PRIORITIES OF
BUDGET POLICY IN UKRAINE
Ryabushka L.B. Ph.D
Ukrainian Academy of Banking
of The National Bank of Ukraine, Sumy
In the
transition economy forced the value of the state budget stability is enhanced
by the fact that the government is forced to take on the functions of the
centralization and redistribution of financial resources to ensure social
security of the population, financing of social sphere, regulation of
interstate and intergovernmental economic relations. Many theoretical,
methodological regulations of the budget role in the stability of the state
remain debatable, that adversely affects the quality of economic and social
processes in the country. The impact of the state budget on the socio-economic
processes in special science literature is being actively explored. The current
scientific developments of foreign and Ukrainian scientists outlined the
problems, it should be noted that the role of the state budget as the
instrument of macroeconomic regulation and the main lever of social and
economic development of the state is not enough investigated. Therefore the
purpose of the research is to reveal the economic nature of the budget and its
functions, budget justification growing role in providing and regulating social
and economic development, methodological bases of
the formation of the effective model of the budget.
The
budget in Ukraine, like in other countries, is formed on the basis of the
declared budget policy which comprises the forecast and program of the
documents of economic and social development and includes provisions:
the forecast of economic and social development of Ukraine, the main objectives
of budget policy, including limiting the amount of state budget deficit, the
level of the estimated annual gross domestic product, the public
debt limit, establishing the minimum wage subsistence level and its support,
relations between state budget and local budgets, including justification of
the share of local budgets in the consolidated budget of Ukraine Social and economic processes are unstable in Ukraine; it
becomes evident that Ukrainian Government is in the search
of priorities of budget policy.
Priorities of budget policy
are conceptual basic model of
budget in state. Ukrainian Government holds
budget reform. Taking it consideration
the main tasks of the reform are: balanced budget, tax system improvement, reduction the
level of deficit and growth tempo
of the state debt, improving the effective of government expenditure. The role of budget
in financial provision and regulation of social and economic processes is
determined by the state's role in the life of the society. Budget as an
important financial document balances the financial interests of the state
distribution of the business relationships, provides the balanced development
in the state. Therefore,
the budget as an important financial document of state is the real form of
existence of real, objectively determined distribution relationships that play
a specific role - to satisfy the needs of both society and its administrative
and territorial structures in the financial resources. In
addition, further analysis of the views of world famous scientists shows the
leading role of the state in modern society, it will be so in the future. With
the expansion and growth of modern economy the greater responsibility takes the
state, the regulative functions of the state budget are deepening and
developing, both in developed and in transforming economies, which is important to take into account when
implementing the market reforms. The budget is influences on social and
economic processes through its functions in the state. In foreign practice the
most important functions are the budget control function and scheduling
function. In Ukrainian literature they distinguish the distribution and control
functions. The additional functions are denoted: redistribution of GDP,
government regulation and economic incentives, financial support of
institutions and public sector organizations and the implementation of social
policy; control the formation, distribution and use of centralized funds of
financial resources, economic security, ensuring the existence and so forth.
The national model of social and economic development should be based on
practical research on existing models of the world’s budget. World practice is
work out conceptual bases to the choice of that or other model of the budget.
Firstly, depending on the level of distribution of GDP in the budget are divided the model of market and administrative
economy. The distribution of GDP is mean
government expenditure by main function: general public services, public order and
safety, defense, health care, education, social protection, economic affairs,
environment protection and others. Secondly, depending on the level of
centralization of GDP in the budget are divided the American, Scandinavian,
West-European model of the budget. In this research the level of centralization
of GDP is mean correlation between government revenue and government expenditure. In the third,
according to the form of the budget construction the
models of financial relations divided into the unitary, federative and
confederative states.
The
strategic priority of budget
policy in Ukraine is orientation on the European level of life quality and
providing of public services. As a result the effective budget policy in Ukraine is orientation similar to the West-European model. Therefore
in terms of research directions of construction of priorities of budget policy
is suggested to define on the basis of mathematical ground of the government
finance statistics of the
countries on such criteria: the level of centralization of GDP, government expenditure for defense, government expenditure for education
and
government expenditure for health care.
Based
on Country Statistics, Eurostat and
World Economic Outlook (WEO) data, IMF the matrix of grouping countries
by the level of centralization of GDP (correlation between government revenue and government expenditure) is presented. The
basis for cluster formation calculations were Simple average indicators of government revenue and government expenditure for
the period of 2005-2010. The results of analysis ground existence of such
models of budget, as American, Countries with developing economies,
West-European and Scandinavian. The first cluster
embraces the countries with the level of centralization of GDP to 25% (U.S.A
and China). The second cluster includes the countries with developing economies
and is characterized by the moderate level of centralization, 30-40% of GDP
(Poland, Czech Republic, Bulgaria, Romania, Slovakia, Latvia, Estonia and
Ukraine, Russia). The third cluster includes the countries are developed
economy where the level of centralization of GDP is within 41-50% (Germany,
Italy, France, Austria, England. Also the high level of centralization is
Slovenia's GDP). The fourth cluster
includes countries with high social and economic development and the level of
centralization, 51-60% of GDP (Finland, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Saudi Arabia).
It should be noted, countries with an administrative economy China and Saudi
Arabia have different levels of centralization of GDP. China has features of
the American model. Saudi Arabia has features of the Scandinavian model. It is necessary to analyze the
individual functional government expenditures for defense, education, and
health care in Ukraine in comparison to other countries such as China, the USA,
Russia, Germany and Sweden. Today there are countries that practically refuse to
finance the defense expenditure, and there are countries that have a powerful
enough military capacity, but most of them are financed according to the
principle of minimal sufficiency. Therefore, the biggest government expenditure
for defense is observed in the USA and Russia (3,7-5,2% GDP). The lowest level
is recorded in Germany - about 1% of GDP. In turn, in Ukraine this
government expenditure is about 1,3-1,1% of GDP.
However, a difference in approach to finance the defense expenditure is crucial
in formation of the budget model. A
bright feature of the formation model of the state budget is the realization
of social function, but its approach to financial security is different. The important question is a measure of coverage of the basic parts
of social sector (education, health, culture) and the size of their providing
by the state. The continuous growth of
government expenditure for education is in the USA and Germany (5-7%); in
Sweden the level of government expenditure for education is about 7% of GDP.
This government expenditure in Ukraine is about 6-7% of GDP, in
China the level of government expenditures for education is
about 2,5% of GDP, in Russia such government expenditure
do not exceed 3,8% of GDP. The largest government expenditure for health care
is in the U.S.A about 15% and Germany - 11%, the lowest is in Ukraine - about
4% of GDP. China has a level of government expenditure for health care in the
range of 5% in 2005-2010; Russia demonstrates the growth of government expenditure
for health, which in 2005 was at 6% level and in 2010 reached the level of 7,2%
of GDP.
The
application of matrix and cluster analysis allows identifying some imbalances
of government
expenditure and proves the directions for the formation of the effective model of
budget in Ukraine. First of all, the government expenditure for education in
Ukraine is about 6,5% GDP and government expenditure for health care is insufficiently
funded - 4% GDP. For further effective functioning of the Ukraine economy and
with the purpose of the rational allocation of budget government expenditures
it is proposed to reduce government
expenditure for education (in relative terms) to a level of 4-5% of GDP, and to
increase government
expenditure for health care to 7-10% of GDP. The defined level of the
government expenditure is more oriented on the West-European model of the
budget and ensuring social standards.
The priorities
of budget policy are effective instrument of macroeconomic indicators, when
appropriate budgetary resources and their efficient use ensure the financial
stability of the economy. Despite the existing imbalances in budget, Ukraine
should be oriented to the West- European model of life quality and providing of
public services. Therefore,
research highlights the necessity to achieve strategic transformation of social
and economic development and budget stability in Ukraine, such as: - creation of
the basic background for economic growth by keeping inflation low,
stabilization of public finance and making a stable financial system, updating
the tax system; - promotion of the business by reducing state intervention in
the economy, reducing administrative barriers to its development and updating
the infrastructure and basic sectors of the economy; - preservation and
development of human and social capital by improving efficiency and social
stability, improving the quality and accessibility of education and health
services; - deepening international economic integration
of Ukraine towards cooperation with the EU. Today
the EU is the trade partner number 1: more than 30% of trade turnover of
Ukraine is the EU. The share of EU investment is 3/4 of total investment in
Ukraine - now it is absolutely specific areas of sectorial cooperation. The
integration into European political, economic and social space will provide
more opportunities for innovations and modernization for Ukraine and society. As experts have
noted everything depends on the position of Ukraine in international space on
its pragmatism, understanding its own interests and ability to realize these
interests. Finding the ways of development of different models of economic
growth, political dialogue is open and productive for Ukraine.