Committee on the Honouring of
Islamic law, International Islamic Relief Organization. The supreme body is the
Congress.
At the same time,
the structure LIW is not clearly defined. This organization is trying to
respond to major regional and global challenges the integrity of the Islamic
world. However, it does not seek to develop mechanisms to address common to all
Muslim countries problems of an economic and social nature, which determined
its weakness and relative inefficiency, reducing the activities of the League
of Islamic World to the proclamation of political declarations more general
nature.
In April 1965, a
session of the World Islamic Conference held in Mecca on the initiative of
Saudi King Faisal bin Abdul Aziz Al Saud, at which the king made a call for creation
a military-political alliance of Muslim countries - Islamic Pact. In the
context of the growing confrontation between the Soviet Union and the United
States and gained prominence non-aligned movement countries of the third world,
that idea did not find wide response among the developing countries of Asia and
Africa. However, the authorities of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia still returns
to the project of Faisal to establish peace unified armed forces of the muslim
world.
1969 became a
turning point for the creation of a new mechanism of consolidation of state
sponsors of common religious values. The reason for this was an incident with
arson the third most important religious shrines and sacred to all muslims
mosque Al-Aqsa in Jerusalem by Israeli extremist. This event shook the all islamic world and caused a strong protest among
the muslim population. Four days after the incident, on 25th august,
the foreign ministers of fourteen arab states went to Cairo to decide to hold a
summit of leaders of islamic countries in order to protect muslim holy sites.
In the same year,
on a wave of public indignation in the muslim area, political representatives from 28 Asian and African countries met
in Rabat (Morocco) to create coordinating center that on the principle of
religious solidarity could provide protection shrines of islam. The heads of muslim
states pledged to jointly safeguard the rights and interests of the muslim ummah,
to support the Palestinian people in their struggle for the liberation of
Palestine, and to consult on how to strengthen cooperation and mutual
assistance in the economic, scientific, cultural and spiritual areas, in
accordance with the immortal teachings of islam. In this regard, in the basis
for the new organization was based the principle of consolidation with
countries where the majority of inhabitants are muslim. To achieve this goal,
it was decided to establish a new international structure.
As a result of
matching the positions of the muslim east, in 1970 I and II Conference of
Foreign Ministers in Jeddah and Karachi was formalized education interstate coordinating
center - of the «Islamic Conference». The General Secretariat of the
organization and its head were elected and the temporary seat of the Organization
of Islamic Conference (OIC) «until the liberation of Jerusalem» became Jeddah.
Two years later, in
February-March 1972, at the third conference of foreign ministers in Jeddah was
adopted charter of the organization, according to which the application for
admission must be submitted to the OIC General Secretariat and approved at the
next conference of foreign ministers. For approval is necessary to collect 2/3
of the votes of the participants [7].
The OIC is the
largest and most influential Muslim formal intergovernmental international
organization. Currently, it unites 57 countries with a population of over 1.4
billion people. According to the number of participating countries, OIC is the
second institutional structure after UN in the world. The objectives of the OIC
- joint actions to strengthen islamic solidarity and large-scale cooperation
between Member States in the political, economic and social fields, conducting
peaceful policy emanating from the fundamental canons and aimed at preserving islamic
values, as well as support for the muslim peoples in the protection of freedom
and independence. In particular, support for the Palestinian people to
establish an independent state and the preservation of islam's holy places in
its territory. As we know, these issues have not lost their relevance and
determine the international agenda in the current context of globalization.
The basic
principles of the OIC - full equality, respect for the rights of every people
to self-determination, non-interference in internal affairs, respect for
sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity of states, the solution of
disputes between member countries of the OIC peacefully through negotiation,
mediation or arbitration, non-use of force or threat of application. All this
is fully consistent with the cornerstone principles of the UN activities [8].
OIC suggests multifaceted
cooperation between the «islamic state» based on religion («islamic solidarity»).
The organization is an intercontinental character, its universality claim to
the level of the UN in the directions of their activities, but it is limited to
the member states belonging to the «Ummah» - a religious community of people
who practice islam, even if muslims do not make up the majority of the
population in some countries, that is practiced in the reception states that
only in the future, after the appropriate changes in their society on the basis
of the postulates of islam, can become full members of the movement «islamic
solidarity». In this regard, the islamic international organizations - it intermediates
in the process of «realization of the idea of global Islamic solidarity» [1;70]
as stated by King Faisal of Saudi Arabia at the opening of the I ñonference of heads of state and government of the
islamic countries in september 1969 (Rabat, Morocco).
The strengths of
the OIC are:
• the leading role
of the rich oil-producing states, together with some other countries of the
islamic region controlling huge reserves of strategic raw materials - oil,
natural gas;
• the existence of
certain levers of influence on Western Europe and North America by investing a
significant proportion of petrodollars in Western economies;
• considerable
resources and vast territory, which is crucial to influence the contemporary
international relations [8].
However, on the
activities of the organization affects the extreme heterogeneity of the
socio-political structures and ideological orientations of the ruling regimes
in the muslim world. They share different approaches to major international and
foreign policy issues, differences in the forms and methods of use of islamic
tenets in domestic and foreign policy between fundamentalists and moderates
supporters. From here lack of a clear overall strategy of the OIC in politics
and the economy, maintaining the sharp contradictions. Thus, in the muslim
world there is confrontation between the two main trends: on the one hand, the
trend of consolidation of muslim states and their isolation in world politics
and economy, on the other - the internal differentiation of islamic region in
the ideological, political, economic and social basis. Both trends are
reflected in the activities of the association.
In the history of
the OIC organization «islamic solidarity» played a key role, but it was not a
reflection of the «islamic integration» and was conceived as a tool to activate
the pan-islamism in modern conditions with the relevant international legal
registration of constituent documents. That is, the further development of the
Middle East crisis was used by Saudi Arabia to create under its aegis focal
point «islamic state».
Attempts to unlock
the conflicts in the ways of «islamic solidarity» with the use of the OIC and
its missions for the settlement did not give any results. This indicates that
the religious aspects in the activities of the OIC is increasingly replaced by
political stance on important issues of our time, including on the key issues
of war and peace.
It is crucial that the
formation of the structure of the OIC pragmatic wing of the muslim world failed
to defend the secular nature of the organization. This allowed the early stages
of development to overcome its religious seclusion and out of the plane of
religious and political confrontation with the rest of the world to channel
into defending the interests of the axis of South – North.
Against the
backdrop of the collapse of the UN system and its substitution mechanisms of US
and NATO coalition, operations OIC to intervene in the internal affairs of
other countries remains unnoticed.
Organization of the
Islamic conference and its subsidiary bodies system, specialized agencies and
affiliated institutions became a reality of modern international relations. Its
effectiveness is the main issue - the maintenance of international peace and
security, as well as the development of cooperation between the states of the
spread of islam - is questionable. It is difficult to part with their national
interests for states, even if the religious factor is listed in the national
interest.
Thus, the OIC was
founded as a response to the challenges of the muslim world, which comes from
the resulting policy in the middle east Israel, supported by the western world,
especially the United States. In the postwar period, almost all states of the
muslim east were involved in the global geopolitical struggle between the two
world systems. But the incompatibility of the norms and values of islam with
the communist essentially atheistic ideology, on the one hand, and capitalist,
with its consumer culture - on the other, did the muslim population as a whole
immune to the policy of the USSR and the USA.
From the
dissolution of the caliphate to the establishment of the Organization of Islamic Conference in 1969, the carriers of
the idea of pan-islamism were World Islamic Congress (WIC) and the League of
Islamic World. Theological non-governmental organizations in fact are the
guardians of the «purity» of islam. They
entrusted with the development of various issues related to the
theological justification of the most important problems of Islamic
intergovernmental organization. Much attention is paid to their activities in
the theory of international «islamic solidarity», the concept of an «islamic
state», developed draft constitution, with «muslim vision» of the world as a
whole. As WIC and LIW have consultative status with the UN.
The formula «Ummah
- religious community - isolidarity - islamic bloc - a single islamic state»
not implemented in practice, and there is a severe contradiction when trying to
implement it, so stands the idea of «islamic solidarity» as the most
practicable in modern conditions the formula for relations between muslim
countries.
The modern movement
«islamic solidarity» is not recognized by theorists, but is widely represented
political practices, including at the state level, who see the result of their
activities output muslim organizations and countries from the United Nations
and the founding of the United Muslim nations with its Security Council, the
formation of the muslim «common market», creating a united muslim armed forces
with a unified military command, so that muslim countries will become the third
force in the world, independent from the capitalist and communist powers.
The concept of «islamic solidarity» can be
regarded as the most important foreign policy principle of muslim countries towards
the realization of the ideas of pan-islamism. In any case, it is a wish to it her theologians and
politicians regimes acting for the practical implementation of this concept. In
this regard, the idealization of «islamic solidarity» in international relations is a
manifestation of religious-oriented branch in the development of the theory and
practice of international relations. The emergence of financial capacity in a number of
oil-producing muslim
countries in conjunction with the changed configuration of international
relations were perceived initiated and inspired movements «islamic solidarity» in the
literal sense as a green light to start the restructuring of international
relations in the islamic
model on the way to the islamic world order.
However, assessing the realities
of the XXI century, the movement of «islamic solidarity» in the face of the Organization of Islamic
Conference to state that «the spread of the phenomenon of globalization in all
spheres of life, and in particular the liberalization of trade, unlimited flow
of information and the development of communication and technology to shorten
the distance and turned the world into a small village universal», and that «the
construction of a bridge across the gulf in international relations that arose
in connection with the adverse effects of globalization is not just a moral
obligation, but also a vital imperative goal, the achievement of which calls
for establishment of international partnerships and social justice to the same
extent as to achieve equality in access to the fruits of progress,
globalization, the revolution in communications technology and trade liberalization
to all members of the international community to ensure that globalization
could get a human dimension and could help create a balance between northern
and southern societies» [1;28].
Thus, summing up the relatively
dynamic course of history of integration processes in the islamic world, the
cooperation of muslim
states on trans-regional level, began to develop in the first half of the XX
century to the present time has reached a high enough level. In this regard,
the OIC under the concept of «islamic solidarity» for the right to occupy a central
place in the islamic
world and it is
a key organ of cooperation of the states with a large number of muslim population.
References
1. Zhdanov N.V. The Islamic concept of world order. – Ì.: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2003. – 563 p.
2. Gasanova E.Yu. Turkey // The
ideology of the national liberation movement in the countries of the East.
1917-1947. – Ì.: Nauka, 1984. – P. 72 – 85
3. Sharipova R.M. Pan-islamism
today. Ideology and practice of the League of islam world. – Ì.: Nauka, 1986.
– 139 p.
4. Moskalenco V. The
islamization of Pakistan and Central Asia // Russia and the muslim world. – Ì.: INION, 1993. - ¹5. – P. 62 – 70
5. Gareeva G. Islamic
fundamentalism and the experience of nation-building in Pakistan // Russian
muslim world. – Ì.: INION, 2001. – ¹12. – P.
113 – 125
6. Sultanov B.K. Kazakhstan and
Organization of the Islamic Conference – Almaty: Kazakhstanski institut
strategicheskikh issledovani pri Prezidente Respubliki KazakhstanAspect, 2010.
– 268 p.
7. Hasanov R. Organization of
Islamic Conference and the muslim states of the CIS [Elektronnyi resurs] // Central Asia and Caucasus
// http://www.ca-c.org/journal/11-1997/st_03_hasanov.shtml.
8. Sheryazdanova K., Smagulova
D. Integration institutions: from Organization of the Islamic Conference to
Organization of Islamic Cooperation [Elektronnyi resurs] // Polititca i politicheskie nauki // http://www.cyberleninka.ru/article/n/integratsionnye-instituty-ot-organizatsii-islamskaya-konferentsiya-k-organizatsii-islamskogo-sotrudnichestva.