Almaty Management University
PhD, Senior lecturer, Aiman M. Kazybayeva
Master of economic sciences, Lecture,
Vladislav V.Ostrovskiy
Concept of "risks in the
realization of investment construction projects" and the mechanism of
their management
In the mass consciousness it is often stated that the
risk is possible danger or failure. So the great definition dictionary of the
Russian language (Kuznetsov S.A., 1998) defines “risk” as:
1) the possible danger of something;
2) action in a promiscuous manner, requiring courage,
fearlessness, hoping for a happy outcome.
In the formation of commodity-money relations risk is
an economic category, which extends to all levels of management, and get great
importance on the issues of economy and finance, where risk is managed, i.e.
the development of risk events is predicted and measures to decrease the full
extent of loss are assumed (Mierin L.A., 1998).
The variety of situations, in which the concepts are
used, closely related to the word "risk", used in different contexts,
implies the diversity of interpretations of this word . There are two main
approaches to the definition of this category: let's call first one "only
losses", risk is defined as the possibility of losses, and let's call the
second one "loss/ profit" - as the possibility of loss and profit.
The comparison of these approaches as well as the assessment of the wide range
of values of the phenomenon under study are illustrated in Table 1, which
presents a number of examples of the definition of risk, encountered in the
literature on risk management.
Table 1 – The comparison of approaches to the
definition of the concept “risk” (Kolchin V.G., 1998, Mierin L.A., 1998, p. 15, Chernova G.V., 2000,
Balabanov I.T., 1996, Chovushyan E.O., 1999, Grabovyi P. G., 1999,
Kozin M.N., 2000, Vasiljev V. Ì., 1997, Project Management Institute, 2000)
|
Approach |
Definition of risk |
|
Only losses |
1. The risk of
project realization in the modern literature in some way is a whole complex
of ideas about the possible failures of its implementation that is to say
about possible non-achievement of project aims or noncompliance of design
constraints. 2. The risk is
recognizing danger (threat), the occurrence on any negative event in any
system with certain consequences during time and space. 3. Economic
risk is the possibility of some kind of loss, measured in monetary terms. 4. Risk is
possible danger of losses. 5. When talk
about the risk, usually mean the possibility of negative incident in the
future and the severity of its consequences. |
|
Losses/ profit |
1. Risk is the
probability of obtaining economic benefits (profits) or appearing of
additional unexpected losses (expenses) by construction organization taking
into account characteristics of sector, in the process of the implementation
of its construction activities in the freedom of the active entrepreneurial
search, dynamics, and mobility of the economic environment. 2. The risk in
the activities of a construction company is the possibility (probability) of
the economic benefits (profits) or occurrence of contingent additional losses
(expenses) compared with the forecasted and alternative variants of the
development of economic situations. 3. Risk is the
probability of achieving the desired (undesirable) outcome of the decision.
That is to say, under certain conditions, the result of a decision made with
risk, either win or loss, damage are possible. 5. Project
risk - is uncertain event or condition, the occurrence of which has positive
or negative effect on the aim of the project. |
The mistake is to define risk as the possibility of
loss and profit. In Russian language, the word risk is accompanied by the
possibility of losing something, but not purchasing.
Modern researchers believe that the risk is the
reverse side of freedom of choice - and the lack of alternatives means no risk.
Thus, entrepreneurship cannot exist without risk, and the operations with
excess risk tend to bring the greatest profit. The problem is not to look for
business without risk, with the cernainly foreseen outcome to avoid the risk,
but to forecast it and long to decrease to an acceptable level (Seregin E.V.,
1998).
Risk is present in virtually all spheres of human
life, so it is not possible to state it accurately and clearly, because the
definition depends on the scope of its use.
When considering the process of realization of
investment construction projects in the aspect of the riskiness of this
activity, there is a need for a comprehensive study of the concept of "the
risk of the investment construction project."
Investment construction projects are complex systems,
elements of which are isolated from the environment for a certain
characteristic, forming a unified, stable and consistent framework. The
investment process is carried out in dynamic environment, which has immediate
impact on the investment construction projects and consequences of this impact
can be determined.
It speaks about the functioning of each element and a
system as a whole in terms of uncertainty, which is understood as incomplete or
inaccurate information on the conditions of the project realization, including
- the associated costs and reults. The uncertainty, associated with the
possibility of in the appearing the adverse situations and consequences during
the project realization, is characterized by the concept of risk.
Thus, officially the risk of realization of the
investment construction project is defined as the possibility of adverse
situations and consequences, appearing in the process of project realization.
The key elements here are three risk characteristics:
firstly, the uncertainty of conditions in the project realization is related to
the possibility of negative situations and consequences; secondly, the degree
of possibility, that is to say the possibility of adverse situations and
consequences; thirdly, these very unfavorable situations and the consequences.
The first aspect is related to the uncertainty that
always accompanies the risks of investment construction projects, and has the
following properties (US Department of Defense, Defense Acquisition University,
2002):
- The risk exists only in relation to the future and
is indissolubly tied to the forecasting - there is no past risks.
- The risk assumes the occasionality of unfavorable
situation and consequences, forecasted or not, that is to say adverse
situations can either occur or not.
- The forecasting of adverse situations and
consequences is the presence of a risk management mechanism.
The practical difference between the categories of
risk and uncertainty is that in the first case, the distribution of the results
in the group is known, (which is achieved by preliminary calculations or study
of statistically prior experience), and in second is not. It is more often
caused by the inability to make grouping of the cases, as considered situations
are unique to a great extent. Thus, the actual uncertainty relates to specific
uncertainty, where no calculations or assignment of a numerical probability,
even though subjective are possible.
Another aspect of the risks of investment construction
projects is associated with the assessment of the degree of possibility, that
is to say the probability of adverse situations and consequences. Probability
is a certain number, which the hogher is the more possible is adverse situation
in future. The existence of the possibility of a large number of adverse
situations in future does not mean that they all have a certain level of risk.
That is to say, the probability of appearing of the
adversity, and the consequences have to be above zero and less than one. At
zero probability there is no risk, and at one hundred percent probability-
during the realization of investment construction projects there will be a
controversial issue, crisis, problem, incident with consequences, but there
will be no risk (Integrated Computer Engineering, 2002).
The probability is divided into subjective and
objective (Wentzel E.S., 1999). The concept of objective probabilities is based
on the interpretation of the concept of probability as the limit frequency
meaning at infinitely large number of experiments and the estimated probability
is made by calculating the frequency, with which this event occurs.
Bibliography
Stakhanov, V. N., (1998). Commercial
risks in regional economic streams. Rostov n/d: General and the prof.
education.
Sparrows, S.N. and Baldin, K.V., (2009). Risk management in business
activity. Third prod. Moscow: Dashkov and To.
Smith, S. A., (1998). Big
explanatory dictionary of Russian. San Francisco: Academy of Sciences.
Stoyanova, E.S., (2000). Financial
management: theory and practice. Petropavlovsk: Prospect.
Titov, V.V., (1999). Organizational and methodical questions of risk management in the
Russian business. Obninsk: IATE.
Trifonov, S.V., (1999). Model of
optimization of the price of risk at justification of real investments. Moscow:
SPb.
Vasilyev, V.M., (1997). Management
of construction investment projects.
St. Petersburg: Publishing house
of DIA.
Vasilyev, V.M., (2001). Management
in construction: The textbook for higher education institutions. St.
Petersburg: Publishing house of DIA.
Venttsel, E.S., (1999). Probability
theory. Chalyabinsk: High school.
Vishnyakov, Ya.D. and Radayev, N. N., (2008). General theory of risks. 2nd edition. Moscow: Akademiya.