Ôèëîëîãè÷åñêèå íàóêè/ 3.Òåîðåòè÷åñêèå è ìåòîäîëîãè÷åñêèå ïðîáëåìû
èññëåäîâàíèÿ ÿçûêà.
ïðåïîäàâàòåëü àíãëèéñêîãî ÿçûêà Àñàíîâà
À.Ñ.
Êàçàõñòàíñêèé óíèâåðñèòåò Äðóæáû íàðîäîâ
Pronunciation myths and facts
Many students and teachers have myths about what it means to learn and
teach the pronunciation of English. These are four commonly held ones:
Learning
the pronunciation of English means learning how to pronounce the individual
vowel and consonant sounds.
There is much more
to the pronunciation of English than its individual sounds. How these sounds
are organized plays a greater role in communication than the sounds themselves.
Two major organizing structures are rhythm and intonation.
The rhythm of English is
created by the contrast in syllable lengths within words as well as across word
boundaries. For example, in the word English, the first syllable Eng-
is pronounced longer than the second syllable –lish. When we focus on
the timing of syllables, we can see that the rhythm of the word English is identical to the rhythm of
the words after and vision. Not only can words have
identical rhythms but the rhythm of a word can be identical to the rhythm of a
phrase; for example, festival and first of all. In fact, many novice
learners of English have actually written festival
when they heard first of all. English
speakers rely as much on rhythm to identify words as on the consonant and vowel
sounds. Sometimes, they pay attention to the rhythm more than sounds. A San
Francisco newspaper columnist reported that a student went to the library to
ask for a copy of John Steinbeck’s novel, Of
My Cement. When we compare the rhythm of this mishearing to the rhythm of
the actual title, Of Mice and Men, we can see that
they are identical.
The lengthening of a syllable is conditioned
by stress. In the word tumor the
first syllable is stressed; therefore, it is longer than the second. Equally
important as stressing a syllable is not stressing a syllable. If the second
syllable of tumor is also stressed,
and if the vowel of that syllable is incorrectly pronounced so that the
syllable sounds like more, then a
listener may hear the utterance as two words, as two more.
It
is difficult, if not impossible, for students to hear and pronounce some
sounds, such as the difference between the vowel sound in ship and the vowel
sound in sheep. Therefore, it is useless to spend time on pronunciation.
Pronunciation is an
integral part of language learning. The abandonment of pronunciation
instruction has been based on the mistaken belief that pronunciation means only
sounds, and on the failure of such a limited focus to affect learners’ overall
pronunciation. As I have tried to show here, the scope of pronunciation is much
broader than an inventory and description of sounds. It embraces the elements
of rhythm and intonation, which function in the communication process. Thus,
any learner with a goal of learning English for communicative purposes needs to
learn the rhythm and intonation of English. The importance of pronunciation takes
on even greater significance when we understand the connection between
pronunciation and other aspects of language use. As listeners expect spoken
English to follow certain patterns of rhythm and intonation, speakers need to
employ these patterns to communicate effectively. Similarly, listeners need to
know how speech is organized and what patterns of intonation mean in order to
interpret speech accurately. Thus learning about pronunciation develops
learners’ abilities to comprehend spoken English. Learning about
pronunciation also helps learners with the spelling system of English. Novice
learners expect to find a one-to-one correspondence between a sound and its
spelling. However, the letter a, for
example, can be pronounced five different ways, as these words demonstrate: same, sat, father, call,
and about. Often a
speaker’s difficulties with pronunciation originate from misinterpretation of
the spelling system, rather than difficulty with the pronunciation of the
sounds. A learner who expects the letter o
to be pronounced like the word oh
will be surprised to find that it is not pronounced that way in words like love, color and production.
Pronunciation, then, is not
only important for oral communication, but it is closely linked with listening
comprehension, spelling, grammar and reading. To ignore pronunciation is to
ignore important information that can support these other skills.
Pronunciation instruction is boring.
Pronunciation
teaching is not intrinsically boring. Perhaps pronunciation teaching has been
boring because it has been done in a boring way. However, pronunciation
teaching is not by nature boring. Teaching that does not involve the students’
intelligence is boring. Teaching that employs material that is irrelevant to
the students is boring. Practice that is monotonous and unvaried is boring. A teacher who believes pronunciation
teaching is boring is boring.
Nonnative speakers of English cannot teach
pronunciation.
Nonnative speakers
of English can teach pronunciation. Much of the concern about teaching
pronunciation has centered around the exact pronunciation of vowel and
consonant sounds. However, if the goal of teaching learners is to enable them
to communicate in English, we can see that communicative effectiveness depends
not only on the pronunciation of these vowel and consonants perfectly. While it
is not unusual for teachers who are not native speakers of English to feel
apprehension can be diminished and eliminated. Becoming educated about teaching
pronunciation in its broader scope can make a big difference in a teacher’s
feeling of confidence. In addition, nonnative speakers of English typically
have an advantage over native speakers in that they can learn to perceive and
manipulate rhythm and intonation more easily than native speakers, for whom
these are unconscious features.
These four myths about teaching
pronunciation have contributed to its general neglect in contemporary language
pedagogy. In view of the fact that information about pronunciation supports not
only oral-language development but the ability to interpret speech as well as
the skills of reading and writing, pronunciation cannot be considered
tangential to language learning; it should be treated as an integral part ort
of the entire process. What many teachers have dreaded about pronunciation has
been the undue attention to sounds. By attending to the broader features of pronunciation,
which have a more immediate, discernible effect on communication, teachers will
find that teaching pronunciation will be a much successful and satisfying
experience.