Педагогические науки/ 5.Современные
методы преподавания.
Aukhadieva
Shamshinur Dalelovna Ph.D.
Kazakh
Ablay Khan university of international relations and world languages
Almaty,
Kazakhstan.
Shauenova Nazerke Kozha-Ali-Askarovna
Kazakh
Ablay Khan university of international relations and world languages
3rd
course student, Department of International Relations
The
method of case studies in the organization of educational process: experience,
problem
It
is possible to give as a practical example of application of interactive
methods of teaching about the training method known as a case method (Case
study) - a method of the analysis of situations. Its essence that students suggest to comprehend a real life
situation which description at the same time reflects not only any practical
problem, but also actualizes a certain complex of knowledge which needs to be
acquired in the resolution of this
problem. Thus the problem has no unambiguous decisions.
The case method,
first, reflects standard situations which are most frequent in life and which
the specialist should face in the course of the professional activity.
Secondly, in the
educational case training and educational tasks that predetermines a
considerable element of convention at reflection of life in it are on the first
place. A situation, a problem and a plot here is not real, practical, but such
what they can be in life. They are characterized by artificiality,
"collection" from the most important and truthful vital details. Such
case gives a little for understanding of a concrete fragment of society a
little. However it surely forms approach to such fragment. It allows to see in
situations typical and predetermines ability to analyze situations by means of
application of analogy. The main sense a case method is that he acts as model
for receiving new knowledge of a situation and behavior in it.
The central
concept of case-method is the concept of situation ,
i.e. a set of variables when the choice of any decision from them influences in
a decisive way the end result. Existence of the only
correct decision is essentially denied. At this method of training the student
is independently compelled to make decisions and to prove it.
The method of
analysis of the situation began to be applied in the early twentieth century in
the field of law and medicine. The leading role in the spread of this method of
learning belongs to Harvard. Exactly there the first
case-situations were developed for training of students on business
disciplines. The main feature of the method was to study students
precedents, i.e. the available past situations of legal or business practices.
Particular emphasis was placed on the independent work of students, during
which to look through and analyze a large number of practical material.
The method of
case studies - is an interactive technology for short-term training of students
on the basis of real or fictional business situations, directed not so much
on development of knowledge, how many on formation at students of new qualities
and skills. Use of this method is necessary because it allows to see ambiguity
of the solution of problems in real life. It is possible to be the remarkable
specialist, but to learn to find the most rational solution, to be ready to
correlate the studied material to practice - it needs to learn by means of
active methods of training, including cases in training courses.
The purpose of
the case study method - to teach students both individually and as a group:
- Analyze the information;
- Sort it to solve a given business
problem;
- Identify key issues;
- Generate alternative solutions and
evaluate them;
- Choose the best solution and form
a program of action.
Students in
operating time over a concrete case are found in the center of process of
solutions of a certain problem. As a rule, the group is
divided into smaller, more active sub-working groups consisting of 4 - 6
people.
In these small groups study materials of this case and
develop offers for a solution which are discussed then by all group. Cases can
be the most various on the volume and the contents. It depends on the purposes
of training, level of knowledge of students, and also on what help should be
given, and what information needs to be provided to students during
decision-making process.
Generalization of
the existing literature on this problem shows that efficiency of educational
process on the basis of case – technologies depends on definition of a
technique of use of a case in educational process and, of course, on a good case.
There are main variants for receiving of the case,
i.e. a specific problem situation.
The first variant
consists that the history, and most often a fragment of life of the real
company information about which is received by the author of a situation
directly during the research or consulting project, or purposeful collection of
information is taken as a basis. In Russia the use of significant scales of
similar primary sources of information still restrains owing to a much bigger
closeness of domestic business (especially concerning financial information),
less active participation of teachers in consulting practice with their foreign
colleagues.
The second option
is use of secondary sources, first of all information "scattered" in
the mass media, specialized magazines and editions, information bulletins and
booklets distributed at exhibitions, presentations, etc. The considered way is less labor-consuming as it is necessary to deal
with already collected and, in own way, systematized information. Therefore in the absence of opportunity to obtain data from the primary
source of the publication of such Russian periodic business magazines as
"Expert", "A secret of firm", "Company",
"Management skill", national daily newspapers "Kommersant",
"Sheets", it is necessary to consider as strategic and besides a free
resource in technology of situational training.
The third, the
least widespread, option — the description of a fictional situation. It is
necessary to refer the maximum dispassionateness from real business, problems
of the real company to number of the main disadvantages of such approach. And
it contradicts the essence of a method of concrete situations.
As a fourth
option should be called "accidental" receipt of the case from
colleagues, at seminars, etc.
Experience of
teaching in high school system shows that teachers face some problems at
introduction of a method of cases in educational process. The analysis of the
received results showed that generally as problems call difficulties with selection of a suitable case and a lack of methodical development on use of a
method of cases when training in concrete disciplines.
For the solution
of the matters it is necessary to organize methodical seminars or the centers
for development of interdisciplinary case-study which tasks would include:
- the
organizational and methodical help to the teachers introducing and/or using a
method of training of Case-study;
- ensuring the scientific researches and
educational process connected with use of Case-study;
- professional development of teachers by
their training in methods of use of Case-study in educational process;
- organization and rendering the methodical
help to teachers in development of cases;
- creation of manuals on use of the
Case-study methods, creation of educational and methodical complexes on the
basis of results of theoretical and applied researches.
Generalizing it
is possible to note that there is the general technology of work when using a
method of case-study. Prior to occupations the teacher: a) selects a case, b)
defines the main and auxiliary materials, c) develops scenarios. The student's
duties - to receive a case and the list of the recommended literature, to
prepare for occupation. During occupations the teacher: a) organizes
preliminary discussion of a case, b) divides group into subgroups, c) directs
discussion of a case. Student: a) asks questions, b) offers versions of
decisions, c) makes the decision, d) makes the written report on work.
Experience of
introduction in educational process of this method allows to determine sources
of case method by discipline subjects as well. Generally a source of case
method can be a real life situation.
But, except a real life situation as sources of a case it is possible to use
both art, and publicistic literature which can prompt ideas, and in some cases
define a subject outline of a case. Effective use of fragments from fiction and
journalism which thanks to talent of their authors can not only decorate a case
but also make it interesting, dynamic, well acquired.
Fragments from
journalism, inclusion in a case of operational information from mass media
considerably staticizes a case, increases to it interest from students. For
example, the happening political processes in the countries of the East and
their analysis is a direct source of definition of base of case method in
studying of specifics of diplomacy and international relation in this region.
Use of operational information about political processes in the international
relations and journalism imposes to a case and culturological function, and
stimulate to increase of political literacy and civil activity of students.
It is impossible
to underestimate also value of local material. Proceeding from our experience,
it is possible to note that the most saturated and interesting discussion of
cases about activity of the different companies happens when the company and
its production have a certain personal value for students. All this promotes
deeper understanding the existing relations between these countries. Thus these
materials can play a role of the direct tool for diagnostics of a political
situation of the region.
The conclusion is
obvious: the critical mass of cases which are used in programs and courses, can
be based on local material. And in this case it is not that cases have to light
only experience of the national enterprises. Those companies and those goods or
services which are present in the national market at this or that look mean.
For example, using statistical materials, it is possible to give scientific
character and severity to a case. When using statistical materials the student
needs to comprehend these materials, having answered some questions: "What
role is played by these materials in the characteristic of a situation?",
"What does directly characterize a situation in material?", "How
do these characteristics release?", etc. Statistical materials place or in
the text of a case, or in the appendix.
Sound materials
to a case can be received by means of the analysis of the scientific articles,
monographs and scientific reports devoted to this or to another problem. If
works of journalism and fiction give an emotional saturation and subject
tangibility to a case, works of science give it big severity and a correctness.
The good scientific article is usually characterized by profound understanding
of any question, and the scientific monograph gives the systemic, comprehensive
characteristic of an object of research. As for the scientific report, its
feature is relevance and novelty of material. These products of science not
always describe and explain a situation. Therefore they need special judgment
in aspect of a situation.
Inexhaustible
well of material for cases is the Internet with its resources. This source
differs in considerable scale, flexibility and efficiency.
As the general
conclusions on application of interactive methods it is possible to present the
following reasons:
Thus, organized
cognitive process in practice shows to students how to solve typical
situational problems as at last, to connect together new information with
reality. Verbal and nonverbal reactions of members of small group provide
important feedback in activity of each of them. Participants have an
opportunity better to know each other, both on personal, and at the
professional level. Being method of cooperative training, interactive methods
promote formation of skills of leadership, decision-making, creation of trust,
management of the conflicts.
These positive results correlate with common
objectives of new educational paradigm.
References:
1.
Derkach A.M. Case-method in training
of organic chemistry when training technologists of the food industry in system
of secondary professional education. SPb.: 2012.
2.
Civic education: contents and active
methods of training. Under N. Voskresenskaya and S. Shekhter's edition. With
the assistance of A. Ioffe and Ch. Whyte. - M.: Sivitas fund, 2005.