Orakova Akerke Orakovna
Eurasian National
University named after L.N.Gumilev
Zoo metaphors in different cultures.
The giraffe’s neck, the tiger’s sharp claws, and the skink lizard’s
ability to drop off its tail give these animals successful survival advantages.
When we hear the fable “The Boy Who Cried Wolf” we learn, without having
it spelled out to us, that nobody believes liars even when they tell the truth.
We understand the lesson better than if it had been spelled out to us, because
we feel the boy’s pain and fear inviting his fate. We associate his fate with
what could happen to us if we followed his bad habit of repeatedly raising
false alarms.
Comparing a human
being to an animal has old traditions in many cultures. The origin of these zoo
metaphors can be found in folk mythology and religion, where an animal is
represented as having intellectual and spiritual human properties or as having
supernatural powers.
Gods,
animals, and certain creatures which have elements of both human and animal are
main characters in mythological and folkloristic tales and play a major role in
the development of the behavior of the human being. Certain cultural beliefs of
animals also influence the behavior of a human being as well as how one or
another animal is seen in certain cultures. All of these aspects contribute
greatly to the behavior of the human being not only culture-specifically, but
also universally.
The
bee is
one of the few insects which plays a major role in many cultures. It is
believed to be a sacred insect and considered to be the bridge between the
natural world and the underworld.
Some
archaic Greek cities, such as Hyrai (hyron meant “swarm of bees” in
Cretan), incorporate the name of the bee
in their names.
Austerja, the goddess of bees, and Bubilas, the god of bees,
both are deeply rooted in Lithuanian mythology. People sacrificed grasslands
for Austerja and honey for Bubilas
believing that it will make bees swarm better.
Dogs play a significant role in many cultures. The dog is also one of the twelve animals honored in Chinese
astrology and is believed to be the most loyal animal to the human being. In
the Christian religion Jesus told the story of the poor man named Lazarus,
whose sores were licked by street dogs.
Most
Muslims do not keep pet dogs because of the belief that they are unclean. This
comes from several traditions concerning Muhammad’s attitude towards dogs.
In
some cultures, the fox appears as an animal possessed with magic
powers, or as
a
symbol of cunning and trickery in folklore.
In
European culture, the fox is
often associated with transformation, i.e., tales of fox transformation into
humans and vice versa, as well as stories about anthropomorphic animals imbued
with human characteristics. Some of the first images of the fox in literature are pictured
around 6 BC in Aesop's fables, such as The Fox and the Grapes.
Pigs are a frequent source of reference in many cultures and carry more than
one characteristic. Most of the time, pigs are seen as unclean, rude,
clumsy and lazy animals. In non-pork-eating religions, such as Judaism and
Islam, pigs are treated as inedible animals and carry the concept of treift
(food that is not in accord with Jewish law) and haram (unlawful
food according to the book of Islam). In pork-eating cultures, the pig is
seen from a more benign perspective. Greek mythology includes Demeter, among
other gods and goddesses, as the goddess of pigs. Ancient Romans
sacrificed a pig, together with a ram and a bull, which was one of the
most celebratory acts of the Roman religion (ibid). The Celts had
Moccus,
the god of swine, who later, under Roman occupation, was identified with
Mercury. One of the attributes of The Dagda, a god in Irish mythology, is the
cauldron with cooked pork .
The
metaphor has been used since ancient times and in the present research it is
taken as a broad term which covers many figures of speech. Metaphor is the
application of a strange term either transferred from the genus and applied to
the species or from the species and applied to the genus, or from
one
species to another or else by analogy.
The
contemporary view suggests that the metaphor is a property of concepts and not
of words, that the function of metaphor is to better understand certain
concepts, and that the metaphor is not necessarily used for esthetic and
artistic purposes. Lakoff and Johnson
also suggest that the metaphor is often not based on similarity. Their statement
is that metaphor is not a linguistic ornament, but rather an inevitable process
of human thought and reasoning. New metaphors can be created every day by
anybody.
The
importance of figurative language plays a major role in any kind of literary or
linguistic
work. Each word has a literal meaning, but it can also mean something other
than the literal meaning suggests. A woman denotes a female person, but bitch,
vixen, fox, and cat can also denote a female person, adding more
specific reference to the meaning.
Figurative
language allows stretching the meanings of the word as well as giving meaning
to expressions, which when handled in their literal meaning have no significant
sense. For example in English, to play the bear has little or no sense
in its literal meaning. It does not mean that somebody is living like the bear,
hibernating, hunting, reproducing.
The
term zoo metaphor will refer to
metaphors in which the behavior, emotion or appearance of an animal is a
reference to the behavior, emotion or appearance of the human.
The zoo metaphor is a linguistic device in
which a word or phrase literally denotes a kind of object or idea used
figuratively for something else, as a way of suggesting likeness or analogy
between them.
When a
human being is compared to an animal, it is usually their less attractive
qualities that are highlighted by the comparison. Out of all domestic cattle,
it is only the bull that has a positive connotation: healthy as a bull,
you could say of a man of robust health. At the same time, if a woman is
compared to a cow, the only simile is fat as a cow.
Horses symbolize hard work, and it is often said of workaholics that they
are plowing like a horse. Intriguingly, a technical word that is used to
describe gray horses forms part of expressions to “lie like a gray
gelding,” meaning to say blatant lies, and “ravings of a gray mare,”
meaning utter nonsense.
The main characters in Russian folk tales are
the wolf, the fox, the hare and the bear. The traits they personify in those
tales have given birth to the following expressions: hungry as a wolf;
crafty like a fox; and cowardly like a hare. Interestingly, fare-dodgers on
public transport are popularly known as hares.
As for the bear, that is in real life is a dangerous predator, in Russian
folk tales, he is usually represented as a clumsy but goodhearted creature. A
case in point is the mascot of the 1980 Moscow Olympic Games, Misha the bear.
At the same time, a large and clumsy person is more likely to be compared to an
elephant, as in the phrase “like an elephant in a china shop.”
Another creature of the animal world that is associated with industry and
hard work is the ant, thanks to a classical fable by Ivan Krylov, in which
it is juxtaposed with a careless dragonfly. Interestingly, the bee, whose
stings could be quite dangerous for humans, has positive connotations as in the
phrase “to work like a bee,” while quite harmless flies get a bad
name, as in the phase “importunate like a fly.”
Comparisons to birds usually have positive connotations: to sing like
a nightingale; slender like a swan; wise as an owl; quick as a sparrow; and
proud as an eagle. At the same time, some birds are associated with negative
traits: “fierce like a vulture” you could say of an aggressive and angry
man; she is “prattling like a magpie” you could say of a particularly
talkative woman; while a mother who does not take good care of her children is
sometimes called a cuckoo. A person who takes his or her time when doing
anything is compared to a tortoise, while somebody who can run very fast
is sometimes compared to a swift-footed deer.
The world of fish offers
numerous linguistic comparisons too: to be “silent like a fish”; to feel
like “fish in water”; like a “fish beating against the ice,” meaning to
struggle desperately. An ironic pun – to be silent like a fish against the
ice – means to keep mum, even though you may be desperate.
Zoo metaphors are often used to characterize
leadership styles. For example lion means aggression, command, control and
eagle means great instinct and strategy.
Zoo metaphor is a
powerful tool to stimulate conversations about behaviour and behavioural
differences and interactions. Reflective conversations stimulated using animals
metaphor can work well across cultures provided the facilitator is sensitive to
different cultural perceptions and interpretations.