the features of surgical treatment
of echinococcus of
the lungs in children
j.À. shamsiev
Samarkand State Medical
Institute, Republic of Uzbekistan
The results of surgical treatment
315 children with echinococcosis of lungs were studied. The patients were
divided to 3 groups according to features of technique of echinococcectomy in
different periods of action of the clinic. 123 (39,0%) patients, who underwent
antiparasitic manipulation with 2-5% solution of formalin in the period
1998-2001 years, were included in the 1st group. In the 2nd
group there were included 110 (35.0%) patients, whom echinococcus cyst of lung
was treated with slolution of glycerol in room temperature in the period
2002-2005 years. 3rd group was 82 (26.0%) patients, whom glycerol
with 70˚Ñ
temperature was used as germicide during 2006-2010 years. Besides that in this
group surgical minimal approaches were used, which in many cases was completed
with fiberoptic endoscopy revision of fibrous capsule. There was showed that
developing of surgical tactics, wide using of minithoracotomy, facilities of
videoassisted manipulations, processing of a cavity of echinococcus cyst with
hot glycerol, individual approach to suture of remanded cavity proceed
decreasing of postoperative complications’ rate to 7 times (from 21,9% to 3,6%)
and in-patient treatment duration after surgery almost twice.
Keywords: echinococcosis, children,
surgical treatment, miniapproach, postoperative complications.
Uzbekistan is located in one of the world's five
endemic focuses of echinococcosis. Every year in our country about this
parasitic disease it has been performed 4.5 thousand surgical operations [3].
Due to the long asymptomatic duration and the absence of pathognomonic symptoms
of echinococcosis often diagnosed at later stages, when a variety of
complications have been come out, the frequency of which varies from 15 to 52%,
which significantly affects the duration of the disease, reduces the
effectiveness of treatment [1, 2, 5-7].
According to operative information gathered in
accordance with the Orders of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of
Uzbekistan ¹ 73 of 15.02.2002, at the general structure of patients with
echinococcosis children make up 20.4% [3]. The disease takes them much heavier,
manifested by chronic intoxication of the human organism with disorders of
homeostasis system, most common by multiple and combined injures [5].
Traditional approaches, used in surgical treatment of
echinococcosis, particularly in children, differs by traumatic duration, often
greatly exceeds the severity of its intervention on the affected organ [1, 4].
In addition, broad sections, which have traditionally resorted to surgery
hydatid disease, no longer meet modern requirements of cosmetics and
miniinvasive surgical interventions.
Aim: To look for improving
methods of the results of surgical treatment of echinococcosis in children.
Materials and methods.
It has been studied the results of surgical treatment
of 315 children with isolated (247) and combined (68), pulmonary echinococcosis
admitted to the Samarkand branch of pediatric surgery of the Republican
specialized scientific-practical center of Pediatrics. Depending on the
particular technology implementation echinococcectomy at different periods of
operation at our clinic, all patients were divided into 3 groups. In Group 1
(1998-2001) it has been included 123 children (39.0%), which antiparasitic
treatment was carried out by 2-5% formalin solution. In group 2 (2002-2005) it
has been included 110 (35.0%) patients with lung echinococcosis cyst treated
with a solution of glycerol at room temperature. In the third group (2006-2010)
it has been included 82 (26.0%) patients who had been used as a germicide
glycerol, heated to 70˚C. In addition, patients in this group, we made extensive use of minimal access surgery, which in some cases
supplemented by fibroendoscopical revision of the cavity of fibrous capsule.
Patients in all three groups were matched by age (table
1). A large part of them (73%) were children of school age.
Table 1
Distribution of the patients due to age
|
Group of patients |
Age of the patients, years old |
In general |
||||||
|
3-7 |
7-12 |
12-15 |
||||||
|
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
|
|
1 (1998-2001) |
26 |
21,1 |
53 |
43,1 |
44 |
35,8 |
123 |
100 |
|
2 (2002-2005) |
35 |
31,8 |
43 |
39,1 |
32 |
29,1 |
110 |
100 |
|
3 (2006-2010) |
24 |
29,3 |
36 |
43,9 |
22 |
26,8 |
82 |
100 |
|
In
general |
85 |
27,0 |
132 |
41,9 |
98 |
31,1 |
315 |
100 |
Taking into consideration the comparability of
patients in groups according to the number of lesions and complicated duration
of disease (Table 2), it should be noted that in children there is a high
frequency of multiple (42.9%) and complicated (51.4%) cysts of the lung.
Table 2
Distribution of the patients
with echinococcosis of lungs depending on the type of the disease
|
Type of injuries |
Group of patients |
In general, n=315 |
||||||
|
1 group,
n=123 |
2 group,
n=110 |
3 group,
n=82 |
||||||
|
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
|
|
Solitar |
91 |
74,0 |
87 |
79,1 |
66 |
80,5 |
180 |
57,1 |
|
Multiple |
32 |
26,0 |
23 |
20,9 |
16 |
19,5 |
135 |
42,9 |
|
Non-complicated
|
56 |
45,5 |
50 |
45,5 |
47 |
57,3 |
153 |
48,6 |
|
Complicated |
67 |
54,5 |
60 |
54,5 |
35 |
42,7 |
162 |
51,4 |
At the same time it should be noted that during the
period of our observations, since 1998 a steady downward trend in the frequency
of multiple and complicated cysts of the lung, which is probably associated
with improved early diagnosis of the disease process in our region.
Bilateral
lesion of echinococcus diagnosed in 39 (12.4%) children, of whom
bilateral-solitary process was occurred in 25 (64.1%) patients, bilateral
plural process - in 4 (10.3%) patients, solitary process on the one side and
multiple process in the other side - in 10 (25.6%) patients. In 68 (21.6%)
patients had lung echinococcosis combined with liver disease and other rare
localizations of echinococcosis.
In the structure of the lung complications of
echinococcosis 90.7% were festering cysts with their subsequent burst in the
bronchus (59.9%), in the pleural cavity (10.5%) or in the bronchus and the
pleural cavity (3.7%) (table 3).
Table 3
Structure of complications
of echinococcal cysts of the lungs
|
Complication |
Group of patients |
In general |
||||||
|
1 group |
2 group |
3 group |
||||||
|
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
|
|
Suppuration
with burst to the bronchus |
39 |
58,2 |
36 |
60,0 |
22 |
62,9 |
97 |
59,9 |
|
Suppuration
of the cysts |
14 |
20,9 |
9 |
15,0 |
4 |
11,4 |
27 |
16,7 |
|
Suppuration
and burst to the pleural cavity |
5 |
7,5 |
6 |
10,0 |
6 |
17,1 |
17 |
10,5 |
|
Suppuration
and burst to the bronchus and to the pleural cavity |
1 |
1,5 |
4 |
6,7 |
1 |
2,9 |
6 |
3,7 |
|
Burst
to the bronchus |
7 |
10,4 |
4 |
6,7 |
2 |
5,7 |
13 |
8,0 |
|
Burst
to the pleural cavity |
1 |
1,5 |
1 |
1,7 |
- |
- |
2 |
1,2 |
|
In
general |
67 |
100,0 |
60 |
100,0 |
35 |
100,0 |
162 |
100,0 |
It is believed that the burst of non-infected cysts is
greater risk in terms of dissemination of the process - such patients were 15
(9.2%).
In the presence of multiple echinococcosis of one lung
removal of all cysts was carried out simultaneously in stages. We followed the
tactics two-moment surgical interventions. In bilateral lung injures in 39
(12.4%) patients surgical treatment of echinococcosis was performed in stages
(Table 4), first on one and then on another lung with a maximum shortening inter-stage
period of 2 to 4 weeks.
Taking into
consideration the well-known shortcomings of the standard surgical approach - a
wide thoracotomy, as well as taking into account the possibility of topical
diagnostics of modern endovizualization, we have worked with in 2002 is widely
used methods of topical minithoracotomy (table 4).
During minithoracotomy under intubation narcosis it was carried out skin
incision no more than 5-6 cm in IV-VII intercostal space, depending on the
topical localization of hydatid cyst between media-clavicular and the posterior
axillary lines on the affected side.
Table 4
Distribution of the patients
with echinococcosis of lungs depending on the surgical access
|
Access |
Group of patients |
In general |
||||||
|
1 group |
2 group |
3 group |
||||||
|
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
|
|
Wide
thoracotomy |
102 |
82,9 |
17 |
15,4 |
2 |
2,4 |
121 |
38,4 |
|
Two-moment
wide thoracotomy on both sides |
21 |
17,1 |
1 |
0,9 |
- |
- |
22 |
7,0 |
|
In
general |
123 |
100 |
18 |
16,3 |
2 |
2,4 |
143 |
45,4 |
|
Minithoracotomy
|
- |
- |
84 |
76,4 |
71 |
86,6 |
155 |
49,2 |
|
Two-moment
minithoracotomy on both sides |
- |
- |
8 |
7,3 |
9 |
11,0 |
17 |
5,4 |
|
In
general |
- |
- |
92 |
83,7 |
80 |
97,6 |
172 |
54,6 |
|
In
general |
123 |
100 |
110 |
100 |
82 |
100 |
315 |
100 |
On the giant cysts that spread to more than one lobe, the
optimal approach was the best available in the VI intercostal space. In cysts
that are located within one upper lobe, the operational access was in the IV or
V intercostal space. Access in the VII intercostal space was carried out with
distal localization of echinococcus cyst. In most cases, preference is given surgical
access in the V-VI intercostal space. Muscle mass was pushed in the blunt
manner, with use electrocoagulator we in the unipolar mode crossed fibers of
intercostal muscles. Pleural cavity were opened, and revealed the echinococcus cyst.
Cyst led up to the wound. Later echinococcectomy did not differ from the
traditional.
Results and discussion.
Already at the stage of development in 2002, our
surgeons at once gave his preference for the new access. The technique is
simple and fast implementation, low blood loss, it is convenient for the
implementation of the basic stages of intervention at the correct preoperative
topic diagnosis, there is much more easily during the postoperative period.
Patients in group 2, in which we started to introduce minithoracotomy, the
proportion of these approaches has reached 83.7% (table 4). In recent years,
almost all children with pulmonary echinococcosis we surgically operated
through minithoracotomic access. Only 2 (2.4%) patients, from the third group
we had to go to the conversion thoracotomic wounds: in one because of multiple
lesions of the lower and upper lobe of right lung, the other due to the
presence of massive adhesions in the pleural cavity, and the need to perform a
full pneumolizis.
In uncirculated adhesive process to mobilize lung can
be successfully carried out through minithoracotomic access by video-assisting.
After videoendosurgical dissection of adhesions it was much easier to injury
echinococcus cysts located in the costal surface of the lung within 7-8 cm from
thoracotomnogominiodissection. Video-endoscopic technique we used on the stage
echinococcectomy in 23 (18.3%) children third group, mainly for additional
endoscopic revision of difficult angles and recesses of deep-lying cysts and
sinuses of the pleural cavity (in patients with burst cyst into the pleural
cavity). During the video-endoscopy in 3 patients were removed during surgery
unnoticed small daughter bubbles. The advantages of this method over
conventional inspection of the inner walls of the fibrous capsule and pleural
sinuses are twenty-fold increase in the image on the TV monitor screen,
expanding the viewing angle from the side of optics, good lighting zone
inspection.
The high frequency of complicated forms of pulmonary
echinococcosis, reaching 51.4%, reflected in the structure of the performed
surgical interventions, where the proportion of semi-closure of the residual
cavity with a fibrous membrane at the bottom of the abandonment of drainage was
42.5% (table 5).
Table 5
The character of the
surgical interventions in echinococcosis of lungs
|
Surgical operation |
Group of patients |
In general |
||||||
|
1 group |
2 group |
3 group |
||||||
|
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
|
|
Ideal
echinoccocectomy |
4 |
3,3 |
2 |
1,8 |
1 |
1,2 |
7 |
2,2 |
|
Closed
echinoccocectomy |
71 |
57,7 |
57 |
51,8 |
46 |
56,1 |
174 |
55,2 |
|
Semi-closed
echinoccocectomy
|
48 |
39,0 |
51 |
46,4 |
35 |
42,7 |
134 |
42,5 |
|
In
general |
123 |
100 |
110 |
100 |
82 |
100 |
315 |
100 |
Note. During removing several cysts in
one patient it was taking into consideration the biggest intervention.
An important technical point in the performance of a
semi-closed echinococcectomy is the imposition of tight pleurorizic sutures. In
all other cases, we tried to completely eliminate bed of parasite by suturing
due to Bobrov Spasokukotsky method that we could perform in 174 (55.2%)
patients. These types of operations can be attributed the ideal
echinococcectomy, implemented in 7 (2.2%) patients, when, after extraction of
the entire chitin shell free edge of the fibrous capsule was excised, and the remainder
of the shell was sutured by the use of one-row interrupted sutures.
In our patients there were not absolute indications
for performing lobectomy and pulmonectomy. In uncomplicated duration the
drainage tube was removed from the pleural cavity after 2-3 days (in general in
3,9 ± 0,07 days) after the x-ray investigation with the full unfolding of the
operated lung (table 6).
Table 6
The results of the complex
surgical treatment of patients with echinococcosis of
lungs
|
Indexes |
Group of patients |
||
|
1 group,
n=123 |
2 group,
n=110 |
3 group,
n=82 |
|
|
Duration
of the hospital staying, bed-days |
21,4±1,16 |
20,4±0,79 |
14,0±0,41 |
|
Duration
of staying in ICU, days. |
4,5±0,15 |
2,42±0,21 |
1,4±0,07 |
|
Duration
of hospital treatment after operation, days. |
17,1±1,04 |
14,4±0,79 |
9,9±0,44 |
|
Duration
of the surgical operation, min |
60,4±1,31 |
47,2±1,93 |
32,0±1,14 |
|
Periods
of normal body temperature, days. |
9,0±0,74 |
5,9±0,69 |
3,7±0,39 |
|
Periods
of removing drainage from pleural cavity, days. |
4,8±0,33 |
3,0±0,31 |
2,9±0,07 |
|
Periods
of removing drainage from residual cavity, days. |
23,0±2,86
(48)* |
15,5±1,18
(51)* |
13,4±0,78
(35)* |
Note. * – number of patients
At the same time we were not in a hurry in removing
the drainage tube of the residual lung cavity: as a rule, they were removed
after on average of two weeks after the operation. This period is necessary for
reliable obliteration of the pleural cavity around intrapulmonary tube and the
residual cavity itself.
The active use
minithoracotomic accesses in the 2-d and 3-rd groups had a positive impact on
the timing of finding the children in the ICU and subsequently in the hospital,
the baby's body temperature normalization (table 6).
In patients of group 3 due to the use and facilitation
techniques minithoracotomy elimination of "complex" residual cavities
by suturing them to the drainage we could halve the duration of the
intervention and thus reduce its invasiveness. That is, in technically complex
situations, we do not try at all costs fully take in the cavity of the fibrous
capsule, exposing the child at risk of intra-and postoperative iatrogenic (due
to damage to blood vessels, respiratory tract suturing, deformation of lung
tissue, increased thoracotomy wounds, etc.). Rapid obliteration of residual
cavity in the drainage tube, we think contributes to the thermal and chemical
effects of glycerol on the hot walls of the fibrous capsule in contact with the
effect of sclerotherapy and the establishment of a permanent negative pressure
inside the cavity due to Bobrow valvular banks. In addition, an effective means
of preventing one of the most common postoperative complications in children -
suppuration of residual cavity is to find the drain pipe inside the fibrous
capsule. It was noted above (table 3) that the initial signs of suppuration
echinococcal cysts were present in 147 (46.7%) patients, and the frequency of
postoperative suppuration of residual cavity during treatment with glycerol at
room temperature (group 2, 2002-2005) and hot-glycerol (third group,
2006-2010), and sufficiently wide (42.5% of patients) of cyst drainage
operations did not exceed 1.8 and 1.2% (table 7).
Table 7
The frequency of
postoperative complications in patients with echinococcosis
of lungs
|
Complication |
Group of patients |
In general, n=315 |
||||||
|
1 group,
n=123 |
2 group,
n=110 |
3 group,
n=82 |
||||||
|
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
abs. |
% |
|
|
Pleuritis |
6 |
4,9 |
2 |
1,8 |
1 |
1,2 |
9 |
2,9 |
|
Suppuration
of the operation wound |
11 |
8,9 |
6 |
5,5 |
1 |
1,2 |
18 |
5,7 |
|
Suppuration
of residual cavity |
8 |
6,5 |
2 |
1,8 |
1 |
1,2 |
11 |
3,5 |
|
Bleeding
|
2 |
1,6 |
— |
— |
— |
— |
2 |
0,6 |
|
In
general |
27 |
21,9 |
10 |
9,1 |
3 |
3,6 |
40 |
12,7 |
Note. In the presence of in one patient 2 and more complications it was
taken into consideration the most severe complication.
The set of technical and tactical decisions aimed at
reducing trauma intervention, taking advantage of videoendosurgery, non-closure
of the basal lung zones contributed to the prevention of postoperative
intrapleural reliable bleeding - since 2002 we have these complications were
not observed. Occur very rarely have pleurisy and postoperative wound
infections, the overall incidence of postoperative complications was reduced
from 21.9 to 3.6%.
Conclusion
The improvement of surgical treatment of
echinococcosis of lungs, the wide use minithoracotomic approaches,
opportunities video-assisting interventions, treatment of echinococcal cysts
cavity by hot glycerol, individual approach to the closure of the residual
cavity contribute to reducing the number of postoperative complications in 7
times (from 21.9 to 3.6%) and timing hospital treatment after surgical
operation almost in half.
References
1. Gumerov À.À., Tkachenko Ò.N., Shangareeva R.Kh. The complex treatment of echinococcosis in
children. Surgery. - 2010. - ¹1. – P. 25-29.
2. Ikramov À.I. The complex radial diagnostic and choose the method of surgical
treatment of echinococcosis of the lungs and liver: Doctoral dissertation. Tashkent,
2002. – 33 p.
3. Ikhamov F.À. The improvement of traditional and elaboration of the new methods of
surgical treatment of echinococcosis of the liver: Doctoral dissertation. – Tashkent,
2005. – 42 p.
4. Mamleev I.À., Gumerov À.À., Ishimov Sh.S. Diagnostic and surgical treatment of echinococcosis of
the lungs in children // Pediatric surgery. - 2006. - ¹ 4. - P. 5-9.
5. Pulatov À.Ò. Echinococcosis in the childhood. – Ì.: Medicine, 2004. – 224
p.
6. Sahin E., Kaptanoglu M., Nadir A., Ceran C. Traumatic rupture of a
pulmonary hydatid cyst: a case report. UlusTravmaAcilCerrahiDerg. – 2006. –
Vol. 12, ¹1. – Ð. 71-5.
7. Zampoli M., Zar H. Conservative management of a ruptured pulmonary hydatid
cyst // PediatrPulmonol. – 2007. - Vol.1, ¹12. – Ð.
1229-32.
Ïî÷òîâûé àäðåñ:
Ðåñïóáëèêà Óçáåêèñòàí, ã. Òàøêåíò, 100109 Àëìàçàðñêèé ðàéîí, ìàññèâ ÒàøÃîñÌÈ,
äîì 26, êâ.33. e-mail evovision@bk.ru