ê.ô.í. Øèíãàðåâà Ì.Þ., ìàãèñòðàíò Êàëìóðçàåâà
Æ.À.
Ðåãèîíàëüíûé ñîöèàëüíî-èííîâàöèîííûé
óíèâåðñèòåò
Introducing
gothic
novel
into
the
classroom
One
of my favorite television shows was called Reading
Rainbow, which was a children's program promoting reading
and literature. Part of the theme song to the show says, “I can go anywhere.
Friends to know, and ways to grow . . .” expressing the excitement about
getting into a good book. Literature is important because it opens up new and
exciting worlds in the future, present, and past, with a plethora of
characters, some of whom are loved, while others are hated, but all of whom are
memorable and often stay with us long after finishing a book. They teach us
things, things we did not know were missing from our lives, and enrich our
collective knowledge as individuals and as a society. Apart from this,
literature is also full of history and culture, and as a soon-to-be-teacher of
English as a foreign language in Sweden, it is important to be able to
incorporate the history and culture of the English-speaking world and help
students come into contact with it. Reading literature introduces an individual
into the greatest club on the planet, where membership is free, and the way
literature can make us question the way we think, our morals and beliefs,
molding us into critical thinkers is invaluable. Literature can be a tool or a
medium for teaching critical thinking, and allow students the ability to do
something creative with their acquired knowledge in a way that gives pleasure,
if done correctly.
Why
is literature important and how can it add depth and new dimensions to our
lives? Why are Bram Stoker's Dracula
and Stephenie Meyer's Twilight good choices
for exploration in the classroom? What are Gothic fiction and vampire
narratives, and what sort of themes can be found in them? How does being able
to visualize a story make for better understanding, and how can the information
discussed in this essay be designed and used in a creative and interesting way
in the classroom? These are the questions that will be answered here.
So
why are Stoker's Dracula and Meyer's Twilight
both interesting, if not unique choices for exploration in the classroom?
Students studying English at the “Gymnasium” level, which is equivalent to upper-secondary
school are expected to work with during their second or third year “samtida och
aldre skonlitteratur . . . ” which means contemporary and older literature, to
which Twilight and Dracula
provide good category matches in that sense. Moreover, by starting with the
vampire narrative Twilight a teacher can
activate their students' interest in vampires and the students can then be
segued into working with and reading Dracula.
In other words, spark an interest in a classic through contemporary literature.
Furthermore, the theme of vampires has really exploded within pop culture in
the last ten years, seen in the highly popular vampire literature turned into
the tv series The Vampire Diaries
and True Blood (known as The
Southern Vampire Mysteries), not to mention the literally
hundreds of other young adult and adult vampire series available. Stephenie
Meyer's Twilight is by far and
away the best-known among young adults, teenagers, and adolescents. This is
also why using Meyer's Twilight
as a starting point in the topic of vampire literature and making interesting
comparisons with Dracula can be a good
idea, particularly since Twilight
is a contemporary vampire narrative containing a setting and characters which
seem familiar to the young people of today.
In
addition, as part of the Amnesplan, or subject plan for English 6, students are
also expected to come into contact with “a variety of themes and content found
in film and fiction; authorship and literary epochs”. The novel Dracula
takes place towards the end of the Victorian Era in England, and it is
considered an example of Victorian fiction, where one can see some of the
ideals and behavior prevalent in the period such as the evolving role of women
in society, as well as the sexual conventions of the period. In addition, the
novel also provides a good base for examining what constitutes Gothic fiction,
and what role fear plays as fear is a universal emotion that is experienced by
all of us at some point. Furthermore, Dracula
is, above all else, a primary example of the classic vampire narrative where
one can examine the role and world of the vampire by looking at some of the
most basic themes in literature: good vs. evil or love vs. lust. As Robert E.
Probst explains, “students read literature to know themselves, . . . to create
themselves, for reading will enable them to refine and sharpen their
conceptions of the world and the people in it” [Probst R. 1988,p.6].
As
there is an expectation that many students will have already read Twilight
and/or seen the films, considering that the last part of the Twilight
series was just released in cinemas in November 2012, it may be the closest
tangible idea of what a vampire is for the generation currently enrolled in
secondary and upper-secondary school, allowing students to access their prior
knowledge about vampires. However, vampires and the vampire narrative have
evolved, as shown in this essay, and this is also something that will also lead
to interesting and very fruitful discussions during both the pre-task and
during the students reading of Dracula
where the goal is that they will be using their previous knowledge as well as
their newly-acquired knowledge from Dracula.
Therefore, Twilight will serve as
a springboard to motivate students on the topic of vampires where the students
will be shown the first film in the series to refresh their memory of the basic
story and provide some important visuals, before moving them to the focus of
the classroom lesson-plan and project, comparing and analyzing Dracula
and Twilight.
However,
for students to be able to succeed in attempting to analyze literature, they
have to be able to connect with a story on a personal level, or at least that
is what Jeffery D. Wilhelm argues in his book entitled, “You
Gotta BE the Book ” Teaching Engaged and Reflective Reading with Adolescents.
His reason for writing this book stemmed from his personal struggle as a
middle- school teacher with his adolescent pupils and their negative attitudes
towards reading, which is something also seen in classrooms around the country
today. This book should be a must for every English teacher to read because he
reminds us that teaching literature is not just about “teaching a set of texts”
or books from the literary canon, but that it is about developing, motivating,
and engaging students to see the value in literature as a powerful source of
knowledge, a way to reflect on what they think about the world and to have an
enlightening and fulfilling experience reading [Wilhelm J.1997, p.145].
According to Wilhelm, teachers must act as a central motivator and encourage
creativity in the classroom by focusing “on the construction of meaning [where]
the classroom can become a place where students not only produce meaning, but a
place where they share ways of reading and being with a text” [ibid 11].
Wilhelm's teaching theory is based on the transactional approach created by
Louise Rosenblatt, who has influenced much of reader-response literary theory,
and his theory focuses on the individual reader's interaction with a text. [ibid
19]. However, it is not enough just to ask students what they think or feel
about a text, as part of learning to think critically is learning how to
analyze and express why they think or feel the way they do. This will be shown
in some of the types of questions that follow later.
How
does one go about creating a stimulating and interesting literature project
about the novel Dracula, starting from
the novel Twilight? The pre-task for reading is crucial for setting the mood
and getting the students to start thinking about what they will read as well as
triggering their personal or “schematic knowledge”, as Tricia Hedge calls it,
because “certain words or phrases in the text . . . will activate prior
knowledge . . . in the mind of the reader” [Hedge T.2000, p.190]. This activity
is a word-association game, where the teacher gives the students the word
“vampire” and allows them to brainstorm a list of words both associated with
vampires, but also describing them. It is here that students will start
considering how they see the figure of the vampire. For those who feel
artistically inclined they can also draw a picture. Hopefully this will be a
rich collection of images and emotions describing what is considered to be the
modern vampire and also the classic vampire. Some questions to be discussed in
class with the teacher and students in small groups are: How do we see
vampires? Are they to be feared and rejected or loved and accepted, or do we
feel something else in between and why? Are vampires good or evil, or a
dichotomy, a mixture of both? It is here that the discussion can take on a more
philosophical approach as well, because vampires have symbolically represented
the Other in society throughout history. This approach could lead to a fruitful
discussion about the Cullen family in Twilight,
and where they stand in regard to “Otherness”, which could then lead into how
we in society treat those around us whom we consider to fall into the “other”
category.
Literature
1. Probst, Robert E. Response and Analysis: Teaching Literature in Junior and Senior High School.Portsmouth, N.H.: Boynton/Cook , 1988.
2.
Wilhelm, Jeffrey D. "You Gotta BE the Book": Teaching Engaged and
Reflective Reading with Adolescents.
New York, NY: Teachers College Press, 1997.
3.
Hedge, Tricia. Teaching and
learning in the language classroom. Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 2000.