Bukovinian State Medical
University, Chernivtsi
The use of Grammar-Translation
and
Audio-Lingual Methods
in teaching Medical English.
Many schools
around the world are using Grammar-Translation and
Audio-Lingual
Methods for teaching Medical
English. These traditional approaches to English language training have done
well to meet the needs of medical students. Today's global economy requires
career-specific language that includes workplace culture, effective delivery of
professional services and the ability to coordinate research and treatment
across borders. Current
methods of instruction most commonly used today for health professionals focus
on English language grammar rules in combination with the health care
terminology in the lessons. These teaching strategies of lessons include
medical terminology and simple dialogues about visits to the doctor's office
and minor illnesses. Medical English is taught from the perspective of medicine
and health care first and vocabulary acquisition, grammar and structure
secondly. Goals are set to prepare students for continuing studies in English
and for English language competency at work that is career-specific.
The Grammar-Translation
Method focuses on developing students' appreciation of the target language's medical literature.
Students are presented with target-language reading passages and answer
questions that follow. Other activities include translating literary passages
from one language into the other, memorizing grammar rules, and memorizing
native-language equivalents of target language vocabulary. Class work is highly
structured, with the teacher controlling all activities.
Grammar
is usually learned deductively on the basis of grammar rules and examples.
Students memorize the rules, then apply them to other examples. They learn
paradigms such as verb conjugations, and they learn the native language
equivalents of vocabulary words.
The Audio-Lingual Method is based on the
behaviorist belief that language learning is the acquisition of a set of
correct language habits. The learner repeats patterns until able to produce
them spontaneously. Once a given pattern – for example,
subject-verb-prepositional phrase – is learned, the speaker can substitute words
to make sentences. The teacher directs
and controls students' behavior, provides a model, and reinforces correct
responses. New vocabulary, structures presented through dialogues,
which are learned through imitation, repetition. Drills are based on patterns
in dialogue. Students' correct responses are positively
reinforced; grammar is induced from models. Reading, writing tasks are based on
oral work. Acquisition is a process that occurs subconsciously
and results in the actual knowledge of a language. Harmer points out that
acquiring language is more successful and longer lasting than learning. He also
notes that currently foreign language teaching seems to concentrate on getting
the adult student to consciously learn items of language. Harmer believes
language acquisition is the theory of choice for teaching English for Specific
Purposes. Harmer [2; 99].
Grammar study is
one of the most important and difficult type of activity in the process of
learning a foreign language. It is well known that grammar forms are the basis
of studying language. But it is very hard to study grammar only by cramming
rules and doing written exercises. You can learn something, but not always for
a long time, because some information obliterates from your mind. But when you “draw”
some pictures in your mind and fix them with the help of dialogues, short
conversations, discussions it remains with you for a long time. It may happen
sometimes that first you remember the situation and then the grammar material
that was used to create such situation.
The
main factor which regulates the use of different grammatical structures in
speech is a factor of communicative task, which is defined by the goal of
expression and a factor of situational conditions, which are regulated in the form
of linguistic context or speech situation that is represented directly or
visually. That’s why all new grammatical structures should be represented to
students in the context or situation. Situation in which new grammatical
structure is demonstrated should be apprehended by ear (except those structures
which are used mainly in the written form). The forming of grammatical habit
begins with an introduction of a new grammatical structure. Students of foreign
language on the intermediate level can acquaint with new speech material in
auditory lessons under the guidance of a teacher or independently. The solving
of this question depends on the character of the language material. Complex
grammatical material, especially situational caused structures must be introduced
under the guidance of a teacher, for example, the majority of structures with
modal verbs of the English language. This will ensure the creation of correct
basis of future language activity, on which depends the successful doing of the
action.
The
main task of auditory lessons is the activation of learned grammar structures
in connected speech of students. As it is known, to provide the use of learned
grammatical structures in the act of connected speech is possible with the help
of educational situations. For teaching grammatical structures of oral foreign
language the most effective are the situations, borrowed from original phonetic
materials mainly with dramatic character. Exercises, in which students’
expressions with necessary use of certain grammatical structure are based on
the oral situation are called “situational grammatical exercises on the
auditory basis” [1;40].
In
contrast to reproduction exercises, situational grammatical exercises on the
auditory basis have the productive basis. In productive exercises of this type
speech reaction of a student is a contextual unity – the expression with the
complicated logical structure. While doing exercise, students first of all
listen to the situation that gives possibility to make clear idea about active
characters and their relations. After that the concrete communicative task is
set before them, for example, to express reproach supposition, etc. If this
communicative task can be realized with the help of synonymic speech forms, the
choice of the form should be to a certain degree limited ( for example, to show
that reproach should be reflected with the help of appropriate modal verb). The
student should also be informed about the role of active character of the
listened situation he would play. Here is the example of the situational
grammar exercise on the auditory basis which has the productive character.
Nora: Hi, Tom and Mary!
Mary: Hello, Nora!
Nora: It is nice to see you! Harry’s
out at the moment, but he’ll be back very soon. Come in and see our house. It’s
nearly tea-time, and there is kettle boiling … This way …
Tom: Let me see, when did we come
over last time, Nora?
Nora: Last summer, wasn’t it?
Task. Imagine you are Nora. You want
Tom and Mary to frequent your place. Speak up your wish. Substantiate it.
Address Tom and Mary. Mind that fulfillment of your wish fully depends on them.
Use proper structure with the verb “to wish” in a complex sentence. The
possible expression of the student: “Dear Tom and Mary it’s unkind of you to
come to our place so seldom. I wish you would visit us at least once a month,
and not once a year. You are our closest relatives. We love you both dearly and
miss you too. Do come to see us as often as you can. Will you promise?”
Situational
grammar exercises on the auditory basis can also have receptive character, they
can recall the understanding of students the communicative meaning of learned
structures, which is listened isolated, in language example. The task for the
student is to create the speech situation, typical for using the structure
learned. Situation created by the student shows how correctly he understands
the communicative meaning of given structure and situational conditions of its
functioning in language. As in case of learning constructions with modal verbs
medical students are supposed to listen to the dialogue, determine the
constructions of modal verbs explain the cases of their usage and create their
own dialogues with the proper use of these verbs.
Example of the dialogue:
Dr. Murray: Good morning.
Mrs. Thurston and Mark: Good
morning.
Dr. Murray: So, Mark, how are you
feeling?
Mark: Pretty much the same, Doctor.
Dr. Murray: OK. Well, Mark, we have
the lab results and as we suspected, it appears that you have diabetes.
Mrs. Thurston: Oh, no! That’s what
my father has. Does this mean that Mark will have to give himself injections?
And my dad has all these other problems that they say come from diabetes.
Dr. Murray: Don’t worry too much,
Mrs. Thurston. Each case is different and we have made a lot of progress in the
last few years.
Mark: Does this mean I won’t be able
to play sports anymore?
Dr. Murray: Not at all, Mark. You
will be able to lead a completely normal life. You can eat more or less the
same food as all your friends. No one will even know you have diabetes.
Mrs. Thurston: But he’ll have to
give himself injections, won’t he?
Dr. Murray: Not, necessarily. There
are some new gadgets that you wear that do away with injections.
Mark: Yeah, there’s another kid at
school who has one of those. But he has to take blood samples.
Dr. Murray: Yes, that’s right; you
have to check the amount of sugar in your blood.
Mrs. Thurston: Don’t worry, Mark.
I’m sure everything is going to be OK.
Dr. Murray: That’s right. Thank you,
Mrs. Thurston. But please remember, Mark, diabetes is a serious condition and
it can have long-term consequences if you don’t follow a very careful treatment
plan. OK? Now, let’s go through everything step by step[3;98]. On the basis of
this dialogue medical students make up their own conversations that will help
them to use modal constructions, enrich their vocabulary and carry up positive
psychological attitude during medical exanimation between a doctor and a
patient. With the help of dialogue
students “draw” some frames in their minds and fix them. They even may remember
the content of the conversation first and then the grammar material that was
used to create such situation.
Reference.1.Áàðàáàíîâà Ã.Â. Ìåòîäèêà íàâ÷àííÿ ïðîôåñ³éíî-îð³ºíòîâàíîãî ÷èòàííÿ â
íåìîâíîìó ÂÍÇ: Ìîíîãðàô³ÿ.- Ê.:Ô³ðìà «²ÍÊÎÑ», 2005.-180 c. 2. Harmer, J.The
practice of English language teaching, Longman Handbooks for Language Teachers,
Longman Publishers, USA, 1996 3. Martin Milner “English for Health Sciences”. –
Thomson ELT, Boston, Massachusettes. –p. 98. 4. Michael Lewis, Gimmy Hill
“Practical Techniques for Language Teaching”, Hove 1992, England. – p. 85,
118-121. 5.R ebeca L. Oxford “The Tapestry of Language Learning the Individual
and in the Communicative Classroom”. – Boston, Massachusetts, USA, - 1992-
p.30, p. 166-175